Live data from Hacker News

Google Brain Toronto

canada.googleblog.com

21–30 of 71 posts

Re: Google Brain Toronto

#21
post #5

Ouch, sorry Waterloo.

Right? This is an odd choice. Google just built their massive new campus in Waterloo, and University of Waterloo is one of the best engineer schools and computer science schools in the world, but they build this an hour away in a market that is much more expensive? An odd choice for sure.

Waterloo is good at churning out entry-level software engineers. UofT is much stronger for ML and research in general.

Re: Google Brain Toronto

#22
post #13

Canada will benefit from the brain wall Trump has erected.

Those jobs would have been shipped to India eventually anyway. Global corporations don't care about silly things like stable economies. They care about the bottom line. Edit: to those downvoting me, can you please explain why? Am I wrong in some way?

India doesn't have top universities and top research talent.

Re: Google Brain Toronto

#24
1. What is the Vector Institute? Is a foundation? Is it a not-for-profit corporation? Something else?

2. Who controls it? The government (which has put in most of the announced funding)? The University of Toronto? Google? A combination of all of those?

3. Who will own the work created by the Institute? How will it be licensed, and what rules will govern its publication?

These are questions that would be answered at a very early stage of an ordinary research partnership between a public university and a corporation, but I can find none of these details about Vector.

Re: Google Brain Toronto

#25
post #6

I am seeing a lot of investments and MASSIVE promised commitments by a lot of people/company. Is all this money going towards paying experts/ buying equipments ? Don't get me wrong, I like seeing all this money being poured in. It's just that i'm curious as to how this money is being used. Tangentially, do you think any of this will trickle down to people who are trying to learn math/ML in the form of scholarships?

I agree. It has all been quite vague. I wonder if any will go towards AI based startups.

Well, I know ycombinator is doing it.[0]

https://blog.ycombinator.com/yc-ai/

Re: Google Brain Toronto

#26
post #5

Ouch, sorry Waterloo.

Right? This is an odd choice. Google just built their massive new campus in Waterloo, and University of Waterloo is one of the best engineer schools and computer science schools in the world, but they build this an hour away in a market that is much more expensive? An odd choice for sure.

From the perspective of someone who's lived in both cities, it makes perfect sense. Toronto is a much much nicer place to live and it'll be way easier to attract talent to it. I wouldn't move back to Waterloo for any amount of money.

Re: Google Brain Toronto

#27
post #13

Canada will benefit from the brain wall Trump has erected.

Those jobs would have been shipped to India eventually anyway. Global corporations don't care about silly things like stable economies. They care about the bottom line. Edit: to those downvoting me, can you please explain why? Am I wrong in some way?

Just speculating, but positions in AI are usually filled by people with PhD's and this knowledge is so scarce in the job market, not low level IT pros who are competing in a race to the bottom

Re: Google Brain Toronto

#28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Those jobs would have been shipped to India eventually anyway. Global corporations don't care about silly things like stable economies. They care about the bottom line. Edit: to those downvoting me, can you please explain why? Am I wrong in some way?

India doesn't have top universities and top research talent.

Maybe not now, but I assure you there many smart people trying to build the infrastructure and plenty of smart talent that could be utilized.

Re: Google Brain Toronto

#29

1. What is the Vector Institute? Is a foundation? Is it a not-for-profit corporation? Something else? 2. Who controls it? The government (which has put in most of the announced funding)? The University of Toronto? Google? A combination of all of those? 3. Who will own the work created by the Institute? How will it be licensed, and what rules will govern its publication? These are questions that would be answered at a…

Also, this is meant to retain talents in Canada rather than coming to USA to work for companies like Google. By working for Google in Canada? Doesn't having "Google Brain" in Canada imply people are working for Google but it's one based in Canada now?

Re: Google Brain Toronto

#30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Those jobs would have been shipped to India eventually anyway. Global corporations don't care about silly things like stable economies. They care about the bottom line. Edit: to those downvoting me, can you please explain why? Am I wrong in some way?

Just speculating, but positions in AI are usually filled by people with PhD's and this knowledge is so scarce in the job market, not low level IT pros who are competing in a race to the bottom

What keeps other countries like India from developing PhD's like that? It seems like they would have a strong incentive to do so.
Post reply on HN