Live data from Hacker News

DDR5 memory is on its way, twice as fast as DDR4

pcworld.com

1–10 of 74 posts

Re: DDR5 memory is on its way, twice as fast as DDR4

#5
Would the equivalent amount of DDR5 actually feel any different to DDR4 to the end user? It seems like hardware is getting better but basic software (web browser etc) is getting more complicated/bloated at the same rate, so things don't actually feel 10x faster than they did a few years ago.

Re: DDR5 memory is on its way, twice as fast as DDR4

#6
So, it's been a while since I tinkered with hardware, but I'm making the blind assumption that although the bus speed is twice as fast as DDR4, there is also twice the read latency, as has always been the case with DDR memory, meaning the net read latency improvement is basically nil.

Of course we expect every generation of Double Data Rate memory to double the data rate. But it's always been a bit misleading to say "twice as fast".

Re: DDR5 memory is on its way, twice as fast as DDR4

#8

Would the equivalent amount of DDR5 actually feel any different to DDR4 to the end user? It seems like hardware is getting better but basic software (web browser etc) is getting more complicated/bloated at the same rate, so things don't actually feel 10x faster than they did a few years ago.

Really? Go back and install Windows 7, then Windows XP, then Windows 98. Tell me the boot times and how long until a browser opens. :D

I think our expectations are just getting higher.

Re: DDR5 memory is on its way, twice as fast as DDR4

#9

So, it's been a while since I tinkered with hardware, but I'm making the blind assumption that although the bus speed is twice as fast as DDR4, there is also twice the read latency, as has always been the case with DDR memory, meaning the net read latency improvement is basically nil. Of course we expect every generation of Double Data Rate memory to double the data rate. But it's always been a bit misleading to say…

Yes, I always considered that inflated bus speeds a scam. It is like having a subway line driving trains every 2 minutes, but only 1 train in 15 taking passengers, rest going completely empty.

If you look at CAS latencies [1] then it's clear that memory speeds stagnated a long time ago:

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CAS_latency

Post reply on HN