Live data from Hacker News

New male contraceptive may be submitted for Indian approval this year

bloomberg.com

11–20 of 331 posts

Re: New male contraceptive may be submitted for Indian approval this year

#11

It's definitely too popular to blame everything on middle-aged white guys. It's sad that even bloomberg is jumping on the bandwagon.

It doesn't even make sense. Women have the possibility to abort a pregnancy while men have no say whatsoever (in regions where the big pharma companies are coming from). So the argument that women would do more for male birth control is somewhat strange considering they have all the power in their hands right now.

Re: New male contraceptive may be submitted for Indian approval this year

#13

I thought it was going to be a pill, we already have vasectomies.

This isn't a vasectomy...it's a gel injected into the vas deferens which does not block the flow of sperm, but reacts with the negative charge of the sperm to render them infertile. The gel may also removed with another quick injection to flush.

Re: New male contraceptive may be submitted for Indian approval this year

#14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are you sure you are commenting on the correct article?

Yes - from the article: "The fact that the big companies are run by white, middle-aged males who have the same feeling—that they would never do it—plays a major role"

this seems like yet another bash at the white male, but if you think of it there's already vasectomies and if you're rich you'll have a few children followed by a vasectomy. this is for the poorer individual that doesn't want the burden but might want to reverse it, which is more appealing to the non-rich-guy. and maybe in india* you can still be seen a virile as it's reversible. *i don't know about indian culture.

Re: New male contraceptive may be submitted for Indian approval this year

#15

I thought it was going to be a pill, we already have vasectomies.

But this is an easily reversible vasectomy, with an even less invasive initial procedure (a couple of injections rather than a keyhole surgery).

Men don't generally get vasectomies until they (think they) are done having children. This would be a reasonable procedure to have when you are young, have it reversed when you are settled and want to have kids, then have re-done (or get a vasectomy) when you're done.

Re: New male contraceptive may be submitted for Indian approval this year

#16

It's definitely too popular to blame everything on middle-aged white guys. It's sad that even bloomberg is jumping on the bandwagon.

I can understand how executives being male may impact decisions to pursue male contraceptives but the white part is really irrelevant and unnecessary

Re: New male contraceptive may be submitted for Indian approval this year

#17
post #3

There's Parmesus Vasalgel that is going through trials in the US, based on this tech. Also, a startup whose name I forget is developing the same kind of tech. They were part of YC Fellowship Batch 3.

The article mentions this, although it's not quite clear to me how they differ (and by how much).

Parsemus apparently got started by licensing the technology from Guha, then developed its own solution inspired by that technology.

Re: New male contraceptive may be submitted for Indian approval this year

#18
post #3

There's Parmesus Vasalgel that is going through trials in the US, based on this tech. Also, a startup whose name I forget is developing the same kind of tech. They were part of YC Fellowship Batch 3.

>Also, a startup whose name I forget is developing the same kind of tech. They were part of YC Fellowship Batch 3.

Contraline: http://contraline.com

Re: New male contraceptive may be submitted for Indian approval this year

#19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes - from the article: "The fact that the big companies are run by white, middle-aged males who have the same feeling—that they would never do it—plays a major role"

this seems like yet another bash at the white male, but if you think of it there's already vasectomies and if you're rich you'll have a few children followed by a vasectomy. this is for the poorer individual that doesn't want the burden but might want to reverse it, which is more appealing to the non-rich-guy. and maybe in india* you can still be seen a virile as it's reversible. *i don't know about indian culture.

I don't know, the assertion in the article makes little sense. The white part shouldn't play any role at all in this; easily reversible male contraception has been a dream of many for a long time. These companies want to maximize profits, and it's obvious that they aren't limiting their products and procedures to what they as middle-aged men would want. If they were, there'd be no products or procedures for women.

I think it's far more likely that these companies don't want to fund trials as it won't be nearly as profitable to them as current contraceptive options. If this was a pill instead, I have no doubt that the companies would champ at the bit for it. I think it's not coincidence that they could only find a non-profit to fund the trials for this specific product/procedure.

Re: New male contraceptive may be submitted for Indian approval this year

#20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

this seems like yet another bash at the white male, but if you think of it there's already vasectomies and if you're rich you'll have a few children followed by a vasectomy. this is for the poorer individual that doesn't want the burden but might want to reverse it, which is more appealing to the non-rich-guy. and maybe in india* you can still be seen a virile as it's reversible. *i don't know about indian culture.

I don't know, the assertion in the article makes little sense. The white part shouldn't play any role at all in this; easily reversible male contraception has been a dream of many for a long time. These companies want to maximize profits, and it's obvious that they aren't limiting their products and procedures to what they as middle-aged men would want. If they were, there'd be no products or procedures for women. I…

yes, i think whiteness is purely incidental. it's just another not-all-statement.
Post reply on HN