Live data from Hacker News

AMA with YC Partner Aaron Harris on Applying to YC – S17 Deadline Is Tonight

news.ycombinator.com

51–60 of 92 posts

Re: AMA with YC Partner Aaron Harris on Applying to YC – S17 Deadline Is Tonight

#51
post #21

If you've applied early, will the (updated) application be checked again after the deadline, or are the chances that it's been looked at already and already evaluated?

We only read applications that have been fully submitted.

If one has submitted early (by clicking on the button by accident), could it be that enough reviewers already looked over the application and evaluated it already before the official deadline?

Re: AMA with YC Partner Aaron Harris on Applying to YC – S17 Deadline Is Tonight

#52
post #19

What's the best stage of startup for applying to YC - when you have a product in mind and still chalking out the plan, working on Product Market Fit (not building it yet)? when you have a working prototype? when you already have some traction? any of above?

Let me phrase this question in a slightly different way:

At what stage would a company like Dropbox (or any other successful YC graduate) benefit the most from going through the YC program?

(And I realize this varies depending on the industry or the founders' backgrounds)

Re: AMA with YC Partner Aaron Harris on Applying to YC – S17 Deadline Is Tonight

#53
post #37
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Similar to talking VC, there is no guarantee. But unless you have a truley secret sauce going on, ideas by themselves rarely matter. People have a tendency to overestimate ideas. They are remarkable easy to come up with. I have been in brainstorming session, where we would come up with at least 10-12 really good ideas within an hour. Usually it is execution that matters at the end, as you don't know what it works or…

I agree with the premise that ideas themselves are worthless. But what's questionable is whether YC acts in favour of the new applicants that share their insights honestly, or whether they are more prone to protect their investment in the already funded startup (by providing them with details/intel).

I agree that execution is everything, but when people say "ideas are worthless" -- I just have to assume they've never had a good idea.

Re: AMA with YC Partner Aaron Harris on Applying to YC – S17 Deadline Is Tonight

#54
Hi Aaron, as mentioned in the YC video tips about volume I wanted to share with everyone that today after a friend watched my video he complained about low volume even though it was fine on my machine. I wanted to let applicants know that there is an adjustment in the edit section of youtube as seen here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dvxTWXVMikg

Which I am doing now haha. although i think it does change the link to an unregistered video so you may have to edit your application.

Re: AMA with YC Partner Aaron Harris on Applying to YC – S17 Deadline Is Tonight

#55
post #48

For the question "What will your company make?" do you recommend that startups focus on explaining what they've already built, or on what they will build out in the future? Thanks!

Depends how far along you are. Feel free to describe both.

Re: AMA with YC Partner Aaron Harris on Applying to YC – S17 Deadline Is Tonight

#56

This may not be something you can answer, but I'm curious as to the scoring methodology and how teams get invited to interviews (or not) behind the scenes. Is there a rating system? A binary yes/no that needs to be seconded by enough reviewers?

There is a rating system. It works in two tiers. The first set of grades is given by a set of alum reviewers. That puts anywhere from 3-10 votes on an application.

The ones with enough passing votes then get reviewed by partners. We then vote on every application between 2-5 times, and stack rank the results. We invite the top ~450 to interviews.

Re: AMA with YC Partner Aaron Harris on Applying to YC – S17 Deadline Is Tonight

#57

Hi Aaron, I'm about to submit our application for cosum, a mobile marketplace that lets people use coworking spaces worldwide on demand per hour instead of months. So basically we're changing the unit from a month to an hour (AWS > Server > Minute) so people pay their actual usage. We lower the price for consumers, increase their flexibility and increase the revenue of spaces by using their resources smarter. I intro…

Just describe what you're doing and how your team is split as you do here. I'd also want to know what the milestones are, and what that means in terms of pay and equity for the team members.

Re: AMA with YC Partner Aaron Harris on Applying to YC – S17 Deadline Is Tonight

#58
post #41

Hi again Aaron, can you tell us the proportion of YC-funded company that had at least 1 referral from other founders / yc partners? If you cannot state a number can you at least qualitatively tell us whether having a referral is a huge boost or a slight advantage?

I wouldn't think too much about it. While I look at referrals when they exist, they don't change my mind one way or the other. The rest of the application is way more important.

Re: AMA with YC Partner Aaron Harris on Applying to YC – S17 Deadline Is Tonight

#59
We built both iOS and web apps. Both require login currently and the iOS app is farther along and more interactive as that is how we capture images. How do we get you guys the login info we made you? Or would we be better off sending a demo video showing both working in concert?
Post reply on HN