Live data from Hacker News

So I have built something that already exists...now what?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 31 posts

Re: So I have built something that already exists...now what?

#11
Drop it.

Or rather evaluate how long it would take you to catch up with them (in their existing state) including the hardware part - acquiring it, stocking, selling, supporting, etc - and then see if you are willing to do that knowing that you will also need to out-market them. Then sit down and think about it. Realistically you are too late and you are too few. Think about it a bit more and then drop it.

Re: So I have built something that already exists...now what?

#12
> So this is actually cross posted from r/startups at reddit. I trust you guys more than the hive mind on this one.

I am confused. Your reddit post[1] had some really good suggestions and advice. What makes you think HN is less hive mind-ish than most other places? And what does hive-mind has to do with the topic?

I just think that point was in bad form. There are good and bad points of reddit community (just like any other online community), this example is not one of them.

[1] http://www.reddit.com/r/startups/comments/c9q1x/so_i_have_bu...

Re: So I have built something that already exists...now what?

#14
Read Rework of Jason Fried and Heinemeir Hansson. This Will mots probably change your perspective on this situation. Getting real of 37signals too. One of the unexpected advise is to underdo your competitors. Another one is to art a business not a stratus. Etc.

Re: So I have built something that already exists...now what?

#15
Read Rework of Jason Fried and Heinemeir Hansson. This Will mots probably change your perspective on this situation. Getting real of 37signals too. One of the unexpected advise is to underdo your competitors. Another one is to start a business not a stratus. Etc.

Re: So I have built something that already exists...now what?

#16
".....has complete feature parity with another company's product! In fact, not only does it have complete feature parity but the other company's product has all the features that I wanted to implement."

Eh? So when you say "parity" you actually mean they've got heaps of features that you don't?

My advice would be to look at the niche that they're trying to serve and attack it from another angle. They're a "everyone can use it to get paid" company, maybe you should focus even more specfically on shopkeepers or tradesmen?

Re: So I have built something that already exists...now what?

#18
Unless you already have the partnerships with the credit card processors and the capital to protect yourself from fraud (90% of the work) - I would release the design as open source and make it compatible with Square.

This will at least let hundreds of people build their own readers, and potentially educate most of them in magnetic stripe encoding.

Alternatively/Additionally the Square reader is miles away from ergonomic and by having another design out there you can make a small profit by selling more reliable readers.

Re: So I have built something that already exists...now what?

#19
I would be really worried if there was no other company in the world that was working on solving the problem that you also working on. Competition is good, it validates the market etc.

The real question is not "some one else is working on this, should I quit?" To me, the real question is "someone else is working on it, the problem is real and there is market demand - am I ready to do whatever it takes, for however long it takes, to make this company successful?"

Post reply on HN