Live data from Hacker News

Everyone loves Bernie Sanders. Except, it seems, the Democratic party

theguardian.com

51–60 of 109 posts

Re: Everyone loves Bernie Sanders. Except, it seems, the Democratic party

#51
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It was not blatantly obvious. I voted for Bernie in the primaries, but let's be clear. Clinton won the primaries by millions of votes. If more states had primaries instead of caucuses Clinton would have won even more states.

It was blatantly obvious. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-politics/wp/2016/07... http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/wikileaks-emails-show-dn...

How does that square with the millions more votes Hillary won?

It is really bizarre. She's said to be an awful politician, yet won the popular vote in '08, and in '16 during the primaries and general.

Re: Everyone loves Bernie Sanders. Except, it seems, the Democratic party

#52
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think people had faith that these issues were actually what the Dems wanted to go after if they'd have won. Many of these only became talking points for the establishment once it became apparent that Bernie was a threat to them. It's definitely fair to say a large share of Trump voters went with their emotions as you said, but I think a lot of folks didn't believe Hillary would enact a progressive policy. If…

> Many of these only became talking points for the establishment once it became apparent that Bernie was a threat to them. Those are issues that Obama ran on twice... >but I think a lot of folks didn't believe Hillary would enact a progressive policy. Did they not realize the alternative?

> Those are issues that Obama ran on twice...

And then completely failed to enact or really even push (outside of ACA which I acknowledge as an improvement).

> Did they not realize the alternative?

They sure liked her in primary season despite plenty of evidence she was weaker against Trump.

Re: Everyone loves Bernie Sanders. Except, it seems, the Democratic party

#53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"compelling message for the working class" They have a compelling message for the working class. It's a message of contempt and hate. The long marriage of the working class and Democrats has ended and it wasn't the working class that walked out the door. The Democrats are down to the comfortable professional class preening its "values" and a coalition of grievance groups. Everyone else is on the other side pulling ba…

I don't see the Republican Party championing anything for the working class but death. http://www.nationalreview.com/corner/432796/working-class-wh...

how about bringing back manufacturing jobs for a start? how about deregulation so employers can hire more people? how about lowering taxes? how about enforcing legal immigration so that working class people stand a chance of getting a job?

Re: Everyone loves Bernie Sanders. Except, it seems, the Democratic party

#54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It was blatantly obvious. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-politics/wp/2016/07... http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/wikileaks-emails-show-dn...

How does that square with the millions more votes Hillary won? It is really bizarre. She's said to be an awful politician, yet won the popular vote in '08, and in '16 during the primaries and general.

The DNC excluded independent voters in several states during primaries, independent voters they needed to win the general.

The voters she won in the primary were not the voters she needed to win. Oops.

EDIT: @akhilcacharya: Why expect independents to vote for your candidate if the party doesn't give them a say in the nominee? You want your cake and eating it too, and hence, you lose.

Re: Everyone loves Bernie Sanders. Except, it seems, the Democratic party

#55

I respect Bernie, and really admire his class and honestly. However I don't agreee with his economic and political ideology. A "hand-out" government would be near disasterious for America. It goes against one of the core principles of being American, the ability and optimism to work your way up without limits. To start a company that can be successful at home and abroad without excess regulation, red-tape, and buracr…

"the ability and optimism to work your way up without limits" is absolutely the classic American ideal, but it requires that everyone is given half a chance. If you're too poor to go to college, or can't access treatment for a debilitating illness, or subjected to racist/homophobic/whatever discrimination, you've already lost out on the American dream. Compare the "basic resources required to start working your way u…

yeah, life isn't fair and never will be. deal with it.

Re: Everyone loves Bernie Sanders. Except, it seems, the Democratic party

#56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't see the Republican Party championing anything for the working class but death. http://www.nationalreview.com/corner/432796/working-class-wh...

how about bringing back manufacturing jobs for a start? how about deregulation so employers can hire more people? how about lowering taxes? how about enforcing legal immigration so that working class people stand a chance of getting a job?

[deleted]

Re: Everyone loves Bernie Sanders. Except, it seems, the Democratic party

#57
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> the ability and optimism to work your way up without limits Kind of like Trump did? Or the current generation of Walton family? Anyway, I thought this was short and to the point on this subject: https://brightside.me/article/what-you-should-think-about-be...

Larry Ellison was born in Brooklyn, NY to a single mother, Ellison was raised by his aunt and uncle in Chicago who were quite poor. Howard Schultz (Starbucks CEO), Sean John, Oprah Winfey, Jay-Z, do you want me to continue naming people who come from hard positions with little to no money and the inner-city and made it on a grand scale?

> do you want me to continue naming people who come from hard positions with little to no money and the inner-city and made it on a grand scale?

Yes, please continue. I'd like a large enough sample to dig into.

Re: Everyone loves Bernie Sanders. Except, it seems, the Democratic party

#58
post #2

I am telling my Democratic friends that instead of whining about the popular vote or talking about resisting Trump in general the Democrats should develop a spine and actually stand for something. If they had had a compelling message for the working class they could easily have won this election.

"compelling message for the working class" They have a compelling message for the working class. It's a message of contempt and hate. The long marriage of the working class and Democrats has ended and it wasn't the working class that walked out the door. The Democrats are down to the comfortable professional class preening its "values" and a coalition of grievance groups. Everyone else is on the other side pulling ba…

That is the correct analysis in my view. There was, in fact, an explicit policy decision in the 1970s to realign the Democratic party with the professional class. The party now stands for doctors and lawyers and tax analysts, and the like, well-heeled professionals of all stripes. Basically the 5%. Their ideology is now firmly neo-liberalism, meaning free market liberalism welded to shallow, cynical identity politics, exemplified by Cory Booker and his slimy collaboration with the nutcase Betsy DeVos. Hell, it's looking more and more likely a corporate stalking horse like Booker will end up being the 2020 presidential candidate. Iron law of institutions. It's so depressing.

Re: Everyone loves Bernie Sanders. Except, it seems, the Democratic party

#59
post #57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Larry Ellison was born in Brooklyn, NY to a single mother, Ellison was raised by his aunt and uncle in Chicago who were quite poor. Howard Schultz (Starbucks CEO), Sean John, Oprah Winfey, Jay-Z, do you want me to continue naming people who come from hard positions with little to no money and the inner-city and made it on a grand scale?

> do you want me to continue naming people who come from hard positions with little to no money and the inner-city and made it on a grand scale? Yes, please continue. I'd like a large enough sample to dig into.

Google, or go talk to successful CEOs. You will be surprised how many come from hard backgrounds, difficult early lives, and financial hardship.

Re: Everyone loves Bernie Sanders. Except, it seems, the Democratic party

#60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't see the Republican Party championing anything for the working class but death. http://www.nationalreview.com/corner/432796/working-class-wh...

how about bringing back manufacturing jobs for a start? how about deregulation so employers can hire more people? how about lowering taxes? how about enforcing legal immigration so that working class people stand a chance of getting a job?

> how about bringing back manufacturing jobs for a start?

This isn't going to happen, at least not anytime soon, though there are attempts to try[0]. America doesn't have the infrastructure to bring back manufacturing things like the iPhone[1].

> how about deregulation so employers can hire more people?

Deregulation of what exactly? What's the regulation that's prohibiting "hiring more people"?

> how about lowering taxes?

On who/what? Citizens? Corporations? What's fair? How do you increase military spending, then, if you lower taxes and are already slashing other budgets? [2]

> how about enforcing legal immigration so that working class people stand a chance of getting a job?

Can you provide examples of un-enforcement? As I understand it, most illegal immigration comes from people who immigrate legally on a green card that expires and just don't leave.[3]

[0] https://www.macrumors.com/2016/11/17/made-in-america-iphones...

[1] http://www.heraldtribune.com/news/20120123/apples-jobs-to-ob... (There are better sources out there)

[2] http://www.npr.org/2017/03/16/520305293/trump-to-unveil-hard...

[3] http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2016/02/03/homeland-sec...

Post reply on HN