Live data from Hacker News

A World Without Wi-Fi Looks Possible as Unlimited Plans Rise

bloomberg.com

51–56 of 56 posts

Re: A World Without Wi-Fi Looks Possible as Unlimited Plans Rise

#51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

One of these things: https://www.vodafone.co.uk/shop/accessories/sure-signal/

One of these things : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Femtocell Not a signal booster.

Yes, I know how it works and that its not literally boosting the existing signal but that's what the chap in the Vodafone shop called it and it does rather make things easier to explain to people who aren't bothered by technical trivia.

Re: A World Without Wi-Fi Looks Possible as Unlimited Plans Rise

#52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

One of these things : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Femtocell Not a signal booster.

Yes, I know how it works and that its not literally boosting the existing signal but that's what the chap in the Vodafone shop called it and it does rather make things easier to explain to people who aren't bothered by technical trivia.

On HN

Re: A World Without Wi-Fi Looks Possible as Unlimited Plans Rise

#53

Just because these unlimited plans are being offered doesn't mean they'll take off. The economics might work well for single people, but if you're a family of five, how many phones and unlimited plans are you willing to get? $500 can get you a good desktop that'll last for 5-10 years, that same amount gets you a mid-to-high range phone that will maybe last for four years. Plenty of places still don't get a good signa…

I have a family plan on T-Mobile. Unlimited data, 14Gb tethering per line, of course unlimited voice, text and I get unlimited data in other countries. I went to Mexico last year and got 3G speeds. I pay $200 a month for 5 lines. It will be 6 soon since they are running a get free line promotion.

Easy with that free line promotion. I got two free lines for Black Friday (4->6 lines) and my billing still hasn't been correct since then (being charged $20/month for each of my "free" lines). I had to escalate to John Legere's office, and it still isn't fixed ("next billing cycle we promise").

Otherwise, have been a happy T-Mobile customer for 16 years.

Re: A World Without Wi-Fi Looks Possible as Unlimited Plans Rise

#54
post #7

Where are these unlimited LTE plans the author speaks of? I haven't seen any except for from a few lucky folks who are grandfathered into truly unlimited data plans. Typing this from my home wifi which tops out at 1.8Gbps connected to a unlimited 100Mbps ISP data connection. 14 wired and wireless devices are currently connected. Try that with any current wireless plan.

I gave up a grandfathered unlimited AT&T plan to take my phone number to T-Mobile, because I'd rather have unlimited* (with the asterisk) data that I can use abroad as well. Unlimited AT&T isn't worth the occasional, accidental $200 charge for checking the news in El Salvador or wherever.

There are caveats even for the grandfathered folks.

Re: A World Without Wi-Fi Looks Possible as Unlimited Plans Rise

#55

Just because these unlimited plans are being offered doesn't mean they'll take off. The economics might work well for single people, but if you're a family of five, how many phones and unlimited plans are you willing to get? $500 can get you a good desktop that'll last for 5-10 years, that same amount gets you a mid-to-high range phone that will maybe last for four years. Plenty of places still don't get a good signa…

I have a family plan on T-Mobile. Unlimited data, 14Gb tethering per line, of course unlimited voice, text and I get unlimited data in other countries. I went to Mexico last year and got 3G speeds. I pay $200 a month for 5 lines. It will be 6 soon since they are running a get free line promotion.

That's a lot of money compared to cable Internet. $50/month can get you unlimited wired access.

Re: A World Without Wi-Fi Looks Possible as Unlimited Plans Rise

#56

Just because these unlimited plans are being offered doesn't mean they'll take off. The economics might work well for single people, but if you're a family of five, how many phones and unlimited plans are you willing to get? $500 can get you a good desktop that'll last for 5-10 years, that same amount gets you a mid-to-high range phone that will maybe last for four years. Plenty of places still don't get a good signa…

That's a weird question to pose frankly. US family plans have almost always functioned by discount per phone added to the plan. They average out to being cheaper per person, not more expensive, which is the entire point of the family plans. That's the direction this will move for households, just as it did for each previous unlimited thing (minutes, texting, etc). To answer it though, the plans will take off and will…

I hope you're right! I'm not against the possibility; I just think the pricing isn't there yet for an average family.

Then again I only got my first smartphone in late 2014, so maybe I'm just looking at this differently.

Post reply on HN