Live data from Hacker News

Any open source porn blocking setups?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 34 posts

Re: Any open source porn blocking setups?

#12
SimpleBlocker is a chrome plugin I use to block out distracting websites.

Here's what I did:

1) Installed RescueTime

2) 1 week later looked at my most visited websites and made a list of all I didn't want to visit again.

3) I added them to Simple Blocker and set a random password.

Now, I can't use chrome to access those sites, unless I uninstall the plugin. And, I've made a deal with myself that I wont uninstall it for atleast 2 months.

Anyway, tools can only help. At some point you just have to do it.

Re: Any open source porn blocking setups?

#13
What you describe is going to be very, very hard to achieve.

Looking at this simply from the standpoint of addition for the sake of simplicity, if you cannot utterly, completely, totally (etc) eliminate every possible chance for you to be able to access what you're trying to access. Whatever you try, you will know that there's a way to work around it and find yourself surprisingly motivated to bypass any limitations you try and impose on yourself.

The best way I can explain this is to reference the example I read that explained this phenomena to me. You can train ferrets to happily sit on your lap and go to sleep, but to achieve this you have to put them on a leash and then make it utterly impossible for them to get off your lap by holding onto the leash and only letting them roam around your lap. It'll take quite a while before they finally give up, accept that they're not going anywhere, and settle down, but they eventually figure out that there is absolutely no way they can change the situation and accept it. Getting yourself to that stage is... you're an IT guy. You can answer that yourself.

On top of that, this whole thing is ten thousand times more intense due to the fact that it's addiction-based.

Now, you could try and get a cellular contract that stipulates an upstream VPN (ie, where the cell signal coming into your phone comes from from a VPN you specify), and do the same for your wired internet (ie, the ADSL/cable/fiber/etc line going into your house also upstreams off a VPN). Configure the server side of that VPN on a machine with a firewall and some scripting that does the blocking. Then, take the private key you logged in with, encrypt that into say a tiny dm-crypt block file, take half the dm-crypt passphrase and keep it yourself, and give the other half of the passphrase to someone else. While the two halves are separate noone can login to the VPN server, guaranteeing noone will snoop or be able to adjust the settings.

So, that would work.... buuut you could very easily just walk down the road and buy a data SIM. Welp.

Unfortunately I think you would need to lock yourself in a room to achieve the kind of solution you're trying to get at.

I saw something really amazing on addiction recently - http://youtu.be/Sh7YB58EFgU - which I found on imgur of all places (apparently it has its moments). Being criticized for being in such a position is unproductive and unhelpful, and I can't say I think too highly of the couple of commentators who've replied here and mocked you for being candid, straightforward and honest, and being bold enough to say you need help. Kudos.

My practical/viable advice is this (you're going to have to read between the lines so I can keep this PG-13): I suspect it's probably difficult to do what you need/want to do without the porn anymore, and/or difficult to feel satisfied without it. You're going to need to adjust - in workable increments (enough to pinch a little, but not too much; a disciplined amount) - to get yourself completely off of this extra input. By all means do continue, per se; just without the porn.

Remember that our enjoyment of this whole process is just really, really intricate commentary; the main focus is that this is our way of reproducing. It's not the sole purpose; we've been built the way we have so that we're biologically obsessed with it and find it difficult to not reproduce. It's important, though, to remember that reproduction is the foundation of why all of this sort of thing exists; not anything else, for example getting high for its own sake, or forgetting other things in life, or staying wired, or anything else (I have no idea (and don't need) the finer details of your situation; I'm just pointing out some examples to give an idea of what I'm talking about).

I point this out because you may need to spend some time recalibrating your mental model to something that factors reality into the picture.

The way it's supposed to go is, if you're on your own, you have two options - periodically run the photocopier without any paper to keep the mechanism in shape (), or wait for the process to happen in your sleep. The first approach is what most guys use; the second is the body's pressure relief valve and only generally operates when you're already super tense and overloaded. But neither of those options are supposed to be particularly engaging or enjoyable; they're industrial means to an end. The brain is built to find the process noteworthy regardless of cause, but sex is the really enjoyable version.

However, you've (unfortunately) hyperoptimized/trained/specialized yourself to know exactly what makes you super happy, and you've learned how to continuously provide (= source) the top 1% of input that you really like. That's going to need to be discarded - these skills you've taught yourself are effectively useless - because sex doesn't work quite like that, sex is about communication and balance between two (usually) people.

So I have an odd idea for you. I found this a while ago - http://www.nateliason.com/multiple-orgasms-men/ - which you may find interesting to throw yourself into. It's sufficiently unusual that if you haven't discovered it before it will be novel and new and help distract you, and it'll also help get you back on track and prepare for relationships. I've heard some urologists freak out about these types of techniques, while others say there's no cause for alarm. I personally sit on the "I haven't seen any actual studies showing catastrophic disasters" fence, so I'm giving this a go myself (the main challenge is remembering to do it, which is proving a little difficult as I don't have a smartphone and can't use the recommended apps).

TL;DR: You need to replace the stimuli you're currently using with other stimuli of some kind. Just flat-out removing it absolutely stupid and not going to work (it'll just backfire very badly and disillusion you in a big way).

Re: Any open source porn blocking setups?

#15
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not every lifestyle permits intimate relationships. And not everyone can just snap their fingers and "get a long term relationship".

Also, looking for a relationship specifically to solve a habit problem is not a good idea. People in relationships can do a lot to support their partners habit changes, but it is unhealthy to try to take responsibility for someone else's habits. It is likewise unhealthy to expect someone else to take that responsibility.

Looking for a relationship to fulfil desire for opposite sex, I think, is a legitimate reason to look for relationships.

It's akin to the man is drinking engine oil to quench his thirst, asking how to stop drinking engine oil. We don't say "Drinking water specifically to stop bad habits is not a good idea". IMHO anyway.

Re: Any open source porn blocking setups?

#17
post #7
post #2

Get a long term relationship where you're not alone. A woman who would turn off your computer and show you something "uplifting"[1] when you're tempted to watch porn. [1] Whatever it maybe for you. :-)

Not every lifestyle permits intimate relationships. And not everyone can just snap their fingers and "get a long term relationship".

Exactly what kind of "lifestyle" doesn't permit an intimate relationship? Being a Catholic priest? Being a hermit like Unabomber Ted Kazcinski?

If your lifestyle doesn't permit an intimate relationship, which is one of the best things about being a human, then you need to find yourself a new lifestyle.

Re: Any open source porn blocking setups?

#18
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not every lifestyle permits intimate relationships. And not everyone can just snap their fingers and "get a long term relationship".

Also, looking for a relationship specifically to solve a habit problem is not a good idea. People in relationships can do a lot to support their partners habit changes, but it is unhealthy to try to take responsibility for someone else's habits. It is likewise unhealthy to expect someone else to take that responsibility.

The habit problem is very likely to be caused by the lack of a relationship in the first place. Sex and intimate relationships are a normal human need, so of course people are going to turn to substitutes when they don't have this.

Re: Any open source porn blocking setups?

#19
I've heard it said that to kick an addiction, you have to achieve a mental change where you stop wanting the thing you're addicted to. Consider someone who is addicted to overeating. He could go on a fast for a while, as long as he has the willpower, but eventually the willpower is going to run out and he's going to cheat. By contrast, if he were to make a positive decision to become an athlete, or a bodybuilder or model or something, he would be able to control his diet not as a strenuous act of self-deprivation but because he now sees himself differently, as someone with a mission, and snacking starts to seem really irritating to him.

So my unsolicited advice is that you need to come up with a way to see yourself differently. Maybe as a man of faith. Maybe as a mountain climber or something. Consider giving yourself a mission that will get you the heck out of your apartment and take up all your free time, so that your addiction becomes an annoyance that you won't want to bother with.

And good luck!

Post reply on HN