Live data from Hacker News

Ventusky – Weather data visualization

ventusky.com

91–100 of 117 posts

Re: Ventusky – Weather data visualization

#92

Cool! This reminds me a bit of weatherspark, which used to have a fantastic tool for visualizing long term trends. What were the 10th/50th/90th percentile temps for a given day over the last 30 years, etc. I wonder if the data sets here could be used to build something similar.

Everyone misses weatherspark. It's been a year since they went down and there's still no replacement for their historical weather viewer. I know they decided to stop because their flash based API for the radar map was depreciated but even just the historical and predicted line plots of weather data I'd pay money for. Ventusky is no weatherspark replacement and I don't think the models they're drawing their data from…

Do you know if weatherspark used public or private data sources? I've been working on some open source data visualization tools and if the data sets were public perhaps we could build something with weather data sets in mind.

Re: Ventusky – Weather data visualization

#93
post #70

This is a great visualization of free data, although not the first in this style, but it's usefulness in actual forecasting or nowcasting is rather limited. Interpolation between sparse grid points can result in missing fine details, like the subtle boundaries that kick off the most violent storms in the central Plains. Limiting to just GFS and GEM make sense from a proof of concept level, however these are long rang…

Will GOES-16 improve the existing models? Or is the plan to create new models? I'm really curious to know how the higher resolution images will be used.

Current models ingest new data from a variety of sources, including surface observations, buoys, airplanes, and GOES-derived data. The derived data might be more accurate and might be used more extensively going forward - I'm not entirely sure.

IMO (as an amateur) the bigger impact is for convective meteorologists that are continually watching satellite imagery and the work that places like CIMSS are doing in analyzing satellite imagery and detecting patterns indicative of severe weather. These detection algorithms will have a higher degree of confidence and can be triggered several minutes earlier now - possibly providing earlier warning for tornadoes.

CIMSS proving ground: https://cimss.ssec.wisc.edu/goes_r/proving-ground/SPC/SPC.ht...

Re: Ventusky – Weather data visualization

#94
post #70

This is a great visualization of free data, although not the first in this style, but it's usefulness in actual forecasting or nowcasting is rather limited. Interpolation between sparse grid points can result in missing fine details, like the subtle boundaries that kick off the most violent storms in the central Plains. Limiting to just GFS and GEM make sense from a proof of concept level, however these are long rang…

Will GOES-16 improve the existing models? Or is the plan to create new models? I'm really curious to know how the higher resolution images will be used.

GOES-16 will provide the data to allow a significant improvement in forecasts, especially of extreme weather events. Because it can have a variable scan pattern, it can do wide area scans and higher frequency scans tracking storms. The new lightning sensor allows better measurement of storm intensity. It also has finer discrimination for spectral information, 4x increase in resolution, etc.

Re: Ventusky – Weather data visualization

#95
post #70

This is a great visualization of free data, although not the first in this style, but it's usefulness in actual forecasting or nowcasting is rather limited. Interpolation between sparse grid points can result in missing fine details, like the subtle boundaries that kick off the most violent storms in the central Plains. Limiting to just GFS and GEM make sense from a proof of concept level, however these are long rang…

Will GOES-16 improve the existing models? Or is the plan to create new models? I'm really curious to know how the higher resolution images will be used.

We have some internal models that will benefit from the new GOES 16 data. Particularly the cloud mask product and the higher spatial/temporal resolution will be interesting. We develop our own internal cloudmasks using a custom tool and I'm interested to see how they differ. In anticipation of the higher spatial/temporal resolution data, we're updating our tools to reduce the memory footprint.

Re: Ventusky – Weather data visualization

#96
post #87

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can you explain the significance of that

ECMWF has been producing the best global forecasts in the world for many years. This will end in few years, but at the moment IFS, the model used at ECMWF, is the best in the world.

This is true, it routinely exhibits higher forecast skill than any of the US models.

Re: Ventusky – Weather data visualization

#97

Very nice, although default of Fahrenheit, really? The date format is ISO rather than US by default. Maybe a master switch [US|Countries in the 21st Century] 8-)

Firefox en english (the default, not en_GB), Celsius by default. (geographically in Argentina).

Re: Ventusky – Weather data visualization

#98
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My default was celsius. Firefox, language de

Connected from Ireland, Firefox in English, default was °F Possibly the locale detection is limited/imperfect, with °F as a fallback.

Using ºF is an odd fallback, considering it's just one country that uses it (just make sure detection works ok for it and you're done).

Re: Ventusky – Weather data visualization

#99
I only have a minor complaint: It only lets you view real time data and forecasts up to 2 weeks out; there's no archived data like earth.nullschool.net (which has data going back to 12/2013). If there were a site like that, or even a way of creating a DIY site that uses archived numerical data but maintains a similar UI/visual appeal as Ventusky (e.g. the wind streamlines, which I think look much more appealing than on nullschool), I would pay actual real money for this product.

Re: Ventusky – Weather data visualization

#100

This is a great visualization of free data, although not the first in this style, but it's usefulness in actual forecasting or nowcasting is rather limited. Interpolation between sparse grid points can result in missing fine details, like the subtle boundaries that kick off the most violent storms in the central Plains. Limiting to just GFS and GEM make sense from a proof of concept level, however these are long rang…

Windytv ( http://windytv.com ) provides ECMWF 9km global model, NAM 4km for CONUS, NEMS 4km for Europe and also GFS. Info about data sources used at Windytv https://community.windytv.com/topic/12/what-source-of-weathe... Windytv created new version where you can see fine details for many different overlays.

Do you know where to get archived numerical ECMWF/NAM/NEMS/GFS data? Not necessarily on a map.
Post reply on HN