Live data from Hacker News

Arrington : "You’re Welcome, You Bastards"

techcrunch.com

11–20 of 122 posts

Re: Arrington : "You’re Welcome, You Bastards"

#11
post #2

This is kind of a pissy, spiteful post. Why would anyone ever take this kind of conflict public ? What does Arrington have to gain by going around jamming his thumb in "old media" eyes ?

probably still angry about the iphone controversy that he wishes involved him

Re: Arrington : "You’re Welcome, You Bastards"

#12
post #2

This is kind of a pissy, spiteful post. Why would anyone ever take this kind of conflict public ? What does Arrington have to gain by going around jamming his thumb in "old media" eyes ?

He's using the potential bad press over this whole childish incident (on both sides) to head off a letter from lawyers. I suspect it will work.

Re: Arrington : "You’re Welcome, You Bastards"

#13
post #5

I'm going to side on Arrington on this one, even though sometimes, he likes to make a big deal out of something small like removing a few words from his post.

Why? All he had to do was select a few sentences from the excerpts and edit his post.

There's greater reward in the long run from acting like an adult, working well with others, and not being a complete douche.

Re: Arrington : "You’re Welcome, You Bastards"

#15
post #2

This is kind of a pissy, spiteful post. Why would anyone ever take this kind of conflict public ? What does Arrington have to gain by going around jamming his thumb in "old media" eyes ?

> What does Arrington have to gain by going around jamming his thumb in "old media" eyes ? Pageviews?

This.

Arrington plays the game every bit as much as the rest of them. But he's willing to expose how it works, from time to time, in order to make money for himself. I find it entertaining, which is the point.

Re: Arrington : "You’re Welcome, You Bastards"

#16
post #2

This is kind of a pissy, spiteful post. Why would anyone ever take this kind of conflict public ? What does Arrington have to gain by going around jamming his thumb in "old media" eyes ?

> What does Arrington have to gain A troll, like Arrington, craves and hopes to gain attention. Like all trolls the solution is to ignore him. And quit reading clicking through to techcrunch.

Posts meant to generate discussion/heat are the bread & butter of Techcrunch. I don't find that their articles tend break news, or have anything remarkably insightful to say. They are an entertainment news source, I suppose.

Re: Arrington : "You’re Welcome, You Bastards"

#17
post #9

This sounds like someone at Fortune trying to do something industrious and then getting smacked by the higher-ups. I wonder how many good ideas are quashed simply because of policy.

Yeah, I agree, they're trying to jerk Arrington around here.

Now fortune may have not had rights to let Arrington post it, but that's their issue most likely, as they misrepresented it, not Arrington

The first emails from them clearly are talking about excerpts in their entirety.

Re: Arrington : "You’re Welcome, You Bastards"

#18
I once had a friend who never forgot a birthday or holiday. I always got a card from him. The problem was that it was always a card that someone else had sent him. He scribbled over their message and wrote his own, then added a lame message, "I'm doing my part by recycling."

This went on for years and I hated it. It wasn't funny anymore and I didn't want to read what others had written to him.

Then it hit me... Who was reading all the cards I had sent him?

Michael Arrington is like that friend. I will probably never send him an email because I don't want anyone else (much less the whole world) reading it.

Re: Arrington : "You’re Welcome, You Bastards"

#19
post #9

This sounds like someone at Fortune trying to do something industrious and then getting smacked by the higher-ups. I wonder how many good ideas are quashed simply because of policy.

The reasonable man adapts himself to the world, the unreasonable man expects the world to adapt to him, therefore all progress depends on the unreasonable man.

Re: Arrington : "You’re Welcome, You Bastards"

#20
post #5

I'm going to side on Arrington on this one, even though sometimes, he likes to make a big deal out of something small like removing a few words from his post.

Why? All he had to do was select a few sentences from the excerpts and edit his post. There's greater reward in the long run from acting like an adult, working well with others, and not being a complete douche.

Actually, I think you're wrong on both accounts. Fortune is jerking him around. Calling them on it is not a bad thing, because a working relationship on those terms will likely cost more than it will benefit.

Additionally, bloggers (and others in Attention Media) often make more from douchebaggery than from evenhandedness. (And I honestly don't think Arrington is being a douche here.

Post reply on HN