Live data from Hacker News

Nintendo Switch

nintendo.co.jp

181–190 of 431 posts

Re: Nintendo Switch

#181
Overpriced, low battery life compared to iPad and only good game announced was 2011 released Skyrim.

If Nintendo wants to stay in game business they need to get serious. This press info was much worse than I expected it to be.

Re: Nintendo Switch

#182
post #137

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Nintendo and arguably Microsoft simply can't compete with Sony right now. Sony is dominating the high end, exclusive game market. The Last of Us, Uncharted, Metal Gear Solid and coming up in 2017: Horizon Zero Dawn, Death Stranding etc. All of these push the console to the limits and show just how superior the PS4 hardware is over its competitors. Nintendo isn't really suited anyway. Their games are arguably better c…

As years go by the less I'm convinced that the platform with the fastest hardware is the best. With consoles, on the technical front, I want constant fluid framerates and predictability. For instance, I fail to see how PS4 Witcher 3 could be better than Witcher 3 on XBox one by any standard I care about when gaming (and I'm a professional graphics programmer). That said, yes, it seems Sony is winning this generation…

> As years go by the less I'm convinced that the platform with the fastest hardware is the best.

It's never been the case.

The GC was the most powerful console of its generation, the PS2 was by far the least powerful one (with the possible exception of the Dreamcast, not quite sure where that one was).

Re: Nintendo Switch

#183
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Art direction makes up for it. By now, photorealism in games is becoming bland. Given a screenshot of most any random modern AAA game, without the HUD, I don't know if I could distinguish them. I won't argue that more graphical fidelity isn't better, but we've reached a saturation point where graphical fidelity alone won't sell your game.

I couldn't agree more. Over the years I have become less and less interested in games as they have become more and more realistic graphically. The games I still enjoy playing have poor low resolution graphics, but they're challenging and fun. This is one of the things I respect so much about Nintendo; they haven't given in to pressure to make everything realistic. They keep their focus on the game play and allow play…

Scott McCloud (the comics artist) says something very interesting about that:

The more realistic the character drawings are, they less _you_ project yourself into the story.

If this works for a static medium like comics, it could be much more important for dynamic conten like videogames. No wonder that cartoon-like characters like Mario, Link, or Pacman comes to mind before Chris Renfield (for instance).

Re: Nintendo Switch

#184

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I do want to point out that it matches current consoles in the US, but is actually going to be significantly more expensive than anything on the market in many countries. Where I am, for example, if they release at exactly the US price -- which they won't, prices always get inflated -- a Switch will cost more than a PS4 that comes packed with Fallout 4, Skyrim, and Dishonored 2, three hit games. On top of this, I thi…

Regarding the iPad, do kids/parents see that as a gaming device? You can't get real games on one of those.

[deleted]

Re: Nintendo Switch

#185
post #5

Looks incredibly interesting. If Nintendo opens this platform to indie developers it could become hugely successful

And if their security is as shitty as the 3DS, then they won't have a choice in the matter.

Re: Nintendo Switch

#186
post #178
post #91

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, I also think Nvidia played a key role in it. They saved time on reinventing the wheel with their Tegra chip and used existing Vulkan driver for it. At the same time, why can't AMD do the same with others? They should convince Sony to use Vulkan in the new PS#.

Do they really have to? The console APIs on both PS3 and PS4 (and Xbox 360 / Xbox One) were very similar to Vulcan already.

It doesn't make it any easier. They (AMD) need to do double work (implementing another driver). And someone has to pay for it. It's an expense and time wasting which can be avoided if they'd have used Vulkan.

Re: Nintendo Switch

#187

Watching the graphics quality of the Zelda demo, I can't help but think: If only this weren't on Nintendo. The graphics look equivalent to Elder Scrolls: Morrowind (2002). As with so many Nintendo demos; I find myself wishing they were a cross-platform game studio rather than a lagging hardware company.

Equivalent is a stretch: http://www.elderscrolls6.net/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/the-...

http://cdn.wccftech.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/zelda-bre...

Re: Nintendo Switch

#188

What are some of the reasons why Nintendo Switch isn't just phone + app + chromecast-like device + bluetooth controllers?

Whose phone would it be when you are playing at the living room with all your friends?

Wanna put the phone on airplane mode so noone can interrupt when you are playing? Or want to have the owner of the phone take the phone away for calls when you are playing with the other guys?

And anybody wants to show their notification on the TV?

Re: Nintendo Switch

#189

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I love Nintendo and am a huge fan. But part of me can't help but wish Nintendo would just straight up compete with Sony and Microsoft. Well I don't love Nintendo, I think their consoles are pretty gimmicky and sales are fueled mostly by nostalgia and rehashing the same game titles over and over again (the Switch is getting a Zelda title and a Mario title? What a shocker!) I honestly don't believe Nintendo is capabl…

> rehashing the same game titles over and over again (the Switch is getting a Zelda title and a Mario title? What a shocker!) You say that like this is a bad thing. Nintendo isn't just making the same games over and over again. Every new Mario game, and every new Zelda game, brings something new to the genre. For example, Super Mario Galaxy was a very innovative and award-winning game that had a very unique and well-…

The innovations they've been doing lately have mostly had diminishing returns. Super Mario Galaxy, for example, was an alright game, but it was nowhere near as innovative as Super Mario 64 was. I don't even remember if I finished it or not, but I remember that SM64 Bowser boss fight to this day.

I don't know if anyone ever argues that Nintento's first party games aren't the best games on their consoles. It just for many, myself included, the 5 or 6 excellent games that come out don't really justify the price of the console and the HDMI slot it occupies. I know I've never been able to justify a WII U (though Bayonetta 2 came close).

I hope they do better with the Switch—I'd love to justify the purchase :-). But I'm certainly not getting one at launch.

Re: Nintendo Switch

#190

I already paid for the game and now I have to pay again for multiplayer, when the prior two generations were pretty much free MP (when it even worked, that is.) Why, Nintendo?

Well, seems like they are following the industry in this. You need Xbox Live Gold to play multiplayer on Xbox.
Post reply on HN