Live data from Hacker News

Pplapi: A virtual database of the entire human population

pplapi.com

21–30 of 45 posts

Re: Pplapi: A virtual database of the entire human population

#21

Maybe the website should tell that this is a synthetic dataset, it is not clear from it.

This and the many similar comments are pretty confusing to me; with the common-sense context of how massively impossible it would be to have actual individual row-level facts on the entire population (with any choice for column[s]) "virtual database of the entire human population" seems it should be sufficiently clear about the nature of the project.

Re: Pplapi: A virtual database of the entire human population

#24

The limit seems to be 2-7171922938 [1][2] for some reason 1 throws an error [3]. Edit: I should have read the documentation first [4]. > The current database contains 7,171,922,938 agents and is approximately 6.8 TB in size. [1] http://pplapi.com/2.html [2] http://pplapi.com/7171922938.html [3] http://pplapi.com/1.html [4] http://pplapi.com/docs/

Naturally. :) I wonder why id 1 isn't working ...

Thanks for the report!

Re: Pplapi: A virtual database of the entire human population

#25
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's a synthetic world population derived from public population data; these are not real people (i.e. human subjects) and the source raw data were not identifiable or even individual-level data. I nevertheless think there are a number of issues raised by the possibility of a human population database, but to be clear: pplapi does not have actual people in it. I am currently writing about some of these issues.

Until I looked at the actual data, I didn't realize this was synthetic either. The developer might want to make that clear in the header text. "Virtual Database" doesn't make this clear. I think "virtual database synthesizing the entire human population" might make it clearer. That said. This is very impressive and has my imagination tingling with ways to apply it.

Yeah, maybe just "Simulated ..." or "Synthetic ..."?

Re: Pplapi: A virtual database of the entire human population

#26
In quite the coincidence, when I attempted to get a random human in the US, I got a simulated person 3mi from my (very rural) house. When I searched the coords, it was in the middle of a forest. The demographics seemed off for my area (too young, income too low, there is no internet access in that area, unlikely religion)

Is the precision limited to the country level?

Re: Pplapi: A virtual database of the entire human population

#27

In quite the coincidence, when I attempted to get a random human in the US, I got a simulated person 3mi from my (very rural) house. When I searched the coords, it was in the middle of a forest. The demographics seemed off for my area (too young, income too low, there is no internet access in that area, unlikely religion) Is the precision limited to the country level?

Geographically, yes the precision is at the country level. Within each country, there is another breakdown by age and sex, another by religion, another for language, and so on. So, there are a few ways - beyond geography - that you can slice the results and they are going to be proportional to reality.

Of course, the devil is in the details, so when you zoom in on any individual you can see the "uncanny valley" of how the simulated agents aren't quite right.

Re: Pplapi: A virtual database of the entire human population

#29
post #6
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Typically, when one does a university research study in the US involving human subjects there are something like IRB requirements (e.g. [ http://humansubjects.stanford.edu/new/resources/consent/ ] I see research mentioned on the website, and also that the entire world population is mentioned in the data set. Have you run into anything like this?

It's a synthetic world population derived from public population data; these are not real people (i.e. human subjects) and the source raw data were not identifiable or even individual-level data. I nevertheless think there are a number of issues raised by the possibility of a human population database, but to be clear: pplapi does not have actual people in it. I am currently writing about some of these issues.

Yeah, this almost got me. Until I start to see a bunch of 3-7 years olds making 6 digits. I have no idea toddler modeling could make this much.

Me: Mom, y didn't you sign me up for this?

Mom: Cuz you never asked for it...

Me: Uhhhh, I was little. I barely knew anything.

Post reply on HN