Live data from Hacker News

Apple should make MobileMe free

ipadwatcher.com

21–27 of 27 posts

Re: Apple should make MobileMe free

#22
post #18
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's price comparable to Dropbox for storage, while adding features well integrated into Apple's apps and hardware. Assuming you pretend the web hosting bandwidth, email accounts, sync services, etc., are free and the only cost is storage, it works out to about $0.30/GB stored, already not bad for a consumer service. For me, instant and reliable multidirectional sync of any contact, calendar, and bookmarks data, acro…

> For me, instant and reliable multidirectional sync of any contact, calendar, and bookmarks data, across all my computers or mobile devices, is worth $8/month. I have the same through Google and it's free. Apple is losing the cloud race badly, maybe free would help.

I love Google, and I would probably use it if I had an Android phone. MobileMe's biggest draw for me is its integration with Apple products with syncing and Find my iPhone/iPad.

Re: Apple should make MobileMe free

#23
post #18
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's price comparable to Dropbox for storage, while adding features well integrated into Apple's apps and hardware. Assuming you pretend the web hosting bandwidth, email accounts, sync services, etc., are free and the only cost is storage, it works out to about $0.30/GB stored, already not bad for a consumer service. For me, instant and reliable multidirectional sync of any contact, calendar, and bookmarks data, acro…

> For me, instant and reliable multidirectional sync of any contact, calendar, and bookmarks data, across all my computers or mobile devices, is worth $8/month. I have the same through Google and it's free. Apple is losing the cloud race badly, maybe free would help.

I have "the same" though Google too, except it's not remotely the same. The contact sync is limited, calendar sync doesn't cut it either without a third party app like BusySync (which I use), IMAP isn't push for real time email, etc.

Also, it's not free through Google, it's ad supported or $50 per year per user.

Re: Apple should make MobileMe free

#24
post #16
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's price comparable to Dropbox for storage, while adding features well integrated into Apple's apps and hardware. Assuming you pretend the web hosting bandwidth, email accounts, sync services, etc., are free and the only cost is storage, it works out to about $0.30/GB stored, already not bad for a consumer service. For me, instant and reliable multidirectional sync of any contact, calendar, and bookmarks data, acro…

Actually it would be $99 / 20 GB which is $4.25 per year or $0.41 per month, but I see what you're getting at.

Actually, depends what you pay. For example:

http://www.amazon.com/dp/B001AMLRU4

$69.42 / 20GB / 12 months = $0.29/GB

Note: You can buy up to 100GB.

Re: Apple should make MobileMe free

#25
post #22
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> For me, instant and reliable multidirectional sync of any contact, calendar, and bookmarks data, across all my computers or mobile devices, is worth $8/month. I have the same through Google and it's free. Apple is losing the cloud race badly, maybe free would help.

I love Google, and I would probably use it if I had an Android phone. MobileMe's biggest draw for me is its integration with Apple products with syncing and Find my iPhone/iPad.

I'm on an iPhone/iPad/MacBook Pro. The fact that I can't have MobileMe on my domain makes it a deal breaker and Google's offering actually a step above.

Re: Apple should make MobileMe free

#26
post #25
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I love Google, and I would probably use it if I had an Android phone. MobileMe's biggest draw for me is its integration with Apple products with syncing and Find my iPhone/iPad.

I'm on an iPhone/iPad/MacBook Pro. The fact that I can't have MobileMe on my domain makes it a deal breaker and Google's offering actually a step above.

"What does can't have MobileMe on my domain" mean?

A number of folks I know use MobileMe to host websites for their domain and handle email for their domain. You do have to "bring your own" DNS.

Re: Apple should make MobileMe free

#27
post #18
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's price comparable to Dropbox for storage, while adding features well integrated into Apple's apps and hardware. Assuming you pretend the web hosting bandwidth, email accounts, sync services, etc., are free and the only cost is storage, it works out to about $0.30/GB stored, already not bad for a consumer service. For me, instant and reliable multidirectional sync of any contact, calendar, and bookmarks data, acro…

> For me, instant and reliable multidirectional sync of any contact, calendar, and bookmarks data, across all my computers or mobile devices, is worth $8/month. I have the same through Google and it's free. Apple is losing the cloud race badly, maybe free would help.

Steven Frank of well known Mac development house "Panic" blogged about the details lost trying to sync contacts through Google instead of MobileMe:

http://stevenf.tumblr.com/post/618349003/here-are-some-thing...

His summary: "If you’re contemplating this change, I highly recommend setting aside a few hours for research first. You may be unpleasantly surprised."

Some more issues are discussed in today's TUAW article, "Sync Wars: Address Book vs. Google Contacts":

http://www.tuaw.com/2010/05/22/address-book-vs-google-contac...

Post reply on HN