Live data from Hacker News

Steve Jobs Tells Germans to Blame Their Government for iPad Price Difference

macrumors.com

21–30 of 60 posts

Re: Steve Jobs Tells Germans to Blame Their Government for iPad Price Difference

#21
post #8
post #3

EU governments sure do love their taxes.

Hell, yeah! And I’m happy about it. High taxes but a lot of bang for the buck.

well, taxes in germany are now going to be shipped overnight to greece, where they will be used to pay back german banks. I'm starting to feel kind of robbed, honestly

Re: Steve Jobs Tells Germans to Blame Their Government for iPad Price Difference

#22
post #18
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

US states sure do love theirs! down to every damn municipality. I hope Volcker will prevail and US will get VAT finally.

Sales tax in my municipality is less than half of UK's VAT, and food and clothing are exempt from it. You're right, I sure do love it.

VAT and sales tax are very different things. It would not be true to say something would cost more or less depending on whether sales tax or VAT was paid by the consumer.

Please educate yourself ;)

Re: Steve Jobs Tells Germans to Blame Their Government for iPad Price Difference

#23
post #14
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not in the UK.

well, judging from what some UK politicians are saying, UK will soon be even less part of EU than it sort of is now.

GBP 14Bn/year says that's not a bad thing... And another GBP 60Bn/year if we scrap the Barnett Formula. That'll right all our economic woes, and not cost the English taxpayer a penny more.

Re: Steve Jobs Tells Germans to Blame Their Government for iPad Price Difference

#24
post #11
post #7

People in Europe usually have the VAT included in the advertised price, so I can see how people would be getting their hopes up when seeing the american prices.

this absolutely freaks us out in US - that we never see actual prices we're supposed to pay, only share of what seller is supposed to get (before paying her taxes).

If you bought an iPad (or pretty much any other item online) it is unlikely you would spend any taxes on it. If you did, many states require the purchaser to report and pay the taxes themselves, not the retailer.

Additionally, sales taxes vary widely state-to-state, so for an that has the same MSRP everywhere in the US, it seems to make sense not to advertise actual tax amount.

Re: Steve Jobs Tells Germans to Blame Their Government for iPad Price Difference

#25
post #15
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

besides, meddling in politics of foreign state... not very smart thing to do for a CEO

Telling people why a product is more expensive (or, seems more expensive) is not "meddling in politics". He either tells them the reason, or he ignores the email. I'd prefer the former, personally.

"Blame your government" - that's not meddling in foreign politics?

Some Apple apologists need to get out of Reality Distortion Field.

Re: Steve Jobs Tells Germans to Blame Their Government for iPad Price Difference

#26
post #20
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sales tax in my municipality is less than half of UK's VAT, and food and clothing are exempt from it. You're right, I sure do love it.

Food and childrens clothing are also exempt from UK VAT.

To be pedantic, food (except for, roughly, `luxury' and catered foods), children's clothing, and books, amongst other things, are zero-rated, rather than exempt (a separate category which includes medical treatment and education).

Re: Steve Jobs Tells Germans to Blame Their Government for iPad Price Difference

#27
post #6
post #3

EU governments sure do love their taxes.

US states sure do love theirs! down to every damn municipality. I hope Volcker will prevail and US will get VAT finally.

What makes you think a VAT will stop municipal and state sales taxes? States and cities will not easily give up this revenue. More likely, we'll just have VAT in addition to everything else we now have.

Re: Steve Jobs Tells Germans to Blame Their Government for iPad Price Difference

#28
post #10
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hell, yeah! And I’m happy about it. High taxes but a lot of bang for the buck.

Not in the UK.

Pish, I don't mind the taxation in this country it's only typically Tory voters that complain and from the last elections that's only 37% of the country.

Re: Steve Jobs Tells Germans to Blame Their Government for iPad Price Difference

#29
post #25
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Telling people why a product is more expensive (or, seems more expensive) is not "meddling in politics". He either tells them the reason, or he ignores the email. I'd prefer the former, personally.

"Blame your government" - that's not meddling in foreign politics? Some Apple apologists need to get out of Reality Distortion Field.

How would you say it?

If Apple equalized the price in Germany then they would actually be selling in Germany for less than the rest of the EU... They don't see a pfennig of that tax.

Re: Steve Jobs Tells Germans to Blame Their Government for iPad Price Difference

#30
post #14
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not in the UK.

well, judging from what some UK politicians are saying, UK will soon be even less part of EU than it sort of is now.

Every single major political party in the UK has stated they will work with Europe.

David Cameron of the Tories stated there would be no _further_ "giving up powers to Brussels". The other two stated that they wanted to work with Europe.

This results in no change by my reckoning.

Post reply on HN