Live data from Hacker News

China announces ban on ivory trade by end of 2017

bbc.com

101–110 of 184 posts

Re: China announces ban on ivory trade by end of 2017

#101
post #71

"by the end of 2017"? This must be a joke. Why not earlier? Why do they have to wait a whole year to enforce a ban like this? It's almost like "China announces ban on human trafficking by end of 2017". Yeah, let's give criminals some time to find new career opportunities!

Considering they need to inform everyone of this, think of strategies to effectively combat ivory trading, etcetera, 1 year is a very small time period.

Re: China announces ban on ivory trade by end of 2017

#102

They need to go further and ban any and all exotic animal trade for the quackery medicine and delicacy markets.

As well as put in place some animal cruelty laws. You would hold your head in your hands if you saw what happens. For dogs, for example, they will tie their front legs together BEHIND their back (YES, DISLOCATING THEM), and leave them tied up like that with a tin can over their mouth until they're ready to deal with them. They'll even hold the dogs legs like a "handle" while carrying them around. I've never seen crue…

They should pass laws, but so should the west. The poultry/egg and fishing industry is unquestionably unethical. And much of the dairy and beef industry would have to improve as well.

Again, not trying to say China shouldn't. But am pointing out that it's a bit of throwing a stone in a glass house.

Re: China announces ban on ivory trade by end of 2017

#103
post #71

"by the end of 2017"? This must be a joke. Why not earlier? Why do they have to wait a whole year to enforce a ban like this? It's almost like "China announces ban on human trafficking by end of 2017". Yeah, let's give criminals some time to find new career opportunities!

I know, it's strange, isn't it? I've read that some fifty elephants are killed every day. Fifty a day!

Undoubtedly, the announcement will only spur poachers to work overtime and make money while the making is good.

Then there's the question of enforcement.

Thousands more will die before this senseless slaughter finally stops, if it ever does.

Re: China announces ban on ivory trade by end of 2017

#104

> I think people on HN perceive hunting or ivory trading as something bad such as human trafficking. It isn't. They both involve exploitation and suffering of intelligent and sentient being for selfish reasons. > My great-grandfather was an Ivory trader Your grandfather was a scum and no amount of mental gymnastics will change that. > With increasing government regulation and heavy handed attitude of regulators the e…

[deleted]

Re: China announces ban on ivory trade by end of 2017

#105
post #102

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As well as put in place some animal cruelty laws. You would hold your head in your hands if you saw what happens. For dogs, for example, they will tie their front legs together BEHIND their back (YES, DISLOCATING THEM), and leave them tied up like that with a tin can over their mouth until they're ready to deal with them. They'll even hold the dogs legs like a "handle" while carrying them around. I've never seen crue…

They should pass laws, but so should the west. The poultry/egg and fishing industry is unquestionably unethical. And much of the dairy and beef industry would have to improve as well. Again, not trying to say China shouldn't. But am pointing out that it's a bit of throwing a stone in a glass house.

I totally agree the West needs to improve animal welfare even further. But SOME cruelty laws are better than NONE, which is why I bring up China more. But you're totally right, there's awful stuff going on here, too.

Re: China announces ban on ivory trade by end of 2017

#106
post #102

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They should pass laws, but so should the west. The poultry/egg and fishing industry is unquestionably unethical. And much of the dairy and beef industry would have to improve as well. Again, not trying to say China shouldn't. But am pointing out that it's a bit of throwing a stone in a glass house.

I totally agree the West needs to improve animal welfare even further. But SOME cruelty laws are better than NONE, which is why I bring up China more. But you're totally right, there's awful stuff going on here, too.

Here's an interesting point: do we know that the poultry/fish industries can absorb the cost of "humanely" raiding these animals without collapsing? Assuming the money is there and this law would not kill an industry, how can we ensure that these cost increases are not passed on to the consumer?

Living in the US is expensive enough. Would you guarantee "ethical eggs" if the cost was fewer poor people could afford them? I am not happy that we treat poultry and fish the way we do, but if that means keeping those products affordable the I'd take that over increasing the welfare of an animal.

Re: China announces ban on ivory trade by end of 2017

#107

They need to go further and ban any and all exotic animal trade for the quackery medicine and delicacy markets.

As well as put in place some animal cruelty laws. You would hold your head in your hands if you saw what happens. For dogs, for example, they will tie their front legs together BEHIND their back (YES, DISLOCATING THEM), and leave them tied up like that with a tin can over their mouth until they're ready to deal with them. They'll even hold the dogs legs like a "handle" while carrying them around. I've never seen crue…

have you ever been in a farm? it sounds really cruel, yes, but thats quite similar to the majority of the meat production... sadly :(

Re: China announces ban on ivory trade by end of 2017

#108

> I think people on HN perceive hunting or ivory trading as something bad such as human trafficking. It isn't. They both involve exploitation and suffering of intelligent and sentient being for selfish reasons. > My great-grandfather was an Ivory trader Your grandfather was a scum and no amount of mental gymnastics will change that. > With increasing government regulation and heavy handed attitude of regulators the e…

> Your grandfather was a scum

Please don't do this here.

Re: China announces ban on ivory trade by end of 2017

#109

You should also check out https://reddit.com/r/babyelephantgifs . We just finished a fundraiser for David Sheldrick Wildlife Trust (an elephant orphanage in Kenya) in collaboration with the UK branch of the organization. But you can still donate! https://www.reddit.com/r/babyelephantgifs/comments/5gm1pl/he... DSWT even made a special video for this fundraiser https://www.youtube.com/embed/ogJprDLQFl8 Just check out f…

If no one told you that elephants had gone extinct, would you, or the average person ever know? Being serious here no down votes plz.

I'm all for being nice to animals but tbh untill we can feed "starving kids in Africa" maybe limited resources would be better directed for humans and not elephants (ie enforcing bans / going after black market).

Re: China announces ban on ivory trade by end of 2017

#110
Please stop saying that hunting is a solution to preserve animals. It's cruel and non-sensical. Hunters actually say that they help preserving animals. Bitch if you wanted to help you'd be donating, not bragging your vanity and your hollowness on some poor's animal corpse.

Saying hunting is a solution is like saying killing poor people is a solution to poverty...[..]

Post reply on HN