Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Hire an Oldster

tryoldster.com

21–30 of 308 posts

Re: Show HN: Hire an Oldster

#21
post #2

I'm 40, in tech years that's like 1000. I also see value in hiring experience but explicitly factoring by age discriminates against a protected class in the USA. I think a lawsuit is in my future if I use this for placement at my company. Of course, if you simply rebranded to talk about "experience" rather than "age" then solvelem probbed. Also, age != experience != skill.

I'm 40 and don't feel that way at all.

Re: Show HN: Hire an Oldster

#22
post #13

Apart from the particular technical knowledge an older guy may have, the accumulated human experience (this is, how to interact, trust, judge, understand, influence and work with other human beings) is always a very valuable factor that they may possess, for while technology changes very fast, basic human nature remains the same. In my country we have a saying: the Devil knows more from being old than from being the…

>the Devil knows more from being old than from being the Devil.

brilliant. what's the origin there?

Re: Show HN: Hire an Oldster

#24

While I think there are issues with the presentation, as edoceo noted, I love anything that stands to dispel the startup bubble myth that experience is a contraindication. I've been privileged to work in companies with programmers in their 50s and 60s and they've been great mentors. Their work continues to be top-notch and the insight and maturity they bring is absolutely invaluable. In order to keep their labor cost…

A good organization has a mix of old hands and inexperienced young people. They have complementary strengths.

Put it another way. When you board an airliner, are you happy to see a fresh faced pilot?

Or my (old) dermatologist. He said he could spot skin cancer from across the room. I asked him how, he said half his business was skin cancer - he looked at it for hours every day.

Re: Show HN: Hire an Oldster

#25
post #6

Brilliant! I'm only 30 but I know plenty of older folks that have a hard time finding jobs. This is basically an issue across all industries. I'd love to get involved in this and help it grow.

Across all industries? Really?

I think the issue of finding a job may be across most other industries, and thus older people will have difficulty regardless.

Re: Show HN: Hire an Oldster

#27
post #4

Interesting idea. Let me talk about something very tangential, if I may: a minor branding query. Why go with "A Qureshi Media startup. Contact us at contact@qureshimedia.com" in the site footer? It made me wonder "hmm, why haven't I heard of Qureshi Media, let me check them out, they are probably some huge media conglomerate." To my surprise, http://qureshimedia.com/ appears to be the website of a consultancy that in…

I think it makes a lot of sense for a company--especially one whose primary business is as a consultancy--to carve products out into their own brands. And you have to start somewhere.

Re: Show HN: Hire an Oldster

#28
I was recently working with an older developer. I don't know, maybe of 65 or 70 years. He was working on aerospace network intrusion detection systems, and I was helping him set up a simulation system. He was slinging around low-level computer architecture terminology, while I was quickly trying to access what I remembered from a college class 15 years prior, just to keep up with the conversation.

Older programmers are worthless, simply due to their age? Ridiculous. I hope to someday be as skillful as this guy.

Re: Show HN: Hire an Oldster

#29
You are only as old as you believe you are. I'm 42 and won't trade spot with any 20-something for a job. The knowledge and experience I have today, most 20-something would love to have but.. they have to live some 20 years to now gain.

WTG putting this message together, good luck!

Re: Show HN: Hire an Oldster

#30
post #2

I'm 40, in tech years that's like 1000. I also see value in hiring experience but explicitly factoring by age discriminates against a protected class in the USA. I think a lawsuit is in my future if I use this for placement at my company. Of course, if you simply rebranded to talk about "experience" rather than "age" then solvelem probbed. Also, age != experience != skill.

I worked for a recruiter for a while, and the euphemism used for age was 'seasoned'.

"Company X isn't looking for anyone seasoned"

"Company Y is open to seasoned individuals"

Companies would also look for people who were a certain number of years of out school. Like, "5 to 10 years experience post-degree." Sure, that could technically mean a 45 year old who went back to school at 35 is qualified for the position, but there is a 0% chance the company would hire that person.

The other recruiters would talk about these things pretty explicitly outside of emails. There were a lot of interesting justifications:

Older people are harder to train

Older people are difficult employees because they are stuck in their ways/used to getting their way

Older people expect more benefits/vacation/pay

Older people use more sick time

Older people don't keep up with developments in the field

Discrimination wasn't limited to age. The recruiters were just as happy to help their clients discriminate on race, or gender, or familial status. Really anything.

In my experience, age was the only protected class that recruiters would try to suss out how the hiring managers felt about while they were trying to determine the ideal candidate. It seemed to me that the other prejudices would only come to light after the recruiter had a relationship with the hiring manager and had sent them a number of candidates in the past. There were still a lot of euphemisms though.

This was just my experience though, and I was working for a small firm. I have no idea what the rest of the field is like at all.

Post reply on HN