Live data from Hacker News

Let’s relocate a bunch of government agencies to the Midwest

vox.com

31–40 of 120 posts

Re: Let’s relocate a bunch of government agencies to the Midwest

#31

The author suggests moving all 20k NIH employees to Cleveland, and seems to think that all 20k will go along with this instead of finding different employment that doesn't involve uprooting their families and moving to Ohio.

He also assumes that should those people not move, that Cleveland has enough people with the right skillsets to fill the gap.

The more relevant question is this: are there enough people with right skillsets willing to relocate to Cleveland?

Re: Let’s relocate a bunch of government agencies to the Midwest

#32
post #20

Pretty weird to see a discussion of the economy in the midwest without a single mention of Chicago - you know, the third largest city in the US... ;)

Just moved out of Chicago. Would not recommend. Besides the north corner and downtown the city and state are broke poor and crime ridden.

Enjoy your insane taxes without much to show for it. Chicago is notorious for corruption and the massive state budget routinely evaporates and screws everyone

Re: Let’s relocate a bunch of government agencies to the Midwest

#33
post #12
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Have you considered that some of the 34% of people living in 'the middle' prefer to live there? I find it hard to believe you are seriously advocating the forced relocation of citizens in the name of making 'more sense'...

Surely not forced relocation, but on the other hand I don't quite understand why people think it's a good idea to fight urbanization on a policy level rather than embracing it.

Many people, including myself, don't like cities. Being from Indiana, everyone I know that lives here wants to be here. Cities are crowded, dirty, and far more dangerous than the country and many small towns. The coasts are already overcrowded, they don't need more people.

Re: Let’s relocate a bunch of government agencies to the Midwest

#34

66% of Americans live within 100 miles of the border. It would make more sense to move all the Americans living in the middle (sometimes middle of nowhere) and focus on making the cost of living in major cities more affordable; 9 of the top 10 cities are all within 100 miles of the border.

Like what Stalin did to Tartars?

Re: Let’s relocate a bunch of government agencies to the Midwest

#35

66% of Americans live within 100 miles of the border. It would make more sense to move all the Americans living in the middle (sometimes middle of nowhere) and focus on making the cost of living in major cities more affordable; 9 of the top 10 cities are all within 100 miles of the border.

50% of the US population lives east of the Mississippi, on 1/3 of the land. It would make more sense to find why people are so frequently living near the border, and incentivize them to move inland, balancing the population more evenly across the land.

Re: Let’s relocate a bunch of government agencies to the Midwest

#37
post #3

The author suggests moving all 20k NIH employees to Cleveland, and seems to think that all 20k will go along with this instead of finding different employment that doesn't involve uprooting their families and moving to Ohio.

The basic premise may be disruptive in a "Big Bang" move but could be accomplished gradually by building new facilities and shifting project flow over time. Also, the DoD makes fast changes like this all the time as the result of BRAC. Government employees don't tend to just up and change jobs - they are career workers who like the stability and promise of a pension.

Would the German experience of transitioning from Bonn to Berlin be of much relevance here?

Re: Let’s relocate a bunch of government agencies to the Midwest

#38
post #20

Pretty weird to see a discussion of the economy in the midwest without a single mention of Chicago - you know, the third largest city in the US... ;)

   the third largest city in the US
Well, it already is large. Apart from the "Chicago issues", what's the point of moving from one overcrowded place to another?

Re: Let’s relocate a bunch of government agencies to the Midwest

#39
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How can you increase demand for housing and decrease the cost of housing at the same time?

...by dramatically increasing supply?

...which would decrease demand (ceteris paribus) :-) I think the question was academic, not practical.
Post reply on HN