Live data from Hacker News

Posterous silently changes all external links to affiliate links

shamrin.posterous.com

11–20 of 187 posts

Re: Posterous silently changes all external links to affiliate links

#11
post #4

I couldn't repeat the link copying trick mentioned in the article. When I right clicked on the link and copied it there was just google.com, no affiliate link. I can see the viglink JavaScript in the source code for the page, though. Yet the dynamic DOM inspector shows that the link href has not been changed, nor is there an onclick handler added. Perhaps it does not work on Safari, or only works for specific users?

I got the mangled link. Opera 10.52 on Windows XP.

Re: Posterous silently changes all external links to affiliate links

#13
post #3

I'm not sure if I'm missing something, or doing something wrong, but following the author's directions, none of my links are mangled whatsoever - copying the google.com link simply pasted google.com. I do have Javascript enabled as stated. I tried with each link in the article, and not a single one of them is redirecting via Viglink. (edit) Using Firefox 3.5 on Linux

adBock?

Re: Posterous silently changes all external links to affiliate links

#15
I too don't actually see it via copying like the article mentions... however a quick View Source on this and another Posterous blog does reveal some javascript to call these guys:

http://www.viglink.com/

Pretty neat, I think! Assuming they're not overwriting existing affiliate URLs, then this seems like a reasonable game to play.

In my mind, Posterous is providing free hosting / platform for the blog, so they have at least some claim to having helped make the affiliate sale.

This isn't going nearly as far in bending the rules on affiliate programs as Browsarity (another YC company):

http://www.browsarity.com/about.php

(And good for Browsarity -- but I'm still surprised that various affiliate programs haven't disconnected them yet because of their much more tenuous connection to the underlying transaction.) [EDIT: clarifed this last sentence]

Re: Posterous silently changes all external links to affiliate links

#16
post #4

I couldn't repeat the link copying trick mentioned in the article. When I right clicked on the link and copied it there was just google.com, no affiliate link. I can see the viglink JavaScript in the source code for the page, though. Yet the dynamic DOM inspector shows that the link href has not been changed, nor is there an onclick handler added. Perhaps it does not work on Safari, or only works for specific users?

I also got the mangled link, Chrome on Ubuntu 9.10... right click > Copy Link Address.

Re: Posterous silently changes all external links to affiliate links

#17
post #11
post #4

I couldn't repeat the link copying trick mentioned in the article. When I right clicked on the link and copied it there was just google.com, no affiliate link. I can see the viglink JavaScript in the source code for the page, though. Yet the dynamic DOM inspector shows that the link href has not been changed, nor is there an onclick handler added. Perhaps it does not work on Safari, or only works for specific users?

I got the mangled link. Opera 10.52 on Windows XP.

It didn't work for me in Opera 10.10 on Mac OS X.

Re: Posterous silently changes all external links to affiliate links

#18
post #4

I couldn't repeat the link copying trick mentioned in the article. When I right clicked on the link and copied it there was just google.com, no affiliate link. I can see the viglink JavaScript in the source code for the page, though. Yet the dynamic DOM inspector shows that the link href has not been changed, nor is there an onclick handler added. Perhaps it does not work on Safari, or only works for specific users?

No affiliate link for me on Safari on Win XP.

Re: Posterous silently changes all external links to affiliate links

#20
post #2

Well, I'm not as torn as the author. They are altering the original content of the author, even if the result is the same. Imagine that someone's religion believes that you go to hell if you use affiliate links... posterous would have condemned them! (dramatizing works)

That's a bit silly, their whole draw is in the fact that they change your content. If you have a youtube link, they turn that into a youtube embed. If you have http://... , they change that into an anchor. There are dozens of examples of content that you can put in an email and they will transform into something more useful, and this is generally regarded as being quite valuable. If you have a problem with posterous…

I agree here, Posterous is free and a dam great service. If you want full control code your own blog or go the wordpress custom install way. They need to monetize somehow.
Post reply on HN