Live data from Hacker News

Grafana 4.0 with alerting is released

grafana.org

11–20 of 91 posts

Re: Grafana 4.0 with alerting is released

#11
I'm currently using Prometheus, Grafana, and Alertmanager. I'm a big fan of the linux terminal, versioned config files, and separation of concerns but the rest of my team prefers web interfaces so I'm basically the only one maintaining Alertmanager. Grafana Altering looks appealing.

What have other people had success with?

Re: Grafana 4.0 with alerting is released

#12
post #6

Grafana really looks interesting, and it is interesting that you can add all the different backends to it, for an example I didn't know you can use Elasticsearch as a timeseries backend. Is it correct that Grafana works best with Graphite? At least that seems to be my impression, and it is a bit sad, since I think Graphite is cool, but it really has a lot of moving parts.

Graphite was the original, but as others have mentioned, Influx, Prom, Cloudwatch & Elasticsearch are all first-class data sources.

Re: Grafana 4.0 with alerting is released

#14
post #3

This release has been long in the making. We started on Alerting way back in March this year and it's finally released! Read more about all the highlights in the release here: http://grafana.org/blog/2016/11/09/grafana-4.0-beta-release/ Oh, and if your in New York tomorrow, signup for GrafanaCon: http://grafanacon.org

Congrats on release! We've been using Grafana for a few years now, and personally built-in alerting is the only thing I would have added. Some may argue that this "violates" good concern separation practices, but honestly you are going to be alerting about the same data you feed to Grafana, so at the end of the day it makes a lot of sense. Call it a "two in one" if you will. Either way this will make monitoring with Grafana much more streamlined.

Re: Grafana 4.0 with alerting is released

#16
Influx + Telegraf + Grafana is such a simple, sweet stack. No work to maintain, trivial to set up, I can ship just about anything I want into it, and reporting is fast.

With alerting in place now, I'm even happier than ever. A huge thank you to the Grafana team for solving a huge pain point!

Re: Grafana 4.0 with alerting is released

#17
post #14
post #3

This release has been long in the making. We started on Alerting way back in March this year and it's finally released! Read more about all the highlights in the release here: http://grafana.org/blog/2016/11/09/grafana-4.0-beta-release/ Oh, and if your in New York tomorrow, signup for GrafanaCon: http://grafanacon.org

Congrats on release! We've been using Grafana for a few years now, and personally built-in alerting is the only thing I would have added. Some may argue that this "violates" good concern separation practices, but honestly you are going to be alerting about the same data you feed to Grafana, so at the end of the day it makes a lot of sense. Call it a "two in one" if you will. Either way this will make monitoring with…

Agreed with the sentiment re: streamlined experience.

We struggled a bit with whether or not it really "belonged" in Grafana, but we believe in alerting while "in the flow".

It makes a lot of sense (from an experience standpoint) to 'manage' alerting while you're 'managing' your dashboards, visualizations, and queries; you already have a sense of the data _right there_.

Re: Grafana 4.0 with alerting is released

#18
post #6

Grafana really looks interesting, and it is interesting that you can add all the different backends to it, for an example I didn't know you can use Elasticsearch as a timeseries backend. Is it correct that Grafana works best with Graphite? At least that seems to be my impression, and it is a bit sad, since I think Graphite is cool, but it really has a lot of moving parts.

We use it with Tgres [1] (which only pretends to be Graphite, but actually is Golang + PostgreSQL) - works great.

[1] https://github.com/tgres/tgres

Re: Grafana 4.0 with alerting is released

#19

True story: Our monitoring stack now has three distinct components with alerting functionality.

We'll probably be in the same position. Grafana will make simple thresholds easy to visualize, Kapacitor can do more advanced anomaly detection, and we still need something like Sensu to do alerts that aren't really bound to metrics - and it provides a dashboard of alerts. Kinda annoying, but it works, I guess.

Re: Grafana 4.0 with alerting is released

#20
post #11

I'm currently using Prometheus, Grafana, and Alertmanager. I'm a big fan of the linux terminal, versioned config files, and separation of concerns but the rest of my team prefers web interfaces so I'm basically the only one maintaining Alertmanager. Grafana Altering looks appealing. What have other people had success with?

Zabbix and Icinga2 were the most appealing alternatives that didn't require versioned config files for alerts last time I checked.

I think Grafana will fill the basic GUI alerting needs, though. When you need more than a simple flat treshold you usually want to get out of the GUI and ask the ops team for help anyway.

Post reply on HN