Live data from Hacker News

Logojoy: AI-powered logo creator

indiehackers.com

101–110 of 343 posts

Re: Logojoy: AI-powered logo creator

#101
post #44

Hey guys - Dawson here (founder) let me know if you have any questions about Logojoy / the story.

Hey Dawson, small world! I worked at RHINO for a bit last year. Were you working on this at that time and what was the time commitment to it back then? You mention two and a half months but given the freelancing I’m guessing it wasn’t full-time effort?

Hey! Small world for sure. It was 90% of my time, I did a little freelancing for existing clients. I started work on it in September 2016.

Re: Logojoy: AI-powered logo creator

#102
post #85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The messaging here is a little coy - "Signup to save your progress" But I don't care about saving my progress, I'll just close this and... oh, I can't. So it's not so much, sign up to save your progress, it's sign up, period.

Yes, this is the point at which I exited also. I believe you'll be losing a lot of people at this point. You should make it possible to close this dialog and store a session cookie so people can come back.

I can confirm the moment that signup box popped up... it lost me interest. I have no interest in signing up for something I do not know what it will produce.

Re: Logojoy: AI-powered logo creator

#103

Hey guys - Dawson here (founder) let me know if you have any questions about Logojoy / the story.

Really well done! I was just playing with it and noticed that when I combine an inline icon with a name, the icon hangs way lower than the middle line of the next. Is that a bug? A design choice I don't understand? As another point of feedback, some spinners when searching icons and loading logos would be really nice. Maybe because of the HN effect or maybe for some other reason, but it took a few seconds for lots of actions and I wasn't sure if stuff was supposed to be happening or not. But the product is fantastic and I hope to use it soon.

Re: Logojoy: AI-powered logo creator

#104
post #28

Hey guys - Dawson here (founder) let me know if you have any questions about Logojoy / the story.

Dawson, how did you decide what were the simplest things that needed to be done first?

Great question. I've been designing logos for 12 years so I have a good sense of what's important:

1. Amazing fonts. This is the low-hanging fruit, and the core of every logo. Some logos are just nice fonts :P

2. Brainstorming and idea exploration. Logojoy is cool because it gets you thinking, and makes it a joy (haha) to explore different fonts, symbols, colors, etc.

3. Presentation. If you look at how the top agencies present logos to clients, it's always with a ton of whitespace, real-life mockups, etc.

Re: Logojoy: AI-powered logo creator

#107

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Old and boring is still sometimes the best. It's not so much old vs new, or cool vs boring, but rather the thing you are most experienced with. If the goal is to just build the damn thing, go with a stack you would be most productive in.

When I’ve seen people set out to learn something and build something, they tend to accomplish neither—but if they focus on just one of those, the other is often a happy side effect.

The golden rule in my experience is that you can have both, if being careful in the proportions. Usually I limit new things to 1-2 concepts/tools a time, and use well tried ones for others. This way I usually manage to get stuff done and avoid getting stuck in my comfort zone.

Note: I have some hobby projects with minimal progress, where I ignore the golden rule and try new stuff all the time :)

Re: Logojoy: AI-powered logo creator

#108
post #40

What struck me the most is going with the old and tried tools (PHP+MySQL). Nowadays everyone - myself included - is trying to have an excuse to try the sexiest JS framework of the day and most of us fail miserably to deliver anything useful - because of lack of experience or just reinventing the wheel altogether. Old and boring is still sometimes the best.

> Old and boring is still sometimes the best. It's not so much old vs new, or cool vs boring, but rather the thing you are most experienced with. If the goal is to just build the damn thing, go with a stack you would be most productive in.

Exactly. I'm making 25k month with a SaaS that was built on boring ASP.NET+SQL Server+Angular 1 because that's what I knew. I host it on Windows because I know how to make it fast and secure. I'm happy I focused all my time on building the features that clients were asking for, instead of learning the latest frameworks or fighting an OS I'm not familiar with.

Re: Logojoy: AI-powered logo creator

#109

Hey guys - Dawson here (founder) let me know if you have any questions about Logojoy / the story.

Have you looked into whether this is legit on legal usage? You appear to be using noun project icons in these logos, and afaik most logos on the noun project are creative commons with attribution (and I confirmed by selecting a few logos with icons which matched this license on the noun project site). It doesn't appear that you provide any attribution at all to the icon creators wherever you display the icon, and I h…

> I haven't even looked into whether your font usage is appropriate, can you clarify that as well?

I did a test and the first result it gave me was just my company name in the Disney font.

Re: Logojoy: AI-powered logo creator

#110
post #22

If I could offer feedback about the pricing structure -- I think if I didn't know (from the article) that it's free to create unlimited logos, I wouldn't have figured that out by looking at your pricing section. And I know it says "It's free to build unlimited logos. Only pay when you want to download" right there in plain text under the headline, but my eyes skipped over that part. I expected clickable price boxes t…

Thanks for your feedback, will definitely test different arrangements.
Post reply on HN