Live data from Hacker News

Auto Safety Regulators Seek a Driver Mode to Block Apps

mobile.nytimes.com

51–60 of 75 posts

Re: Auto Safety Regulators Seek a Driver Mode to Block Apps

#52
post #50

What if you are just a passenger in the car? How will they determine this?

Make you perform a challenge that's possible with two hands but impossible with one. See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9aMXEOAvfb4

What happens when people try to do this while driving with their knees?

Re: Auto Safety Regulators Seek a Driver Mode to Block Apps

#53
post #50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Make you perform a challenge that's possible with two hands but impossible with one. See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9aMXEOAvfb4

What happens when people try to do this while driving with their knees?

Or, people who don't have two hands?

Re: Auto Safety Regulators Seek a Driver Mode to Block Apps

#54
post #41

What if you are just a passenger in the car? How will they determine this?

Many cars have seat sensors - so disable the phone if there is only the driver's seat occupied

And watch as MPG drops when people start carrying 100 pounds of whatever in the passenger seat.

Re: Auto Safety Regulators Seek a Driver Mode to Block Apps

#55
The solution to this is simple: one way or another, except for people whose job it is to drive, we should stop having people drive cars, whether that means public transit, more bike lanes, or self-driving cars or something else.

I do think it's possible to approximately locate a driver's phone, though it will likely work relatively imperfectly. But then consider that driving drunk is also a huge hazard, and yet most people don't have breathalyzers required to start their cars (and yes, this technology does already exist)

Re: Auto Safety Regulators Seek a Driver Mode to Block Apps

#56
I feel like something which is missing from this entire conversation is the idea of building user interfaces which are easier to use while driving. It feels like we are stuck in an era when abstinence was the only teen pregnancy solution which was politically safe to discuss.

A simple example would be a music player where the UI is a full screen block of solid color which recognizes swipe guestures to control playback. There's no reason to look at the phone because there's nothing to look at.

A bit more controversial would be Apple automatically dialing up the accessibility font size boost if the phone is moving faster than 10 mph. We may not be able to prevent people from using their phones while driving, but we can reduce the amount of time required to interact with their phone's UI by using easier-to-acquire font sizes and putting less text on the screen.

Re: Auto Safety Regulators Seek a Driver Mode to Block Apps

#57

The solution to this is simple: one way or another, except for people whose job it is to drive, we should stop having people drive cars, whether that means public transit, more bike lanes, or self-driving cars or something else. I do think it's possible to approximately locate a driver's phone, though it will likely work relatively imperfectly. But then consider that driving drunk is also a huge hazard, and yet most…

It'll take some time to get to that point. Is the proposed driving mode a good stop-gap? I think it could well be.

Re: Auto Safety Regulators Seek a Driver Mode to Block Apps

#58

The solution to this is simple: one way or another, except for people whose job it is to drive, we should stop having people drive cars, whether that means public transit, more bike lanes, or self-driving cars or something else. I do think it's possible to approximately locate a driver's phone, though it will likely work relatively imperfectly. But then consider that driving drunk is also a huge hazard, and yet most…

Man, I'm so tired of the whole self-driving meme

It's years off in most of the world, while more and more sophisticated infotaiment screens that can distract the drivers are ALREADY on the market

Re: Auto Safety Regulators Seek a Driver Mode to Block Apps

#59

I feel like something which is missing from this entire conversation is the idea of building user interfaces which are easier to use while driving. It feels like we are stuck in an era when abstinence was the only teen pregnancy solution which was politically safe to discuss. A simple example would be a music player where the UI is a full screen block of solid color which recognizes swipe guestures to control playbac…

Is the issue really with how people interface with applications, or rather that interacting with applications takes focus away from the road?

A person can be looking at the road with their eyes but not focusing on it (being prepared to respond) at the same time.

Re: Auto Safety Regulators Seek a Driver Mode to Block Apps

#60

The solution to this is simple: one way or another, except for people whose job it is to drive, we should stop having people drive cars, whether that means public transit, more bike lanes, or self-driving cars or something else. I do think it's possible to approximately locate a driver's phone, though it will likely work relatively imperfectly. But then consider that driving drunk is also a huge hazard, and yet most…

It'll take some time to get to that point. Is the proposed driving mode a good stop-gap? I think it could well be.

I don't think it's a good stop-gap for me. I wan't to be able to use my own gps app (OSMand), not retarded Google Maps that has less features than bottomfeeeder gps unit you buy at wallmart

But I can concede that people are sure as fuck going to use facebook on those screens if there was a way to do so -.-

Post reply on HN