Live data from Hacker News

HP Buying Palm For $1.2 Billion

finance.yahoo.com

21–30 of 148 posts

Re: HP Buying Palm For $1.2 Billion

#21
post #12

This is very surprising. I'd speculated that Sony or RIM would consider buying them once HTC fell out of favor. Sony seemed to be a good fit from a capacity to deliver a high quality product, plus they have ability, much like Apple, to sell stuff at a premium. RIM seemed less likely but given their need for a new phone OS, it seemed like a pretty easy fit. Corporate culture might have been a factor against them doing…

HP's not the sort of company that can enter a new market like this and turn it on its ear This isn't a new market for HP. They've been a leader in the PocketPC space for years, with their Axim line, and Compaq's Ipaq link (no, Apple didn't invent the "i" thing). I wonder now what's to become of the Ipaqs. I assume that the Windows Mobile based devices will simply be phased out.

I didn't mean to imply this was a new market for HP. I meant that they haven't historically torn up a new market the way say Sony has in the past.

Bringing webOS to a Slate device actually makes a lot of sense; I hadn't considered that and honestly that might be the real reason they pulled the trigger.

Re: HP Buying Palm For $1.2 Billion

#23
post #18

Well, this is great. I love my Apple gear, and I'm going to stay that way as long as they keep making well-designed (minimalistic externally) stuff. But with the Palm acquisition, HP will be able to do just what Apple is doing. And that's great - integration between software and hardware makes my life (as a user) so much easier. The main question I have is: will they have any taste? The HP slate has a big white HP lo…

It's funny, even though Apple has resisted messing up the hardware, there is still that "Sent from my iPhone" message which always struck me as having no taste at all. It is different because you can remove it, but still.

True!

I hate that bleepin' message. (I didn't know you could delete it.)

Re: HP Buying Palm For $1.2 Billion

#24
post #22

"Palm’s unparalleled webOS platform" Question: is Palm's web os platform really unparalleled? Or is it quickly falling behind the race that is now dominated by iPhone and android?

It still curb stomps iPhone OS and Android in a number of ways. The card based interface and notifications are unparalleled (IMO).

Re: HP Buying Palm For $1.2 Billion

#25
post #18

Well, this is great. I love my Apple gear, and I'm going to stay that way as long as they keep making well-designed (minimalistic externally) stuff. But with the Palm acquisition, HP will be able to do just what Apple is doing. And that's great - integration between software and hardware makes my life (as a user) so much easier. The main question I have is: will they have any taste? The HP slate has a big white HP lo…

It's funny, even though Apple has resisted messing up the hardware, there is still that "Sent from my iPhone" message which always struck me as having no taste at all. It is different because you can remove it, but still.

I view 'Sent from my BlackBerry / iPhone' as a way of explaining why the email is so short.

Re: HP Buying Palm For $1.2 Billion

#27
post #22

"Palm’s unparalleled webOS platform" Question: is Palm's web os platform really unparalleled? Or is it quickly falling behind the race that is now dominated by iPhone and android?

webOS was definitely the most promising of the platforms imo. It never saw much adoption because the political approval/development process at Palm was horrible even if you tried really hard to get your apps on it (see jwz) and it was only available on the one not-very-popular phone.

I'm happy to see someone who might do something decent with webOS take over.

Re: HP Buying Palm For $1.2 Billion

#28
Man, that is a big pile of cash. It hardly seems worth it, but if HP wanted to be a player in the mobile space now they are.

But Palm has a (very long and storied) software problem, not a hardware problem. HP doesn't have much of a reputation in consumer-grade OS software development so I'm not sure how they will be able succeed where Palm failed.

Re: HP Buying Palm For $1.2 Billion

#29
post #25
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's funny, even though Apple has resisted messing up the hardware, there is still that "Sent from my iPhone" message which always struck me as having no taste at all. It is different because you can remove it, but still.

I view 'Sent from my BlackBerry / iPhone' as a way of explaining why the email is so short.

Did BlackBerry start putting those messages in first, before Apple did the iPhone?
Post reply on HN