Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Spamnesty: Waste spammers' time

stavros.io

21–30 of 188 posts

Re: Show HN: Spamnesty: Waste spammers' time

#24
This could works in short run as long as this type of service stay as niche and not too popular. Spammers always, always have a creative work around it. I imagined a counter measure from them by build a bot detector that will spam back the spambot and one hell of continuos email loop doesn't do any good to our internet traffic.

Re: Show HN: Spamnesty: Waste spammers' time

#26
post #7

I have never understood what were the goals of these messages. People saying they have a fund of millions. Is everything arranged for me to send money to them? Simpĺe as that?

I half-fell for one of these once. I was a teaching assistant with my contact info posted on our department page, and a woman in Africa wrote seeking a tutor for her son who would allegedly be doing a summer program at my university to prepare for enrollment in the fall. It all seemed reasonable until she wanted to wire funds to my account. I told her to have her son pay me in person, and she never wrote again! This was a pretty good scam because there were no millions involved, and she'd done her research to match the pitch to the mark.

Re: Show HN: Spamnesty: Waste spammers' time

#28

Really cool. Two remarks: 1) If lots of people start using this, spammers might learn to avoid wasting time with Mnesty's CEO. Having a few more fake companies would help. 2) The bot could probably be made a lot smarter with some natural language processing. But it seems to fill its purpose pretty well already. I think this just shows how desperate for leads spammers are.

I would also suggest giving the spammers more intense work to do. Like a pdf form for new suppliers that they have to download, fill out, sign, scan back in, and return. Or maybe submit to a form page with a horribly difficult captcha.

Re: Show HN: Spamnesty: Waste spammers' time

#29
post #7

I have never understood what were the goals of these messages. People saying they have a fund of millions. Is everything arranged for me to send money to them? Simpĺe as that?

Basically, they spammer is hoping to milk you for "fees" that they will say are necessary in order to free up/transfer the money that they have waiting for you. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_Prisoner

My God. There really is nothing new under the Sun...

Re: Show HN: Spamnesty: Waste spammers' time

#30
How is the bot tailoring the replies, for example

> Hello, I have wired the funds you asked for. Could we please proceed to the next stage? Daniel Wong CEO, MNesty, LLC

Is that a canned response? This happens later on in the thread (does it recognise that the topic of the conversation is "funds" rather than say "product")

Post reply on HN