Live data from Hacker News

Ask YC: Should I quit programming to pursue the arts?

news.ycombinator.com

51–56 of 56 posts

Re: Ask YC: Should I quit programming to pursue the arts?

#51
I had a similar realization in my early twenties which led me into an artistic field. For the next four years it became an obsession which took up most of my time. Then reality kicked in and I found myself broke and unemployed and had to give it up. One of the biggest failures in my life so far. Just when I started to get a hang of it too.

One advice I would give is try to have some sort of income from somewhere else, so you can finance your artistic pursuits, because most likely you won't be making any real money from it.

Anyway, sorry for the sob story. Had to vent.

Re: Ask YC: Should I quit programming to pursue the arts?

#52
Do it.

Based on your question, you are looking at the visual arts. So, what kind of art are you going to do? do you want to sell work in galleries? If so, do it. but don't commit half way. Be prolific. Don't paint for 4 years and then give up. Because, unless your paintings are Rembrandts (in which case why give up?) your paintings will be worthless in the long run to whomever bought them... or to their children. Antiques roadshow price... $50.00, not $50000.00

So consider at least the people you will interact with, and the contribution you make back to the world. Paintings accrue value because of the longevity and quality of the artist. This is true for the other arts as well. Compete against the world, but more importantly compete against your friends. It raises your skills and qualities. Follow your own vision, because that is the great difference between you and the other guys.

It's other artists that decide what is good art. not galleries or collectors or anyone else. so hang out with your peers. only good things come of it.

Be serious and have fun.

In the great scheme of things, it really doesn't matter what you do, except to you.

Reading these comments, I am reminded by Yoda's sage wisdom. "Do or do not. There is no 'Try'".

For the record, you can do both. It's just harder. Because you should never use one interest as an excuse for poor performance in another.

So do it. It is an entrepreneurial life. Work your ass off and you can become a great success. it is true in any field. The real success comes from those who do the work. And it's a startup world, just like Web 2.0. You can be too far ahead of the curve, or yesterdays news, or provide products the market really likes or miss completely, or come in as a poor second. The art world like silicon valley is very forgiving especially to people who keep on bringing new work for people to experience.

Not many people remember when the Blue Man group were crazy street performers in New York. They worked hard and adapted or tried different things and are now a big success. It's just like a startup. work hard; be adaptive; see what works; do your thing. Sounds kind of familiar doesn't it?

Re: Ask YC: Should I quit programming to pursue the arts?

#53
post #50
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I like having a job, though, cuz then I don't feel guilty about not spending all my time saving the world. I'd love to, but I have work to do!

Lame ;p I prefer spending my time figuring out how to save the world instead of working.

Ssssh, stop chipping away at my cold heart! That's pretty insensitive of you...

Re: Ask YC: Should I quit programming to pursue the arts?

#54
post #53
post #50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Lame ;p I prefer spending my time figuring out how to save the world instead of working.

Ssssh, stop chipping away at my cold heart! That's pretty insensitive of you...

If I'm insensitive enough, will you try to save the world from people like me?

Re: Ask YC: Should I quit programming to pursue the arts?

#55
post #52

Do it. Based on your question, you are looking at the visual arts. So, what kind of art are you going to do? do you want to sell work in galleries? If so, do it. but don't commit half way. Be prolific. Don't paint for 4 years and then give up. Because, unless your paintings are Rembrandts (in which case why give up?) your paintings will be worthless in the long run to whomever bought them... or to their children. Ant…

I met a dramaturge at a party about ten years ago who told me that the Blue Man Group's original investors were groups of Japanese families that mortgaged their homes and life savings to get BMG bootstrapped and started, before their successful show, before the Intel commercials, before the franchise that is BMG today.

Re: Ask YC: Should I quit programming to pursue the arts?

#56
post #32

I went through the exact same thing 2 years ago. I was so sick of sitting in a cubicle and wanted to try stand-up comedy. Every one I knew encouraged me, so like a typical hacker, I set up a project to get educated and find out what it would take. Either a career change, or just part-time to break up the monotony. Here's what I learned: The reality is far different from what it appears to be. Instead of nights full o…

Thanks for the insight, and thanks everybody else for their comments and feedback. Despite the dangers and risks, I'm actually going to try and pursue acting as a part-time hobby on the weekends and stuff (I already have an audition for an independent film next week).

Again, thanks for helping me getting my thoughts and doubts cleared up!

Post reply on HN