Live data from Hacker News

Autopilot Full Self-Driving Demonstration [video]

tesla.com

71–80 of 255 posts

Re: Autopilot Full Self-Driving Demonstration [video]

#71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A real convincing promo video would be in stormy weather with angry, unpredictable drivers and random jaywalking kids.

Agreed. Throw in some fog, high-speed stop-and-go interstate fun, and moving from the interstate into a crowded city full of people jaywalking and running stoplights trying to get to where they're going.

Can we use a game environment to artificially synthesize scenarios? I don't know if there are any that can generate realistic video.

Re: Autopilot Full Self-Driving Demonstration [video]

#72
post #10

I don't know about other countries, but at least in the Netherlands the Benny Hill song is used mainly in videos to ridicule the subject. I remember when funny 'Home Videos' were a thing on TV (before cats took over on the interweb) this song was used in about 90% of them. So to me, using this song in something as serious as a self driving car demonstration is pretty weird.

It's just asking for someone to redo the movie with Kevin MacLeod for the soundtrack.

Come to think of it, I just feel like making a montage.

Re: Autopilot Full Self-Driving Demonstration [video]

#73
post #22

There seem to be some issues. E.g. it recognizes the joggers (0:55) as obstacles even though they're obviously (to a human) on the sidewalk. And when taking a right turn (1:01) it mistakes a hydrant and a parked car in a parking bay on the other side for an obstacle and stops for a moment before noticing that they're not actually in its lane. I think a polite driver may have slowed down gradually to not startle the j…

The car might have been playing on the safe side. If you look at the joggers carefully, only the left one is marked as an "in-path object", the other one has just an "object" box. They could probably tune down the collision prediction algorithm just a little bit, but that has to be done very carefully.

Re: Autopilot Full Self-Driving Demonstration [video]

#74
post #10

I don't know about other countries, but at least in the Netherlands the Benny Hill song is used mainly in videos to ridicule the subject. I remember when funny 'Home Videos' were a thing on TV (before cats took over on the interweb) this song was used in about 90% of them. So to me, using this song in something as serious as a self driving car demonstration is pretty weird.

If you look at it from the perspective of the sane and rational (Tesla autopilot/a cartoon viewer) viewing down to the ridicule (Human drivers and their emotions/absurd cartoon scenario) I think it is well placed :)

Re: Autopilot Full Self-Driving Demonstration [video]

#75

The Benny Hill theme tune was a pretty unfortunate choice of background music, not sure if that's the impression they wanted to make (maybe it was, not sure).

When the last video came out, there were quite a few people saying "wait, that video's sped up, right? It doesn't seem to be taking turns at a safe speed." I expect Tesla got feedback indicating that some people didn't notice that the last video was sped up, so they decided to make this video a lot more obvious by speeding it up even more and adding the music. I agree, it's not really a good choice, but I can see how…

Indeed; for me this music has two primary connotations - "funny" and "sped up".

Re: Autopilot Full Self-Driving Demonstration [video]

#76

There's also the longer (3:28) video with the Paint It Black theme: https://www.tesla.com/videos/autopilot-self-driving-hardware...

That's really weird choice, who are picking these songs? :) I can't imagine they've licensed the music either... I guess next up is the "Highway to Hell" video

Re: Autopilot Full Self-Driving Demonstration [video]

#78
post #30
post #16

So it appears it's reading the road signs? I see it stops on the intersection with a stop sign where's no traffic lights. But what if the sign is damaged or removed? The car will go straight without stopping?

Maybe it's relying on maps & GPS data.

What if the GPS data is outdated?

Re: Autopilot Full Self-Driving Demonstration [video]

#79
post #62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think the current-gen autopilot vision code is a completely different codebase from a different supplier running on different hardware than the gen 1, though, so all those improvements have probably been thrown away.

Curious, why do you think so? Wouldn't make much sense to throw all that stuff away.

For the same reason it makes no sense to keep your Sega Saturn games when you now have a Playstation.

There are some testing scenarios which Tesla should be able to use, ut none of the software from MonilEye has relevance to Nvidia's platform.

Re: Autopilot Full Self-Driving Demonstration [video]

#80

Very cool demonstration (despite curious choice of music!). I did notice that the lane markings are suspiciously bright and well-painted throughout the video. Almost as if they'd been touched up by Tesla! Or maybe this area just has particularly diligent road-painting crews. In many parts of the real world you'd be lucky to get such clear lane markings throughout the journey, certainly not here in the UK or in places…

In my autopilot gen 1 Tesla, when the software was first released, lane markings had to be really clear, but as the software has matured, it now does less than perfect lane marking in pretty heavy rain without issue.

What does it do on roads without any lane-markings? My country has lot's of them outside the cities.
Post reply on HN