Live data from Hacker News

HP Unveils Mini Workstation

www8.hp.com

111–120 of 238 posts

Re: HP Unveils Mini Workstation

#111
post #51

this does not seem interesting to hackers at all

It is if it ships with Linux.

I'm sure they're referring to upgradability which is the last attractive feature of desktops. I can't figure out why anyone would care how big their tower is. If you're going to have an array of 6 monitors, I'm sure you've got an extra square foot or 2 for a standard tower that won't lock you into HP components.

Re: HP Unveils Mini Workstation

#112
I couldn't help but notice this funny marketing line which made me laugh

> The incredibly compact form factor resembles more a super computer from the future than a PC of today.

Re: HP Unveils Mini Workstation

#113

Wow. The Mac Mini used to have a quad core version.

I loved that thing. I used it 24/7 for two years and then sold it for just 250 euro below the original price. Overpriced Macs do have their advantages.

I still use the 2.3GHz quad core "server" version as my main system and I love it :) I took one of the 1TB disks out and put an SSD in to make a DIY fusion drive.

Re: HP Unveils Mini Workstation

#114

I don't understand why they didn't use a Xeon e3-1545m, which is a 35-45 TDP part and has adequate graphics for the intended market. If it doesn't support ECC, there's no benefit vs the Intel Skull Canyon. I am in the market for a new dev machine, and I want Xeon and ECC. Just not enough good options currently (unless you build from scratch).

> If it doesn't support ECC, there's no benefit vs the Intel Skull Canyon.

It does support ECC - right there on the product page.

Re: HP Unveils Mini Workstation

#116
post #9

So how much RAM could be stuffed in one of these? Edit: The Z2 Mini supports Intel Core i3, i5 and i7 processors, in addition to Xeon E3 processors. It also supports up to 32GB of DDR4 SO-DIMM memory, and the unit can be equipped with Nvidia Quadro M620 graphics with 2GB of memory. (from http://www.tomshardware.com/news/hp-z2-mini-g3-workstation,3... )

Any idea to which consumer card the Quadro M620 correlates? If it's something halfway decent then it might be a also a much better ultraportable gaming solution for some people than e.g. a NUC. However that also depends on if the Quadro drivers are suitable for gaming or not.

Its desktop variant the K620 performs between a GTX 750 (non-Ti) [1] and a 730 [2], so it doesn't look exceptional. I'd guess around Intel Iris level.

[1] http://gpu.userbenchmark.com/Compare/Nvidia-Quadro-K620-vs-N... [2] http://gpu.userbenchmark.com/Compare/Nvidia-Quadro-K620-vs-N...

Re: HP Unveils Mini Workstation

#117
post #85

Is there an obvious reason that they stick with traditional air cooling for this, rather than using liquid cooling? Here's an example of a compact system with liquid cooled CPU and graphics card built using off-the-shelf parts: http://blog.newegg.com/building-a-mini-itx-gaming-pc/ I'd think that at this small size, you'd need really high air velocity to make it work. Coupled with small fans, this generally means the…

mini-itx computers are small but this thing is tiny in comparison to the average mini-itx build.

Absolutely it's smaller. Did you notice that they have designed it so that it can act as a VESA mounting plate that goes between a swing arm and the monitor? http://media.bestofmicro.com/B/N/628979/original/HP-Z2-Mini-...

I wasn't suggesting that mini-ITX was a substitute. It's only compact for something that uses standard hardware. What I was wondering was why they stuck with air cooling despite using a custom form factor. I presume there are reasons for this --- I just don't know them.

HP does claim that this machine is "63% quieter than a comparable HP business-class mini PC.": http://www.tomshardware.com/news/hp-z2-mini-g3-workstation,3.... My previous experience with HP machines though is that I hate being in the same room as one even when it is at idle. So even if this is 1/3 as loud, it may still sound like a vacuum cleaner.

Re: HP Unveils Mini Workstation

#118
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is if it ships with Linux.

I'm sure they're referring to upgradability which is the last attractive feature of desktops. I can't figure out why anyone would care how big their tower is. If you're going to have an array of 6 monitors, I'm sure you've got an extra square foot or 2 for a standard tower that won't lock you into HP components.

You'd be surprised how much two square feet cost in a trading floor in Manhattan. Plus enterprise customers are typically "locked in" anyway.

Re: HP Unveils Mini Workstation

#119

No audio output as far as I can tell, and after I plug in my USB keyboard and mouse I'll be out of ports.

USB hub? Many monitors have them these days built in. If yours doesn't, Amazon sells them for barely more than the cost of shipping these days.

Still, there's room on the case for additional front and back ports, and all the hubs I've used have had problems. It also defeats the clean look of the machine.

Re: HP Unveils Mini Workstation

#120
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have the Skullcanyon NUC, and this is not comparable. I've been waiting for someone to offer me ECC in a small form factor. This is the first time I've ever seen it.

I've got one of these: https://www.supermicro.com/products/motherboard/xeon/qm77/x9... which is mini-itx. Pretty small form factor. Using an M.2 boot drive. Not very cost effective though.

In the mini-itx space, there's also http://asrock.com/mb/Intel/X99E-ITXac/index.us.asp which is DDR4, not SODIMMS, and your choice of processor, including V4 Xeons. I have one with a E5-2680V4 + 64GB of ram in it. (128 should be feasible with 64GB sticks as far as I know, but as they're about $700 each last I checked I haven't tried it.)
Post reply on HN