Live data from Hacker News

My Subconscious Is a Better Developer Than I Am

blog.johnnyreilly.com

81–90 of 119 posts

Re: My Subconscious Is a Better Developer Than I Am

#81
post #29

For mind bending check the great explanation from CGP Grey, "You are two"[1], which argues the two brain hemispheres can operate independently. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wfYbgdo8e-8

You beat me to it. One of my favorite videos ever (more https://goo.gl/o0zYbu), puts a lot of stuff into perspective.

Re: My Subconscious Is a Better Developer Than I Am

#82
post #72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not sure I understand what you mean.

Say that you believe X and I believe Y. If I present an argument for Y that amounts to presenting evidence for your consideration that Y is true and X is false. The implicit assumption behind arguing with anyone (even your self!) is that your mind is free to choose to believe X or Y, THAT is freewill. If freewill is an "illusion" then "argument" is a hollow concept as well. If we don't have a choice in what to believ…

I think argument still has a place in a world where freewill is illusory. Surely, one's opinions can change when presented with new evidence, regardless of whether that change originated from a free agent's conscious choice or a more deterministic background process of which one's consciousness is only partially aware. Furthermore, that change in opinion can have a meaningful effect either positively or negatively for both the conscious entity and the world at large.

Re: My Subconscious Is a Better Developer Than I Am

#83
post #30

I'm like this, to the point that I actively harness it: whenever I have some bigger problem to work on I read it and just not work on it for the rest of the day. In the morning I just know I'll have a much better understanding of it somehow. The morning always brings answers no matter how complex something seems. I find it extremely relaxing, just being aware that if something is frustrating I can just drop it for th…

Yeah I purposely load up problems in my head before going to bed... then when I wake up, they're magically solved without any effort. It also has the benefit of being a natural alarm clock: sometimes I have to get out of bed and type the solution in and then go back to sleep.

Paul Graham has an essay "the top idea in your mind" where he talks about what you think about in the shower:

http://www.paulgraham.com/top.html

It's pretty much the same idea... what you go to bed thinking about is probably the same thing you think about in the shower in the morning. For me the solution comes WHILE sleeping; I don't have to wait to get up and think about it.

Re: My Subconscious Is a Better Developer Than I Am

#84
post #31

If you look carefully enough its not only the developer in you but anything meaningful or living in your life is done by someone other than what you usually refer to as me. Normally, such phenomenon is mostly associated with ideas we get on waking up or during shower or exercise. My observation is that whenever you do anything that's unscripted or unplanned - it's "someone else". Say - answering well an interview wit…

> "I'm from India and I find it hard to communicate with western people these ideas directly." I'm from a Western country, and understand what you're saying, though I admit I did pick up on the general idea from Eastern philosophy. If you were interested in sharing the ideas with Western people, perhaps you could do so in the form of thought experiment? For example (and this is only an example, I'm confident this won…

This is probably a bad example, since the same very thing happens in animals. Yet we like to think of ourselves as fundamentally different.

Re: My Subconscious Is a Better Developer Than I Am

#85
post #77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Forgive me if I put as much faith in this answer as anything else said by psychologists or psychiatrists over the last 100 years (I.e. almost completely irreproducible and constantly overturned claims). I'll believe it once psychology is reduced to computational neurophysiology.

100 years ago, the proponents of the "plum pudding model" and "ether" were still alive and kicking. Good science takes time, and must account for all the evidence. Psychology won't be reduced till we achieve "computational neuroemotional physiology". Don't let an enduring discomfort with human emotions give you a scientific blind spot to human nature, otherwise your AI will have trouble finding its way out of the unc…

And yet the vast majority of experimental and even theoretical physics was correct (and simply a limiting case of a more general theory), in diametric opposition to psychology. Physics has never thrown the baby out with the bathwater, but psychology does it every generation or two.

> computational neuroemotional physiology

Not sure what you mean by this. Computational neurophysiology would obviously subsume emotional behavior (unless you subscribe to dualism).

Re: My Subconscious Is a Better Developer Than I Am

#87

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> "I'm from India and I find it hard to communicate with western people these ideas directly." I'm from a Western country, and understand what you're saying, though I admit I did pick up on the general idea from Eastern philosophy. If you were interested in sharing the ideas with Western people, perhaps you could do so in the form of thought experiment? For example (and this is only an example, I'm confident this won…

This is probably a bad example, since the same very thing happens in animals. Yet we like to think of ourselves as fundamentally different.

> "Yet we like to think of ourselves as fundamentally different."

Yes, we do don't we. Yet reality remains what it is. Perhaps by exploring with an open mind we can stop our preconceived notions from clouding our understanding.

Re: My Subconscious Is a Better Developer Than I Am

#88
post #54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Think about what happens when you decide where to eat for lunch. There's an internal process whereby you propose various images (hamburger? pizza? Mexican?). Something else "inside you" says, "Nah, that doesn't sound good. Hmm, maybe. Yeah, that!" Who are you asking? Who is answering?

That happens for you. How do you know it happens for other people? How do you know how many other people share your experience, vs people who don't have that internal monologue?

I don't. Just speculating. Would love to hear about different experiences.

Re: My Subconscious Is a Better Developer Than I Am

#89
post #85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

100 years ago, the proponents of the "plum pudding model" and "ether" were still alive and kicking. Good science takes time, and must account for all the evidence. Psychology won't be reduced till we achieve "computational neuroemotional physiology". Don't let an enduring discomfort with human emotions give you a scientific blind spot to human nature, otherwise your AI will have trouble finding its way out of the unc…

And yet the vast majority of experimental and even theoretical physics was correct (and simply a limiting case of a more general theory), in diametric opposition to psychology. Physics has never thrown the baby out with the bathwater, but psychology does it every generation or two. > computational neuroemotional physiology Not sure what you mean by this. Computational neurophysiology would obviously subsume emotional…

You seem to have nothing to say on the topic of emotion, except that the 1000's of people who study it in universities, clinics and hospitals around the world have nothing correct to say...

I am certain that your emotions on the subject are clouding your judgement. But to be the consistent razor of occam as you present yourself, shouldn't your term be computational neuro? what does physiology have to do with it?

Post reply on HN