Live data from Hacker News

Bahmni – Open-source Electronic Medical Records and Hospital System

bahmni.org

31–40 of 43 posts

Re: Bahmni – Open-source Electronic Medical Records and Hospital System

#31

One of the major EHR systems used in the United States, VISTa, was developed by the Veteran's Administration and is open source. It's sufficiently successful that it's been adopted not just by other government agencies but a number of private hospitals. Most instances still seem to be based on a commercial M implementation, but some use the fully free GT.M stack It's M based and in general not on the cutting edge of…

M / Mumps is a terrible language / datastore to deal with however.

Re: Bahmni – Open-source Electronic Medical Records and Hospital System

#32
post #27

Naming matters. I can't see this without instantly thinking it is about delicious sandwiches.

Why the name Bahmni?

The first implementation of Bahmni took place at Jan Swasthya Sahyog (JSS), a hospital that has been instrumental in pioneering this open source work. Bahmni is named after a village 70km north of the small town of Bilaspur, India where one of three village health centers of JSS hospital is located. The work being done by JSS at Bahmni village is very inspirational to us and hence the name was chosen.

Ref: http://www.bahmni.org/faq/

Re: Bahmni – Open-source Electronic Medical Records and Hospital System

#33
post #2

Epic and the other big medical software providers have this market on lockdown. I do not see a path to this seriously challenging the major players any time soon in the US, even though it could be done. Additionally, the software dependencies (CentOS v6.7 & Java 7) that say breakage occurs with newer versions is very sketchy IMO, ignoring the HIPPA & PCI compliance work that needs to be done (the latter costs $40k a…

I've been working on something to help with data security. If your software project runs into PCI, HIPAA or other data security/compliance issues, we have a solution that can offload the risk and compliance work from your system without any code changes on your end. We have several customers using it in production and are profitable. If you're interested, my email is in my HN profile. I'd love to chat.

Re: Bahmni – Open-source Electronic Medical Records and Hospital System

#34
post #31

One of the major EHR systems used in the United States, VISTa, was developed by the Veteran's Administration and is open source. It's sufficiently successful that it's been adopted not just by other government agencies but a number of private hospitals. Most instances still seem to be based on a commercial M implementation, but some use the fully free GT.M stack It's M based and in general not on the cutting edge of…

M / Mumps is a terrible language / datastore to deal with however.

As a language user, it is really just a semi-structured assembly-style everything-is-string and global-memory as a hierarchical tree map.

The language comes with transaction support, though one can use mutexes instead for performance reasons.

Re: Bahmni – Open-source Electronic Medical Records and Hospital System

#35
Getting US hospitals to use your software is super hard. Majority of them are using Epic, and won't entertain you much if you don't provide Epic integration. And Epic is almost a closed system, they've done their best to make sure that integration with them is almost impossible for small companies.

Re: Bahmni – Open-source Electronic Medical Records and Hospital System

#36

Very proud of this product. The target is not the US domestic market, but developing areas that have no resources for electronic health records. I have seen this being implemented places where the traditional software would be cost prohibitive. Good for humanity. Please contribute patches!

Why did you rip off Epic's UI? This is only going to make them more paranoid going forward.

Which screens in Bahmni made you feel like they look similar to Epic? Here are the Bahmni screenshots: http://www.bahmni.org/screenshots/

It would be pretty amazing if anything looks similar to Epic. Maybe the login screen? ;)

Re: Bahmni – Open-source Electronic Medical Records and Hospital System

#37

There is no way this will be successful in the US specifically because it's based in India which hospitals in the US are extremely resistant to. Also, it looks exactly like Epic and now I understand why they are so careful with their Intellectual Property.

Bahmni isn't meant for US hospitals. It can't compete with biggies like Epic for the US markets, and neither does it want to do that. It's meant for low resource settings and places which can't afford expensive softwares like these. Check out their client list: http://bahmni.org/implementations/

Quite similar to OpenMRS philosophy. Fully open source. AGPL.

Re: Bahmni – Open-source Electronic Medical Records and Hospital System

#39
post #27

Naming matters. I can't see this without instantly thinking it is about delicious sandwiches.

Why the name Bahmni? The first implementation of Bahmni took place at Jan Swasthya Sahyog (JSS), a hospital that has been instrumental in pioneering this open source work. Bahmni is named after a village 70km north of the small town of Bilaspur, India where one of three village health centers of JSS hospital is located. The work being done by JSS at Bahmni village is very inspirational to us and hence the name was ch…

As a Medical Doc and a health tech entrepreneur current living in Bilaspur. I find this fascinating. But I think the village where JSS is located is called as Ganiyari ??

Re: Bahmni – Open-source Electronic Medical Records and Hospital System

#40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why the name Bahmni? The first implementation of Bahmni took place at Jan Swasthya Sahyog (JSS), a hospital that has been instrumental in pioneering this open source work. Bahmni is named after a village 70km north of the small town of Bilaspur, India where one of three village health centers of JSS hospital is located. The work being done by JSS at Bahmni village is very inspirational to us and hence the name was ch…

As a Medical Doc and a health tech entrepreneur current living in Bilaspur. I find this fascinating. But I think the village where JSS is located is called as Ganiyari ??

Yes, JSS is in Ganiyari. About 15 kms from Bilaspur.
Post reply on HN