Live data from Hacker News

Google Trends Electionland

electionlandtrends.appspot.com

111–120 of 178 posts

Re: Google Trends Electionland

#111
post #9

A 100% increase in searches for "voter intimidation" in my city (Seattle) is interesting. I'd love additional context on who is searching for that (i.e. is it the intimidators or the fearful?) Nonetheless, this seems like the beginning of an interesting tool. What would it take to do some sort of fuzzy matching on related searches, like broken voting machines for voting machine problems? I suppose you could wait for…

A minor point, but keep in mind a "100% increase" of 1 is 2.

Re: Google Trends Electionland

#114
post #53
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not an either or scenario. Other countries manage to have voting in person without election day shenanigans like long lines to vote.

Are these other countries comparable to the US in terms of scale and population?

No but elections are managed by the state and local governments in the US - those are comparable to other countries.

Re: Google Trends Electionland

#115
post #59

So far all of these just look like population maps of the US, skewed by time zone. Basically if it's a heavily populated area that is awake, then the dots are big. Maybe as the day goes on it will level out to more interesting insights?

A population density overlay would have been helpful as would a voting trend by state or even by municipality or district to understand if there are any statistically relevant discrepancies. That said, I suspect the point of this tool is to lower the barriers to voting to allow everyone's vote to be collected.

Re: Google Trends Electionland

#116

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unless I'm reading something on your graph incorrectly it's almost perfectly correlated with Martha Stewart Living subscribers. Looks like it applies almost exactly to me.

Well I already did the work I'm willing to do on my end. Further research would obviously have to take in to consideration deviations from general population density, but just looking at the map, there's a lot of voter intimidation being reported in the south that clearly has nothing to do with population density. Also, there's no correlation with voter intimidation and population density for cities in the midwest. S…

I'm not sure why you're pretending that it should be someone else's job to prove the point you're trying to make. You threw up a graph which looks identical to a population-density graph and are pretending you gave us evidence of your assertion.

Re: Google Trends Electionland

#117

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unless I'm reading something on your graph incorrectly it's almost perfectly correlated with Martha Stewart Living subscribers. Looks like it applies almost exactly to me.

Well I already did the work I'm willing to do on my end. Further research would obviously have to take in to consideration deviations from general population density, but just looking at the map, there's a lot of voter intimidation being reported in the south that clearly has nothing to do with population density. Also, there's no correlation with voter intimidation and population density for cities in the midwest. S…

Except your graph doesn't seem to support your point...IMO it's your word vs. your graph.

Re: Google Trends Electionland

#118
post #69

Apparently a bunch of states (23?) are using a software system called Interstate Crosscheck to look for "double voters". > Election officials in more than two dozen states have compiled lists of citizens whom they allege could be registered in more than one state – thus potentially able to cast multiple ballots – and eligible to be purged from the voter rolls. The problem is that it often only uses a persons name as…

No, it is not possible for your vote to be "wiped out." If you cast a ballot it will be counted. It's frankly a bit dangerous to imply otherwise.

As it says in the bit of article you quoted, states can use these systems to find people who are "eligible to be purged from the rolls." This is bad. Especially when it disproportionately affects certain populations of people.

But if you show up on election day and you've been purged from the rolls, election officials are required by law to provide you with a provisional ballot.

Re: Google Trends Electionland

#119
post #69

Apparently a bunch of states (23?) are using a software system called Interstate Crosscheck to look for "double voters". > Election officials in more than two dozen states have compiled lists of citizens whom they allege could be registered in more than one state – thus potentially able to cast multiple ballots – and eligible to be purged from the voter rolls. The problem is that it often only uses a persons name as…

Interesting. I'm registered in 3 states (I always kinda assumed registering in a new state unregistered you in another) and my wife is registered in 2. I wonder if my name is on that list. Damn even the criteria they use doesn't technically have to be unique; it's possible to have the same name, DOB and last 4 digits of a SSN (though that's likely incredibly rare but still the possibility is theoretically there). I f…

Merely last name and DOB brings up a fairly unique value. This is what Walgreens, and others, now use instead of SSN.

There was an earlier HN item about how DOB, gender, and Zip identifies 87% of the US population uniquely. No SSN needed in either case.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2942967

Re: Google Trends Electionland

#120
post #9

A 100% increase in searches for "voter intimidation" in my city (Seattle) is interesting. I'd love additional context on who is searching for that (i.e. is it the intimidators or the fearful?) Nonetheless, this seems like the beginning of an interesting tool. What would it take to do some sort of fuzzy matching on related searches, like broken voting machines for voting machine problems? I suppose you could wait for…

It could also be people who had a /wonderful/ easy voting experience, and heard from some guy who reads HN that 'voter intimidation' was a trending search term, so decided to search and see what the fuss was about...

This greatly overestimates the importance of HN as a source of news.
Post reply on HN