Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Who is already sick of all of these "Like" buttons plastered everywhere?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 53 posts

Re: Ask HN: Who is already sick of all of these "Like" buttons plastered everywhere?

#11
post #5

Not only are they bad, they slow down the rendering speed of the pages they're on. http://twitter.com/SlexAxton/status/12663859611

We use it via FBML and JavaScript SDK and the slow down seems to be minimal. We load their script right before .

Biggest annoyance is that it doesn't degrade very gracefully when FB has availability problems, you get a white square in the page in Firefox.

Re: Ask HN: Who is already sick of all of these "Like" buttons plastered everywhere?

#12
post #5

Not only are they bad, they slow down the rendering speed of the pages they're on. http://twitter.com/SlexAxton/status/12663859611

Well it depends how you look at it. It definitely adds to network traffic and CPU load. But IFRAME content and javascript-injected IFRAME are both loaded asynchronously.

Browsers are pretty good in progressive rendering of page content these days. So user should see the main page first and then it starts loading these additional resources. So no big deal IMHO. The button should not degrade user experience during page loading.

Re: Ask HN: Who is already sick of all of these "Like" buttons plastered everywhere?

#13
post #5

Not only are they bad, they slow down the rendering speed of the pages they're on. http://twitter.com/SlexAxton/status/12663859611

We use it via FBML and JavaScript SDK and the slow down seems to be minimal. We load their script right before . Biggest annoyance is that it doesn't degrade very gracefully when FB has availability problems, you get a white square in the page in Firefox.

I think they can solve it when using Javascript SDK on modern browsers. IFRAME could be loaded offscreen and when it finishes then it does postMessage to notify the parent window. Javascript SDK injector then unhides the IFRAME.

Easy to do, but they are probably busy doing other stuff.

Re: Ask HN: Who is already sick of all of these "Like" buttons plastered everywhere?

#14
I thought things were getting ridiculous with all the buzz, digg, sphere, reddit buttons already. From what I can see, those are being replaced with a single option (though I admit, I haven't seen many of the facebook implementations yet).

It is nice to have a 'standard' rather than voting for multiple items. At the same time, how much is liking something really doing for ya?

I don't think it has the benefit of a community like HN, so Facebook doesn't have it all yet.

Re: Ask HN: Who is already sick of all of these "Like" buttons plastered everywhere?

#16
post #10
post #4

I completely ignore all that social networking stuff; my brain sees them as ads and blocks them subconsciously.

I'm the same way. I often read articles that I would like to share with people, but since I'm more interested in the ensuing discussion, I'd rather directly link a person during a conversation (or as a way to start one) rather than throw it at my Facebook page or similar. I consider sites like HN quite different, as that is their sole purpose :)

Yea that stuff is totally blocked out of my mind. I use Facebook to connect with my friends and family, and will share a link occasionally if it really pertains to me. For the most part, though, I don't like spamming mass amounts of data to friends. The only benefit I see to things like delicious and other "social bookmarking" tools is the fact that they're "up in the cloud", aka, backed up somewhere away from my browser config folder.

Has anyone noticed the new Mahalo-esque stuff they're doing? All of your hobbies, movies, music, etc... that they're making part of this social graph is now linked together a lot better.

Example, one of my interests (for fun) is "underwater basket weaving" which now links to a page like this, http://www.facebook.com/#!/pages/Underwater-basket-weaving/1...

"Our goal is to make this Community Page the best collection of shared knowledge on this topic. If you have a passion for Underwater basket weaving, sign up and we'll let you know when we're ready for your help."

Pretty crazy.

Re: Ask HN: Who is already sick of all of these "Like" buttons plastered everywhere?

#17

I thought things were getting ridiculous with all the buzz, digg, sphere, reddit buttons already. From what I can see, those are being replaced with a single option (though I admit, I haven't seen many of the facebook implementations yet). It is nice to have a 'standard' rather than voting for multiple items. At the same time, how much is liking something really doing for ya? I don't think it has the benefit of a com…

Do you think reddit (or twitter or digg or stumbleupon) users will start liking the "like" and prefer it to replace other buttons? Completely agreeing about the ridiculous aspect of so many buttons though.
Post reply on HN