Live data from Hacker News

23andme for only $99 today only

23andme.com

71–80 of 177 posts

Re: 23andme for only $99 today only

#71

What's the deal with the freaky message about not being able to send spit tests from NY State? Can anyone explain that issue to me?

They can't accept samples from NY, or they can't send them to NY? I got the same message for Maryland, so I just sent them to my friend's place in Virginia.

Re: 23andme for only $99 today only

#73
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah I guess it must be the quota. A pity, because I want to do it, but can't spare the cash yet.

I just ordered at the discount. Check the site again.

I've ordered as well. Looks like they were still working with it. My argument is still interesting, although no longer valid to this particular situation. Thanks for the update.

Re: 23andme for only $99 today only

#74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, today they're 23andme, arguably in fairly rough waters (which is probably the reason for this promotion in the first place). Tomorrow they could be sold to the highest bidder, who might not feel they were bound to the terms of service of their predecessor. It could be an insurance company, for instance. And based on your name, your genetic data and a whole bunch of other factors they might decide to deny you or…

Remember that one of the key investors is Sergey Brin, so "Don't be evil" would apply to 23andMe. Sergey is married to the co-founder of 23andMe, Anne Wojcicki.

"Don't be evil" is at this point no more than a marketing slogan and I really don't see how it would apply to 23andme.

Read their privacy policy first, then decide if you think that 23andme does not explicitly hold open the door to do 'evil'.

edit: afterthought, in fact, any company associated with Google in that way would probably be the last party to give even more private information to, they have enough, if not too much, already.

Re: 23andme for only $99 today only

#75
The dangerous thing about these tests is that they only show if you have a marker for a particular diseases/affliction . This doesn't mean that you'll get the disease - we're still amateurs at this technology and I don't know if I want to live my life perpetually fearful of a disease that I have a marker for, but no relevant data on what the chance that I'll actually get that disease.

Re: 23andme for only $99 today only

#76
post #75

The dangerous thing about these tests is that they only show if you have a marker for a particular diseases/affliction . This doesn't mean that you'll get the disease - we're still amateurs at this technology and I don't know if I want to live my life perpetually fearful of a disease that I have a marker for, but no relevant data on what the chance that I'll actually get that disease.

I think you have to take these results with a grain of salt. Its better to know ahead of time so you can begin to take steps to ensure that you dont have problems in the future. Genetic predispositions are only a factor, environment and other epigenetic factors also play a major role in determing your phenotype.

Re: 23andme for only $99 today only

#77
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not possible to do it anonymously?

I'm really not sure on how to make this even more clear, but your DNA is your identity, so when you give it to someone they have your identity and no amount of anonymization is going to change that. All you're missing is the metadata of 'name, date of birth, social security number' and so on. But that's just a system we've placed on top of 'who you are', which is your genes. Your fingerprint, your retina scan, your f…

So do identical twins count for one person?

Re: 23andme for only $99 today only

#78

What's the deal with the freaky message about not being able to send spit tests from NY State? Can anyone explain that issue to me?

In April 2008, New York State's Department of Health sent warning letters to six online genetic testing companies, including 23andme, notifying them that they cannot offer New York state residents genetic tests without a permit nor can they offer them without authorization from a physician. (wikipedia)

Re: 23andme for only $99 today only

#79
post #29

I Just bought six of these. I'm stoked - this is precisely what I've been waiting for for my family. I actually discovered I was lactose intolerant (after 30+ years) through 23andme - somehow that little detail got by me... :-)

So you discovered you were lactose intolerant after 30 years, and throughout those years, you've presumably been drinking milk. Don't you think you would've been just as fine growing old without knowing you couldn't break down lactose?

Heh - you clearly _aren't_ lactose intolerant. Through the simple (and relatively inexpensive) act of popping a lactase tablet before anything with milk, my life got a _whole_ lot better. It's embarrassing how much better things are. When I first got the results, I was like "Woah - 23andMe is broken - _I'm_ not Lactose intolerant" - that's what happens when you live with something your entire life - you baseline off a miserable experience and believe it to be the best you can do.

Genomics certainly improved my life. :-)

Re: 23andme for only $99 today only

#80
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wouldn't they be tied to the agreement that you had when you signed up for the data? I always thought that you'd have to agree with new "terms-of-use" whenever they change

Just to give you an example, I just bought at an auction the complete contents of a defunct company. Amongst the stuff I got was their servers and their bookkeeping. I never entered in to any agreement with the people whose data is stored on those servers, and yet I have all of it. A 'survival clause' that would guarantee destruction of your data in case the company goes out of business would be a minimum here. But i…

Looks like they do have a 'survival clause' in their privacy statment:

Business Transitions

In the event that 23andMe goes through a business transition such as a merger, acquisition by another company, or sale of all or a portion of its assets, your personal information and non-personal information will likely be among the assets transferred. You will be notified in advance via email and prominent notice on our website of any such change in ownership or control of your personal information. We will require an acquiring company or merger agreement to uphold the material terms of this privacy statement, including honoring requests for account deletion.

Post reply on HN