Live data from Hacker News

Vine will be discontinuing the mobile app

medium.com

31–40 of 166 posts

Re: Vine will be discontinuing the mobile app

#31

comScore reports just under 5m uniques for Vine.co last month. It may be down on the height of its popularity but 5m unique users is a decent mass of people to monetise. Seems an odd thing to kill and not at least try to sell.

How would you go about making any money off it though? Nobody's going to sit through an ad when the video is only a few seconds long

Re: Vine will be discontinuing the mobile app

#32

This is really annoying. I don't and haven't ever used vine, but how much could it really cost to keep hosting it, and let people continue using it? Why can't companies be okay having products that are revenue neutral that make people happy?

Everything needs maintenance.

Re: Vine will be discontinuing the mobile app

#34
This is pretty sad. I'm not a "proper" Vine user -- I don't even have the app installed -- but I've long loved seeing vines via Twitter or Tumblr. I hope a similar product comes along to fill the void and reunite the Vine community (introducing: YouTube Loops??).

Re: Vine will be discontinuing the mobile app

#35
post #31

comScore reports just under 5m uniques for Vine.co last month. It may be down on the height of its popularity but 5m unique users is a decent mass of people to monetise. Seems an odd thing to kill and not at least try to sell.

How would you go about making any money off it though? Nobody's going to sit through an ad when the video is only a few seconds long

I don't know the answer, but I do remember people saying that Google was making a huge mistake buying the unmonetizable YouTube.

Re: Vine will be discontinuing the mobile app

#37

Wow, I really like Vine and am surprised that Twitter's visions for its path to profitability don't include such a flourishing community. Sad news keeps coming today... :(

Maybe you could explain what's appealing about Vine? A lot of people don't understand what it offers over a tube site.

Re: Vine will be discontinuing the mobile app

#38

This is really annoying. I don't and haven't ever used vine, but how much could it really cost to keep hosting it, and let people continue using it? Why can't companies be okay having products that are revenue neutral that make people happy?

Because then people turn around and complain that it's not being improved. Seriously, you can't win here.

If you kill it because it costs something and you have no plan to ever keep it going, people complain

If you let it live but just "keep it working", people also complain.

Additionally, killing it brings certain nice guarantees, like, for example, "you can stop worrying about security bugs, privacy bugs, etc at some point" because it's gone.

You can't really just keep stuff working anymore, even in the simple case, new attacks get found that apply to old code, etc.

When those things get busted, or bad things happen, people complain about it.

As for "why not just put one person on it", there's a multitude of reasons. Let's start with "what is the career path for a guy who does nothing but keep a dead product walking?"

So in reality, what people want is "keep focusing on products i care about". But that isn't always a viable model.

Re: Vine will be discontinuing the mobile app

#39
That's fucking stupid. I wasn't crazy about Vine but Twitter was first to market with a brandable property taht quickly became A Thing. It was the one innovative thing to come out of Twitter in the last few years, and now they're shutting it down. If I had any Twitter stock I would dump it all on this news.
Post reply on HN