Live data from Hacker News

Planet Money: Self Checkout [audio]

npr.org

41–46 of 46 posts

Re: Planet Money: Self Checkout [audio]

#41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Rather, you don't get a discount for using the self-checkout. The price you are paying has the cost of a human cashier built into it. If you use self-checkout, you're providing that service yourself for free, but the company still collects the premium they charge for human service.

the machines don't cost anything?

They do, but way less than a human employee (or else they wouldn't use the machines.)

Re: Planet Money: Self Checkout [audio]

#42
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To me it's a lot like pumping your own gas. It's weird when I go back to NJ and have to sit in the car and wait for the one dude working on 6 pumps. But if you talk to people from NJ who have never been outside of NJ it would seem obvious that someone else does it. All of the comments in this thread against self service are the exact arguments NJ people have against pumping your own gas.

I've never had a pump in NJ or elsewhere not work. Self-checkout machines on the other hand, don't work often. That's the difference.

I've never come across a self-checkout machine that doesn't work, but that's just anecdotal. It seems silly to base one's general opinion on the concept of self-checkout machines on how broken the ones you've experienced are. When I was traveling, I spent time in countries where toilets would back up more often than not, and that didn't make me think "Toilets are ridiculous,why do they exist".

Re: Planet Money: Self Checkout [audio]

#43
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've never had a pump in NJ or elsewhere not work. Self-checkout machines on the other hand, don't work often. That's the difference.

I don't know what you're basing that on, I live in Australia and I've never had a self checkout machine not work. They are consistently good and I use them all the time.

Note that the machines have many tolerances that can be set to trade-off theft vs. annoyance of the customer. (E.g. the product weight when placed in the bagging area.) The machines can we way less annoying when they are set to be more trusting.

I also generally found them to work better in Australia than in the US, though the technology seems to be the same. I guess it's because of these tolerances being set differently, but that's just speculation.

Re: Planet Money: Self Checkout [audio]

#44
If I can scan the item and then place it in the bag, I have no problem using self checkout machines. (The local CVS and Harris-Teeter stores, for example.) If I scan the item and can't bag it; but, have to put it on a belt and let it go to the bagging end? I rarely use it. Why? I want to bag my groceries without worrying about bagging those of the person behind me. If I scan everything, pay, and then start bagging, the majority of the time, the person behind me starts scanning their items before I'm done bagging.

Re: Planet Money: Self Checkout [audio]

#45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't know what you're basing that on, I live in Australia and I've never had a self checkout machine not work. They are consistently good and I use them all the time.

Note that the machines have many tolerances that can be set to trade-off theft vs. annoyance of the customer. (E.g. the product weight when placed in the bagging area.) The machines can we way less annoying when they are set to be more trusting. I also generally found them to work better in Australia than in the US, though the technology seems to be the same. I guess it's because of these tolerances being set differe…

You could be correct, just recently the Australian supermarkets announced a crackdown on self-checkout theft (mentioned in the podcast) which would seem unlikely if tolerances weren't currently lenient. In the last week the Coles supermarket I went to had rolled out entirely new software / UI on the machines, and for the first time in ages there were long self checkout queues and people seemed to be taking longer.

Re: Planet Money: Self Checkout [audio]

#46
post #8

I always refuse to use Self Checkout, even when a store clerk offers to operate it for me. The process always takes longer than doing it "the old fashioned way". Maybe it's because I'm over 50, but I prefer face-to-face interaction with a cashier. BTW, I'm not a technophobe by any measure. I'm probably more tech savvy than most people here.

If I have less than 5 items, the self checkout is usually faster but anything over that and then it's just too trouble to do all that stuff myself. For one single item, which happens sometimes, it can be significantly more efficient.

I wonder if that's part of the disconnect for people - I love self checkout, but I live alone, all my shopping fits in one basket, and I walk to & from the store. If you're shopping for a family and filling a whole shopping cart to take to a car, you probably have more items than are reasonable for efficient self checkout.
Post reply on HN