Live data from Hacker News

The Ultimate Guide To Getting Nowhere In Life

garyharan.com

11–20 of 90 posts

Re: The Ultimate Guide To Getting Nowhere In Life

#11
post #8
post #7

I think his offhand implication that reading books is superior to TV is wrong. Most fiction has exactly the same purpose and function on TV, which is to entertain. Yes, reading some books makes you "cultured" but so does TV; just to a different culture. I consider watching all the latest sci fi to be just as "culturing" as reading all the latest sci fi.

Reading makes you better at reading (duh) and writing. Two essential skills that are used daily. What skills does your TV gives to you?

Passively sitting down with the latest Dan Brown novel won't make you any better at reading or writing. Sitting down with a novel that's just beyond your comfort zone (say, Dostoevsky if you're used to Dan Brown) will make you better at reading, and sitting down with any novel and actively paying attention to how the writer shapes the story with words will make you better at writing. But that's an apples-to-sushi comparison: it takes a lot more mental effort to actively engage with a book than it does to passively sit in front of a TV. A more appropriate comparison would be actively reading vs. playing Starcraft, which gives you a bunch of essential skills, eg. multitasking, resource management, positioning & prioritization, etc.

Basically, you get out of any activity what you put into it. If you put zero effort into reading, you're going to get zero skill out of it.

Re: The Ultimate Guide To Getting Nowhere In Life

#13
post #7

I think his offhand implication that reading books is superior to TV is wrong. Most fiction has exactly the same purpose and function on TV, which is to entertain. Yes, reading some books makes you "cultured" but so does TV; just to a different culture. I consider watching all the latest sci fi to be just as "culturing" as reading all the latest sci fi.

Reading is entertainment that requires thought and imagination. While you're reading, it's easy and common to stop and reflect over what has just been said. Not so with video.

When you watch a sci fi movie, you see the world the filmmaker has built. When you read a sci fi book, you build the world the author describes in your head. Value judgments aside, they're very different experiences.

Re: The Ultimate Guide To Getting Nowhere In Life

#15
post #7

I think his offhand implication that reading books is superior to TV is wrong. Most fiction has exactly the same purpose and function on TV, which is to entertain. Yes, reading some books makes you "cultured" but so does TV; just to a different culture. I consider watching all the latest sci fi to be just as "culturing" as reading all the latest sci fi.

Theodore Roosevelt read two books a day and could recite quotations from them years later.

The average TV in the US is on 6 hours per day.

Would you rather be the average American or Theodore Roosevelt?

Re: The Ultimate Guide To Getting Nowhere In Life

#17
post #15
post #7

I think his offhand implication that reading books is superior to TV is wrong. Most fiction has exactly the same purpose and function on TV, which is to entertain. Yes, reading some books makes you "cultured" but so does TV; just to a different culture. I consider watching all the latest sci fi to be just as "culturing" as reading all the latest sci fi.

Theodore Roosevelt read two books a day and could recite quotations from them years later. The average TV in the US is on 6 hours per day. Would you rather be the average American or Theodore Roosevelt?

The average American. Theodore Roosevelt is dead after all. :-)

Re: The Ultimate Guide To Getting Nowhere In Life

#18
post #8
post #7

I think his offhand implication that reading books is superior to TV is wrong. Most fiction has exactly the same purpose and function on TV, which is to entertain. Yes, reading some books makes you "cultured" but so does TV; just to a different culture. I consider watching all the latest sci fi to be just as "culturing" as reading all the latest sci fi.

Reading makes you better at reading (duh) and writing. Two essential skills that are used daily. What skills does your TV gives to you?

That would be a good point if I were 8 years old.

However, my vocabulary is unlikely to increase anymore.

Re: The Ultimate Guide To Getting Nowhere In Life

#19
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Reading makes you better at reading (duh) and writing. Two essential skills that are used daily. What skills does your TV gives to you?

Passively sitting down with the latest Dan Brown novel won't make you any better at reading or writing. Sitting down with a novel that's just beyond your comfort zone (say, Dostoevsky if you're used to Dan Brown) will make you better at reading, and sitting down with any novel and actively paying attention to how the writer shapes the story with words will make you better at writing. But that's an apples-to-sushi com…

The reading I did as a child was well beyond what other children my age were reading, but it never required "effort," because it was pleasurable.

It's a mistake to think that activities which require no effort are useless.

Post reply on HN