Live data from Hacker News

Why We Should All Dump Yahoo

dumpyahoo.com

51–60 of 102 posts

Re: Why We Should All Dump Yahoo

#51
post #48

"...I care about my own privacy and security..." and yet your website has no encryption. Thus, when I enter my details on your form, it is being passed over the same internet in plaintext, thereby violating the exact "privacy and security" this "protest" aims to create.

Well, I think the concept here is to publicly pledge to dump yahoo, in order to convince & pressure others to do the same. Saying you care about your privacy and security doesn't mean you remove yourself from all forms of public expression. It's the most basic form of free speech. If you want to privately pledge, just write it down on a sticky note, and put it on your monitor.

Still. I think its a bit absurd.

Re: Why We Should All Dump Yahoo

#53
post #48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, I think the concept here is to publicly pledge to dump yahoo, in order to convince & pressure others to do the same. Saying you care about your privacy and security doesn't mean you remove yourself from all forms of public expression. It's the most basic form of free speech. If you want to privately pledge, just write it down on a sticky note, and put it on your monitor.

Still. I think its a bit absurd.

This is a site collecting information for a public petition. By definition your GOAL is to share your information publicly. How is it absurd to do so in the open?

Re: Why We Should All Dump Yahoo

#55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To be fair, according to this article, Google, Microsoft, Apple, and others have explicitly denied allowing government officials direct access to their servers. However, due to the secrecy requirements of the law, we cannot know if they did allow the government some other form of access that was functionally equivalent to a rootkit on the server in terms of what the government could access. Pure speculation on my par…

> To be fair, according to this article, Google, Microsoft, Apple, and others have explicitly denied allowing government officials direct access to their servers. Right, but the statements were very carefully crafted PR statements that only implied that there were no similar feeds while leaving open the possibility that there may be. Having watching the industry for some time (Skype's PR denials come to mind as well…

Bruce Schneier agrees with you, which lends your argument some credence to me, but I thought "We’ve never received a request like this, and were we to receive it we’d challenge it in a court" was about as broad and clear a statement as could reasonably be made about this. What would you need them to say?

Re: Why We Should All Dump Yahoo

#56
If we wanted to show that we weren't letting them do this without consequence, we'd be suing Yahoo and the Gov't like real Americans. We'd be suing for such an egregious amount that our national debt would look like a bit of pocket change. We would threaten the very life and livelihood of this country if we TRULY cared about our rights and privacy.

But no, instead you want us to sign a petition.

Give me a break.

Re: Why We Should All Dump Yahoo

#57
post #2

While I agree with the sentiment. Here's why you should not delete your yahoo account. Once you delete your account, yahoo will make it available again to everyone. This means that if you have not unlinked everything it can be used by others to reset accounts on services you forgot that you linked to your yahoo account. Instead of deleting it, forward it all to another account and stop using it. Do not forget to log…

Isn't your E-mail address used as the username in most services' credentials? So you should know which services you registered using your Yahoo E-mail address because that's what you use to log in. Just go in and change them over to using your new address. For those few that don't use E-mail, take a Sunday afternoon and log in to each of them to check. Surely it couldn't be that difficult.

I just checked LastPass; 324 out of 770 of my accounts use an email address as the username.

Re: Why We Should All Dump Yahoo

#58

"...I care about my own privacy and security..." and yet your website has no encryption. Thus, when I enter my details on your form, it is being passed over the same internet in plaintext, thereby violating the exact "privacy and security" this "protest" aims to create.

The form action appears to use https. But yeah, it is 2016 and https should be the norm for even just loading pages with forms.

Re: Why We Should All Dump Yahoo

#59
post #44

Should I drop dropbox, google, apple, MS, CloudFare, LinkedIn, Ebay + paypal, amazon, MasterCard and Visa for the same reasons?

Doing so is just so increasingly limiting on our lives. What might be a more ideal scenario is to change the government's priorities, and enact strict(er) privacy laws that prevent these and other companies from sharing our data, or to be able to speak out when a hidden government department asks them to keep it under wraps.

From the listed above I have only amazon, linkedin and MasterCard anyway, so not that limiting.
Post reply on HN