Live data from Hacker News

Yahoo makes it difficult to leave its service by disabling email forwarding

techcrunch.com

31–40 of 82 posts

Re: Yahoo makes it difficult to leave its service by disabling email forwarding

#31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Where does it say that Google Domains has free GMail integration? All I'm seeing is G Suite integration for $5/month extra.

You have to use the Email Forwarding section in Google Domains, then set it up from within GMail. GMail Settings > Accounts and Import > Send Mail As > Add another email address you own. I remember it taking a few tries to get all the Domains info right, but I can send and receive email from any of my Google-managed domains from within GMail. You can try Googling for updated instructions if these don't still work: ht…

Does it still include your real email address in the headers?

Re: Yahoo makes it difficult to leave its service by disabling email forwarding

#32
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You have to use the Email Forwarding section in Google Domains, then set it up from within GMail. GMail Settings > Accounts and Import > Send Mail As > Add another email address you own. I remember it taking a few tries to get all the Domains info right, but I can send and receive email from any of my Google-managed domains from within GMail. You can try Googling for updated instructions if these don't still work: ht…

Does it still include your real email address in the headers?

Yes it does.

Re: Yahoo makes it difficult to leave its service by disabling email forwarding

#33
Almost all mail providers offer some sort of mail collection feature via POP3 which can be used as an alternative to mail forwarding. The disadvantage is that you'll have some time delay (depending on how often your provider allows you to fetch mail). The advantage is that you aren't relying on any feature of the old mail provider. As long as it still provides POP3 you're all good - and I find it unlikely that yahoo will disable POP3.

(not saying this to justify Yahoo's rogue move here, but to give advice to people who have this problem)

Re: Yahoo makes it difficult to leave its service by disabling email forwarding

#34
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If all you want is the email address, you can simply transfer your domain to Google Domains and use their free GMail integration. That'll save you $48/year assuming you don't value any of the other paid features in Google Apps.

I'd be afraid of Google's control over my domain name registration. Even if they don't do anything malicious, their "wall of silence" with respect to support leaves me very apprehensive. (Some people say it's different for paid-product support, but I don't know whether this includes $12/year domain name registration -- or will so in future.)

There's also the fact that Google loves to abruptly drop support for various services on a seeming whim.

Granted they always leave a transition period, but doing anything involving domains is a pain I'd rather not touch until I have to.

Re: Yahoo makes it difficult to leave its service by disabling email forwarding

#35
post #28
post #14

Just last week I noticed a charge on my credit cars from Yahoo Ad Free mail. There was an online link to cancel but no apparent way to request a refund. I have no idea how I ended up getting signed up for this. I've long used Yahoo as pretty much a spam bucket when I have to give out an address to someone I don't care to get emails from. (For all I know, I somehow got signed up a while back but I certainly am not awa…

it is a scam not associated with yahoo in any way, i heard. the credit card scammers just use the fact that almost everyone in the US has a yahoo email.

I was apparently signed up on Yahoo though as in I was able to log in to Yahoo and cancel the service. Which I assumed made the charge "legitimate" whether or not a refund was offered. I was thinking of disputing it but was inclined not to bother. Maybe I'll take a further look.

Re: Yahoo makes it difficult to leave its service by disabling email forwarding

#36
I worked at a school helpdesk for a while, and I saw that whenever school email accounts were hacked, the attackers would set up forwarding to some other account. People wouldn't notice the forwarding for weeks or longer, and would only come in to us by chance. In the meantime, a lot of information could be siphoned off.

There could be some legitimate security concerns there, especially since most yahoo accounts don't have a convenient and free help desk to stop by, right?

(Disclaimer: I am only a novice when it comes to security, I could be totally off base)

Re: Yahoo makes it difficult to leave its service by disabling email forwarding

#38

I worked at a school helpdesk for a while, and I saw that whenever school email accounts were hacked, the attackers would set up forwarding to some other account. People wouldn't notice the forwarding for weeks or longer, and would only come in to us by chance. In the meantime, a lot of information could be siphoned off. There could be some legitimate security concerns there, especially since most yahoo accounts don'…

There is a very easy solution to this, which I believe Gmail employs: Place a very noticeable banner on the inbox when all your email is being forwarded to another address.

Re: Yahoo makes it difficult to leave its service by disabling email forwarding

#40

I worked at a school helpdesk for a while, and I saw that whenever school email accounts were hacked, the attackers would set up forwarding to some other account. People wouldn't notice the forwarding for weeks or longer, and would only come in to us by chance. In the meantime, a lot of information could be siphoned off. There could be some legitimate security concerns there, especially since most yahoo accounts don'…

There is a very easy solution to this, which I believe Gmail employs: Place a very noticeable banner on the inbox when all your email is being forwarded to another address.

That's assuming everyone composes e-mails through the web UI. Maybe they don't want to make that assumption.
Post reply on HN