Live data from Hacker News

Google Allo – First Impression

prodissues.com

61–70 of 102 posts

Re: Google Allo – First Impression

#61
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are there email servers aimed at Linux noobs?

Not really and the whole thing is a huge pain the ass if you want your emails to be received by Gmail/Yahoo/etc. recipients.

not that big pain in the ass once you get DKIM, DMARC and SPF working...

Re: Google Allo – First Impression

#62

If there are any Googlers on here reading this, some free unsolicited advice from me to you: GMail is awesome. It made email 10 times better and easier (for me anyways) to use. Here's an idea: GText. Despite all the products that have come out, we still refer to texting as, well, texting. So, mail:GMail::text:GText. Here's my problem with Apple's iMessages: they take up all this space on my phone. And when I change p…

[deleted]

Re: Google Allo – First Impression

#63
post #7

If there are any Googlers on here reading this, some free unsolicited advice from me to you: GMail is awesome. It made email 10 times better and easier (for me anyways) to use. Here's an idea: GText. Despite all the products that have come out, we still refer to texting as, well, texting. So, mail:GMail::text:GText. Here's my problem with Apple's iMessages: they take up all this space on my phone. And when I change p…

You're in luck! There is a little-known product made by Google called Hangouts[0]. It is cross platform: iOS, Android, Web, and has native apps for Windows and macOS. It stores your texts in the cloud forever, lets you send emojis and images, files, lets you video chat from any platform to any platform, and every single person with a gmail account already has it! Bonus: on Android phones it can also send SMS and MMS,…

Little known? You must be kidding. It has more than 1 Billion installations [0].

It's pre-installed on every Android Handset and is the designated successor to Google Talk, a once great XMPP chat service which had offered real xmpp federation until Google rebranded it to Hangouts. I really liked Google Talk back then, Hangouts gradually made it worse and worse.

The hurdles to onboard new chat members are too big (you need a G Account, needed a Google Plus profile at some time). While the G Account is a given on Android phones, it's a big hurdle for adding iOS users. The process is buggy as well: After adding an account for a friend, we often had to wait 1-2 days to "find" the person on Hangouts and be able to add them to the group chat.

On top of that, the app is slow slow slow (the browser chat as well).

As a community moderator I had to deal with above issues constantly but we kept using Hangouts for years... despite its shortcomings. Ultimately though, we abandoned it and switched to Telegram. Much faster mobile Apps, super easy onboarding for new members and a great Browser client as well (plus the company is FOSS friendly, allows custom implementations).

The Hangouts dev team even knows about its bad reputation and the product manager even acknowledged that at some time [0]: "P.S. Unlike what the /r/Android subreddit says, the Hangouts team does come to work every morning trying to make it better :)"

[0]: https://plus.google.com/+MayurKamat/posts/T1FNqgAWzgE

Re: Google Allo – First Impression

#64
post #22

The more proprietary chat platforms that arise, the more I want to see Matrix[1] / Riot[2] succeed. Communication networks should not be corporate controlled walled gardens. [1]: https://matrix.org [2]: https://matrix.org/docs/projects/client/riot-ios.html https://matrix.org/docs/projects/client/riot-android.html

I'm just waiting for Matrix to get E2E going... For now, XMPP works well enough.

To be honest, I don't even think E2E is as important in a distributed system. If you're worried about who can see your messages, you can just set up your own server and force server-to-server and client-to-server encryption.

Re: Google Allo – First Impression

#65
post #35

The more proprietary chat platforms that arise, the more I want to see Matrix[1] / Riot[2] succeed. Communication networks should not be corporate controlled walled gardens. [1]: https://matrix.org [2]: https://matrix.org/docs/projects/client/riot-ios.html https://matrix.org/docs/projects/client/riot-android.html

I'm surprised that email is not corporate controlled yet. What did email do right that chat did wrong? Afaik, there was once a good standard for chat.

E-Mail predates the commercialisation of the net. When the first companies came everybody already had a mail address, thus everybody depends on it (I.e. for registration, password lost, ...) Thus everybody still needs a mail address even though (in my observation) actual communication moves to WhatsApp and FB messenger.

Re: Google Allo – First Impression

#66
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are there email servers aimed at Linux noobs?

Not really and the whole thing is a huge pain the ass if you want your emails to be received by Gmail/Yahoo/etc. recipients.

You can get round this by 'smarthosting' your outgoing mail. Typically this is your ISPs SMTP relay server. For example, I host my own Mail environment (MS Exchange, not that it's relevant) and all my outgoing mail is sent directly via SMTP to my ISPs smarthost. That smarthost then directs it where it needs to go based on the recipients domain. This way you are not sending mail directly from your 'untrusted' mail server, into say, Google or Yahoo.

I know from experience that I have to smarthost, as Gmail and Hotmail/Outlook.com reject silently any mail that come direct from my mail server. It's a pain, but there are solutions out there.

Re: Google Allo – First Impression

#67

I see a lot of people asking why not club this feature (and Duo) into Hangouts. I use Hangouts too, but it looks like they'd grown too complicated for a common user who wanted to 'just' do a quick text chat or a quick video chat. Hangouts had chat, SMS, video, phone calling and what not. While I didn't see any problem at all with that and found that good (except the UI that was still not good), probably it's a little…

What I find useful about Hangouts is SMS history backups. Android should backup SMSes when moving to a new phone.

Re: Google Allo – First Impression

#68
post #7

If there are any Googlers on here reading this, some free unsolicited advice from me to you: GMail is awesome. It made email 10 times better and easier (for me anyways) to use. Here's an idea: GText. Despite all the products that have come out, we still refer to texting as, well, texting. So, mail:GMail::text:GText. Here's my problem with Apple's iMessages: they take up all this space on my phone. And when I change p…

You're in luck! There is a little-known product made by Google called Hangouts[0]. It is cross platform: iOS, Android, Web, and has native apps for Windows and macOS. It stores your texts in the cloud forever, lets you send emojis and images, files, lets you video chat from any platform to any platform, and every single person with a gmail account already has it! Bonus: on Android phones it can also send SMS and MMS,…

I just tried it out. Despite of using GMail for years, I didn't know Google had created hangouts.google.com. :-)

Just tried it out and to my disappointment, it doesn't allow me to send a file other than images to other users. Google engineers if you are listening please add the ability to send docs and files to other users!

Re: Google Allo – First Impression

#69
post #54
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm surprised that email is not corporate controlled yet. What did email do right that chat did wrong? Afaik, there was once a good standard for chat.

Email allows just enough delay for antispam to do its work in, plus a whole range of antispam solutions involving backoff. Chat requires much lower latency. Any federated/distributed chat system would have to deal with spam and abuse upfront in its design, or people would just migrate back towards controlled systems without those problems. There's a second issue of where the chat continuity should be kept across devi…

> Email allows just enough delay for antispam to do its work in

One solution is to only check for spam if the sender is not in your address book. And with chat, you usually have to allow somebody in your address book.

Re: Google Allo – First Impression

#70
post #47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is why you should run your own mail server. Email, along with the web, is the last part of the decentralised internet to exist. Don't let it die.

Are there email servers aimed at Linux noobs?

I doubt that being a noob is compatible with running a mailserver for many reasons.

I've seen this mentioned a few times on HN: https://mailinabox.email/

No experience with it myself.

Post reply on HN