Live data from Hacker News

What does a kilowatt hour look like?

blog.kubakuzma.com

81–90 of 147 posts

Re: What does a kilowatt hour look like?

#81
post #48

> David McCay - Sustainable Energy without the Hot Air A fantastic book. A Caltech trained physicist at Cambridge does the calculations to see if the UK could get all its energy needs sustainably. Simple, easy to understand, and enlightening. It deserves the praise they talk about. And it's free to download.

Sustainable Energy Without the Hot Air Free from the author's website: http://www.withouthotair.com/download.html

Re: What does a kilowatt hour look like?

#82
I was just commenting today how approachable this book makes understanding the requirements to transition to renewable energy. I would warn though that the little bit of economics and the discussions about battery storage and solar PV at the end are very dated. The exponential drop in pv prices wasn't anticipated by the author. I think if modern prices were used the 5 models at the end would look very different.

Re: What does a kilowatt hour look like?

#83

If you like this, watch the videos from this guy: https://www.youtube.com/user/jehugarcia he methodically tests old 18650 laptop cells, sorts them, builds battery packs and so on. He's converted a classic VW bus to electric power using his home-made battery packs and packs salvaged from wrecked teslas.

> wrecked teslas Wait what? where is this supply at

California, mostly, but not exactly a common thing yet. Will increase as more cars are totaled in rollovers or other crashes that mess up all of the body work.

Re: What does a kilowatt hour look like?

#84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The key to batteries is being able to use the stored energy. Bonus points if you can add energy and get it back later.

Thermite :p

I know it's frowned upon saying this, but damn if I didn't choke on my coffee haha.

Yeah let's not use thermite to heat our houses people.

Re: What does a kilowatt hour look like?

#85

If you like this, watch the videos from this guy: https://www.youtube.com/user/jehugarcia he methodically tests old 18650 laptop cells, sorts them, builds battery packs and so on. He's converted a classic VW bus to electric power using his home-made battery packs and packs salvaged from wrecked teslas.

> wrecked teslas Wait what? where is this supply at

Copart is a good site for buying wrecked cars in various conditions. Otherwise try calling your local junk yards.

http://www.copart.com/us/search?q=tesla

Re: What does a kilowatt hour look like?

#87

Given how popular (and damn near impossible to discern) unsafe and unprotected lithium-ion batteries are, the idea of making a homegrown power wall terrifies me in ways I can't even begin to contemplate. An 18650 battery, if combusted, can produce hydrofluoric acid with just water vapor in the air (or the water in your lungs) if they use lithium hexafluorophosphate as the electrolyte. Hydrofluoric acid can and will c…

I think your concerns are somewhat alarmist and tend to be a bit scaremongering. You may want to read an actual study about just how much HF is present in the fumes of burning cells. In this one, near the end they burned a whole laptop pack and analysed the gases that were emitted: http://www.brandforsk.se/MediaBinaryLoader.axd?MediaArchive_... The relevant datapoint is on page 61: "As seen the yields of HF is much l…

The PF6 ions in the electrolyte of some Li-ion batteries (not all use the same chemistry) will readily combine with hydrogen in the air to form HF if the battery is combusting. Cylindrical Li-ion cells, like those part of an 18650 battery, literally hold their chemistry under pressure, and a thermal runaway will normally cause the vents in the cell to release the pressure.

If that's happening due to a short (which can and does happen when a cell is charged improperly, or even put under resistive load after the cell is discharged below a safe limit -- copper or other ions, depending again on battery chemistry, can literally bridge across the electrolyte to short the cathode and anode) the result of the release of pressure combined with the reactive nature of now exposed lithium is a small rocket that shoots a plume of gasses like sulfur dioxide or hydrofluoric acid. Again, this depends largely on battery chemistry, and without an MSDS on these particular cells, there's no way to know. But there's a reason why any chemist you care to phone up will say, if you tell them you're in possession of a cylinder of a compressed compound that contains fluorine (it won't matter what kind, fluorine really really likes to bond promiscuously and with reckless abandon), they'll tell you that you're braver they are. Tell them you're intend to string up a few hundred of them and pass an electric current into them, and they'll call a hazmat team for you.

A casual stroll through forums frequented by flashlight fans (yeah, it's a thing) and you'll see plenty of demonstrations of what happens when a Li-ion cell begins a thermal runaway. And plenty of memorials to those who gave up their passion because they're on ventilators after experiencing profound damage to their lung tissues. Hell, ask the firefighters that respond to a fire at a battery recycling plant; granted, that's a bigger scale than one cell, but even one cell in a small room can, depending on its chemistry and how violently it's outgassing, emit enough HF to cause lung damage.

Read an MSDS yourself: http://www.uscg.mil/hq/cg4/cg432/docs/msds/MSDS_LiIon.pdf

LiPo "pouches" mentioned elsewhere in this thread are much less likely to explode spectacularly before bursting, and much less likely to exhaust a plume of corrosive, toxic chemicals in their wake.

Re: What does a kilowatt hour look like?

#88

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wow so I could gather up a bunch of cans and heat my house.

The key to batteries is being able to use the stored energy. Bonus points if you can add energy and get it back later.

Metal-air batteries are a thing.

Re: What does a kilowatt hour look like?

#90

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You have to realize that 1kWh is a lot of energy. Imagine being hit (in a world without an atmosphere) by a 60 pound suitcase falling out of an airliner flying at 45,000 feet. Same amount of energy as that battery pack. (Alternatively: the most powerful air conditioner you can buy running full blast for 30 minutes. Incidentally, that battery pack has as much energy as 100mL of gasoline, which is why gasoline-powered…

Even a single AAA battery has a lot of energy 5,071 J according to http://www.allaboutbatteries.com/Energy-tables.html . My point of reference I use to imagine energy is a major league baseball player hits a baseball with 1,234 J. 1KW/h is 3,600,000 J.

In other words: 1 kWh is the equivalent of the average MLB player hitting a home run roughly every 1.2 seconds.
Post reply on HN