Live data from Hacker News

Google Trips is a killer travel app for the modern tourist

theverge.com

41–50 of 92 posts

Re: Google Trips is a killer travel app for the modern tourist

#41
post #28

A "Travel app" that shows so many clichés condensed in its presentation video (and to top it all, a goat in a spanish street?) hints of enormous amounts of ignorance about the destination. And even feels insulting ... I'll stick to my carrier with free voice and data roaming in UK-EU-US for reading TripAdvisor/Yelp reviews... and a normal GPS Navigator for moving around. Also, maybe Google has missed the minor detail…

TL;DR: smugness usually works better when you actually have something relevant to say. Yeesh, this comment is almost embarrassing. Far be it from me to educate the "well-traveled", but I suppose I'll be the one to tell you that the world is larger than the US, EU and UK: I recently spent nine months traveling around 5 continents and less than one month of that was in any of those places. On top of that, the assertion…

The thing is they are marketing it for Spain (or European travel) in their video [0]. Maybe because Spain, France and Italy are in the top 4 travel destinations world-wide along with the US...

The focus of my critique (rant?) is that the presentation video only shows:

1- Ignorance about the destination with so many clichés and misleading stereotypes.

2- disrespect for many locals (like me)

> I'll be the one to tell you that the world is larger than the US, EU and UK

Brilliant observation, but if you are marketing your app for European travel, don't mislead travellers showing goats in a Barcelona street and show respect for the locals.

> The assertion that having data is a perfect replacement for an offline travel guide is a bizarre one.

Where is that assertion? It's a personal preference. As you may know there's not a single/universal way of travelling, there's also people that might prefer a satellite phone... Your preference of connectivity is irrelevant, but for many people having free wifi/4g renders this offline-first app useless in european soil.

Whenever I've visited the americas (north/south) a working SIM with a data plan has been enough for me...

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ign2GmVEflw

Re: Google Trips is a killer travel app for the modern tourist

#42
post #28

A "Travel app" that shows so many clichés condensed in its presentation video (and to top it all, a goat in a spanish street?) hints of enormous amounts of ignorance about the destination. And even feels insulting ... I'll stick to my carrier with free voice and data roaming in UK-EU-US for reading TripAdvisor/Yelp reviews... and a normal GPS Navigator for moving around. Also, maybe Google has missed the minor detail…

2020? that's like a century away in internet years.

By 2020 Internet-less may become the killer experience :)

Re: Google Trips is a killer travel app for the modern tourist

#43

I hope they'll make a desktop web version of this app, because planning everything (what you want to see, where you want to eat, etc.) on a small screen is tedious. For all my previous trips I have used Google My Maps [0], which is good but not great: on mobile, the places you added to your layers don't contain any Google Maps information, such as opening hours, and you even need to have data to get the name of a pla…

In Google Maps you can now add labels to places. And there is some support for emoji, which makes it almost as good as My Maps.

Re: Google Trips is a killer travel app for the modern tourist

#44
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

One annoying issue I had is that even though Google Now properly identified my air travel ticket and even displayed a notification with my boarding pass QR code, the way Inbox bundles messages made it extremely hard to find that QR code. For some reason it decided to show me everything else but the contents of the actual e-mail. I'm generally happy about Inbox/Google Now features, but this one was a small annoyance i…

>but this one was a small annoyance in my trip this month There are others. Unfortunately (for the airlines I use at least) there's no way for Google Now to know that a re-booked flight is not a new flight. I routinely need to change flight dates/times several times, but still get Google Now notifications for the original flights. I've had mild panic attacks on several occasions when I saw the "you need to have left…

I've had the exact same experience with re-booked flights. As you've alluded to, Google Now etc actually makes that experience more confusing.

Re: Google Trips is a killer travel app for the modern tourist

#45

this solves only 1 part of the problem. at least based on the video, it seems like you'd need to have the hotel and places pre-selected. that's not how it usually works for me. I find having to plan a trip with all the restaurants/hotels/bars to visit beforehand incredibly painful so prefer to just choose the major cities/towns, and explore them after getting there. I also prefer the advice of locals vs tourists that…

The new Google Destinations web app is intended to solve the other half: pick your flights and hotel.

Re: Google Trips is a killer travel app for the modern tourist

#46
So far I am very impressed with their collection of places to see (groupings too!), and their ability to guess how long you might go to each location.

The app isn't perfect, but these features alone are worth adding to the collection of travel apps for sure.

Re: Google Trips is a killer travel app for the modern tourist

#47
post #34

I'm using it right now, and it looks like I can't share the details of my next trip with my trip mates. This is kind of a deal breaker. Anyone has the same issue? I love the idea though, picking a 48 hours list from someone. I wanted to do a website like that years ago, called 48hoursInaCity.com or something, where you could upvote a 48hours tour of the city and choose the one you wanted. Okay, second issue: I can't…

Yeah, I think the ability to share a trip with friends is required. I'm going on a trip later this year with a couple of friends and it would be nice if everyone had access to the information.

Re: Google Trips is a killer travel app for the modern tourist

#49

It's not a killer travel app at all, sorry. As of now I wouldn't trade having some Wikitravel pages offline for this Google Trips app. Let's wait and see before calling it a "killer travel app", shall we?

Wikivoyage, Wikitravel, I can never remembered which is the most up-to-date. There are some offline apps for them on iOS (okay not great) but they've worked for me abroad a few times. The ones that come to mind are Turdus and Voyageur, both free.

Re: Google Trips is a killer travel app for the modern tourist

#50

I hope they'll make a desktop web version of this app, because planning everything (what you want to see, where you want to eat, etc.) on a small screen is tedious. For all my previous trips I have used Google My Maps [0], which is good but not great: on mobile, the places you added to your layers don't contain any Google Maps information, such as opening hours, and you even need to have data to get the name of a pla…

Agree that Google custom maps on mobile could use some polish. I've been just starring places on Google Maps as a bucket list. This app seems to integrate with starred places.
Post reply on HN