Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: I am torn between whether I should do MBA or not. Thoughts?

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 37 posts

Ask HN: I am torn between whether I should do MBA or not. Thoughts?

#1
I work for one of the BIGCO. I am debating with myself whether I should go for MBA or not. I need some guidance from people who have done their MBA. I have bachelor degree in Engineering. I don't like or don't want to get MS degree. My academics are good and I can say I have a good chance of getting into top 10 schools for the MBA.

I am Manager in my current role and have 10 years of experience in software development. I want to move into executive management at a mid size or large company. I will be specifially looking for eMBA as opposed to MBA option.

1. Does it make sense to do eMBA?

2. I did some research for MBA salaries from top schools and it seems that MBA salaries are in range of $125k to $150k. I make around same range right now without MBA.

Is doing MBA beneficial for big jump?

3. Last question is, what is best way to get into executive management ?

Re: Ask HN: I am torn between whether I should do MBA or not. Thoughts?

#2
I'm a second year graduate student in CS and also debating getting an MBA.

I currently study optimization and machine learning, and in the future I'd like to lead a team of people studying similar topics. Initially, my goal was to stay an academia and become a professor, but now I believe I'd like to be in industry doing similar tasks.

Re: Ask HN: I am torn between whether I should do MBA or not. Thoughts?

#3
Though I don't have an MBA, everyone I know that's been through HBS recommends going for one reason and one reason alone: connections. You're there to meet people, make friends, and expand your network.

Since the goal is to network, you want to maximize your time there. I'd elect to go through the full 2 years.

Re: Ask HN: I am torn between whether I should do MBA or not. Thoughts?

#5
If you want to get into executive management and can get into a top school, getting an MBA is a good idea. Consider going the management consulting route. You'll get a substantial pay increase a couple of years out, and exiting to upper management after being a consultant is not uncommon.

I detect you're a non-native speaker. A noticeable accent is going to be bigger problem if you're gunning for executive management than in tech. I'd invest in some language coaching.

Re: Ask HN: I am torn between whether I should do MBA or not. Thoughts?

#6
post #3

Though I don't have an MBA, everyone I know that's been through HBS recommends going for one reason and one reason alone: connections. You're there to meet people, make friends, and expand your network. Since the goal is to network, you want to maximize your time there. I'd elect to go through the full 2 years.

Yes. Aim high.

Re: Ask HN: I am torn between whether I should do MBA or not. Thoughts?

#7

I'm a second year graduate student in CS and also debating getting an MBA. I currently study optimization and machine learning, and in the future I'd like to lead a team of people studying similar topics. Initially, my goal was to stay an academia and become a professor, but now I believe I'd like to be in industry doing similar tasks.

start doing stuff, stop going to school. don't "believe you'd like to be in the industry." BE in it to find out.

Re: Ask HN: I am torn between whether I should do MBA or not. Thoughts?

#8
Do not have an MBA, but many friends who have gone to the top 3-5 schools, as well as some who did eMBA/part-time MBA programs.

There are a few worthwhile reasons to get an MBA, but one really trumps the rest.

As some others have said, the overwhelming value of an MBA is to build strong relationships with future business leaders. End of story. If you don't want to spend 2 years doing that and pay for it, don't do an MBA.

Those I've talked with that did an eMBA mostly regretted it because they were incredibly busy, and barely had time to meet anyone in the program, let alone build strong relationships with them.

If you don't have much background in management or business (most of which you can get from reading books) the course material will be helpful, but you could just as easily learn it on the job - if you can get the job. That is the other reason to get an MBA; to get into a company who requires it, though these are increasingly become less mandatory.

There are many answers to the question of how to get to executive management, but I think a very common one, which is likely to work for most people is the following: work at a service provider which gives you some strong functional/business skills (e.g., consulting, investment banking, equity research, marketing strategy, etc.). Do well there, but don't stay too long. From there, take a middle-management role (e.g, director, VP) at a corporation that is growing fairly quickly. Make your way up, and probably switch to another firm if you're not advancing quickly where you are.

Be careful of the trap of not having operating responsibility - you won't have this as a consultant or investment banker. If you don't have experience owning a P&L, you can't be trusted to do so even if you smart and capable. You could be in corporate strategy, corporate development, etc. but those are not true executive management roles.

Wow that went longer than I intended so I'm going to stop rambling.

Re: Ask HN: I am torn between whether I should do MBA or not. Thoughts?

#10
If you're already making the kind of money an MBA would doesn't seem like it makes a lot of sense. What's the point of paying lots of money and spending all that time to make the same as what you are now? You're salary will go up from real world experience and increased skills from working on the job too. In my experience, only really large companies where you probably don't want to work pay more as you get more degrees.
Post reply on HN