Live data from Hacker News

Tesla Wins Contract to Help Power the California Grid

bloomberg.com

191–200 of 218 posts

Re: Tesla Wins Contract to Help Power the California Grid

#191
post #156

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you trust the software industry to keep others' from turning off your refrigerator for the lulz?

Sensible price conscious refrigeration control would just be different temperature targets based on the price, not turning off the system. If l33t d00dz wanna make my milk one degree warmer, it's not a big deal.

You overestimate programming ability; people will find a way to fuck up.

Re: Tesla Wins Contract to Help Power the California Grid

#192

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> And that need standards for things like communication protocols. All that is needed is a way to get the spot price of electricity from the internet, similar to how I can get the current temperature in Anchorage. Devices don't need to talk to the power grid.

Moving electricity is "hard" so effectively there are many marketplaces in which the spot price is different. A natural design that's been considered/proposed is to get that info directly from the power utility itself.

If I can get the temperature online for my neighborhood (I can), then how can it be hard to get the local spot electricity price online? I don't see anything unnatural or difficult about this. No infrastructure changes are needed.

Re: Tesla Wins Contract to Help Power the California Grid

#193

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> And that need standards for things like communication protocols. All that is needed is a way to get the spot price of electricity from the internet, similar to how I can get the current temperature in Anchorage. Devices don't need to talk to the power grid.

If you're going to be billed by the minute, presumably you won't be taking meter readings manually, so your meter will be connected to some sort of communications network anyway. And if you're /not/ getting billed by the minute, what's in it for the buyer to choose an AC that sometimes turns itself off?

The power company has been upgrading the meters for years to support variable pricing so they can bill by the minute. None of what I've proposed is in any way a difficult or expensive problem to solve.

Of course, the power company having billing by the minute will then create the incentive for such an A/C. That's the whole point!

Re: Tesla Wins Contract to Help Power the California Grid

#194
post #165

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's a different beast. The price is high during those 15 minutes because of supply and demand. If you implement a smart grid that regulate load, you upset the supply and demand balance and the power might become so cheap that new self regulating systems are not worth the initial cost.

Once the smart-device interface is properly defined and the software is written, the hardware cost should not be a problem. You will end up with some kind of "smart device" router that connects to your internet/home network to talk to the power company, and uses a commodity wifi interface to talk to your smart devices. The cost of an ESP8266 is already sub-$7 at hobbyist volumes, you can expect the additional hardwar…

It is completely unnecessary for appliances to talk to the power company. They only need to talk to the internet. The power company just posts the spot price on a web site.

Re: Tesla Wins Contract to Help Power the California Grid

#195

Musk really does seem to be following his pattern of maximally engaging government contracts and subsidies. (That's not necessarily a criticism, just an observation, and one others have made before.)

The contract is with a publicly traded company...

https://www.google.com/finance?q=eix

Re: Tesla Wins Contract to Help Power the California Grid

#197
post #156

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sensible price conscious refrigeration control would just be different temperature targets based on the price, not turning off the system. If l33t d00dz wanna make my milk one degree warmer, it's not a big deal.

You overestimate programming ability; people will find a way to fuck up.

[deleted]

Re: Tesla Wins Contract to Help Power the California Grid

#198

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because the world we live in has certain types of people -- politicians, lawyers, business executives -- that don't solve problems for the world as in, "what is the most efficient way to accomplish this;" rather, they solve problems as in, "what is the most efficient way I can enrich myself. I guess it's maybe rational in a self-interested way--no longer do we live in a world of many competing tribes advancing oursel…

> certain types of people -- politicians, lawyers, business executives I forgot how altruistic software engineers, web developers and IT consultants were.

In a general sense is it not better for all people to be in he business of creating value than to quarrel over transferring it from one to another? I believe that if you care about human welfare, then it is obvious that it is.

Re: Tesla Wins Contract to Help Power the California Grid

#199

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Moving electricity is "hard" so effectively there are many marketplaces in which the spot price is different. A natural design that's been considered/proposed is to get that info directly from the power utility itself.

If I can get the temperature online for my neighborhood (I can), then how can it be hard to get the local spot electricity price online? I don't see anything unnatural or difficult about this. No infrastructure changes are needed.

What's the behavior of the system when the home cannot access the marketplace via their normal ISP? I think power utilities don't want to bind their QoS fate to a company outside of their control or specification.

Re: Tesla Wins Contract to Help Power the California Grid

#200
post #174

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This was brought up in a Fresh Air interview I listened to recently. Nowadays most of our devices use DC, and our grid is also on the verge of becoming much less centralized. You could reap some easy efficiency gains by omitting the DC-AC-DC conversion of a solar panel powering a house that charges a laptop.

DC sucks for transmission over more than a few meters. I'm thinking, even in a house, you still want AC in the walls.

can you explain a bit more?
Post reply on HN