Live data from Hacker News

Eating Vegetables Doesn’t Stop Cancer

well.blogs.nytimes.com

21–25 of 25 posts

Re: Eating Vegetables Doesn’t Stop Cancer

#21
post #5
post #3

Lowers risk of heart disease or stroke instead. Sounds good to me!

But that means people eating more fruit and vegetables will actually increase the cancer rate in the society, as fewer people die before they develop cancer (which is an almost inevitable event in an ageing body). Of course, this is related to the effect that you can double the number of people that suffer from a aggressive form of cancer by finding a treatment that makes them live twice as long after diagnosis (if y…

Thanks for finding the weirdly cynical lining to that cloud. You gave me a good laugh.

Re: Eating Vegetables Doesn’t Stop Cancer

#23
post #19

However, eating fruits and vegetables is still necessary for proper bodily function and general health. There is no better reason to eat fruits and vegetables than this. Cancer fighting is a sideshow, although an important one. There is also the potential benefit that if you eat more fruits and vegetables then you're less hungry for junk food.

> However, eating fruits and vegetables is still necessary for proper bodily function and general health. Tell that to (ancient) Inuit.

Hmmm ... interesting point.

Maybe it's: if you're not eating a total (ancient) Inuit diet, then fruits and vegetables combined with the relatively small amounts of protein and fats most other peoples eat is necessary ...

Hmmm

Re: Eating Vegetables Doesn’t Stop Cancer

#24
post #20
post #11

For those who've read The China Study , note that this is about increasing consumption of vegetables, not decreasing consumption of anything else (including animal protein).

Oh yes, the China Study. http://www.cholesterol-and-health.com/China-Study.html

FUD promoted by the well known Weston A Price foundation a very successful pusher of fat in our diets. While their motives aren't yet clear (diary&meat industry lobby) their methods are clear:

http://www.care2.com/causes/health-policy/blog/who-is-the-we...

Re: Eating Vegetables Doesn’t Stop Cancer

#25
post #24
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Oh yes, the China Study. http://www.cholesterol-and-health.com/China-Study.html

FUD promoted by the well known Weston A Price foundation a very successful pusher of fat in our diets. While their motives aren't yet clear (diary&meat industry lobby) their methods are clear: http://www.care2.com/causes/health-policy/blog/who-is-the-we...

Or you could say the China Study is vegetarian FUD backed by other lobbies (soy, grains, corn, etc).

By the way, nothing wrong with fat in our diets, unless is tran-fats or excess omega 6 PUFAs (typically seed oils). Please read Gary Taubes also.

Post reply on HN