Earlier quoted context omitted.
As the son of one who's in fact gotten even more abusive this year, as my father got early stage Alzheimer's, which to date is still a minor disability, to more comprehensively take out 57 years worth of grudges against him, to the point of the unforgivable, to the point I'm almost certain she wants him dead if she can arrange it through sins of omission.... Yes, there are people who you're technically that close to,…
Holy run-on sentences, Batman!
When does a daughter's duty end?
51–57 of 57 posts
Re: When does a daughter's duty end?
#52I think it's safe to say that her father was a dick but it's also highly unlikely anybody in that family is free from blame.
Re: When does a daughter's duty end?
#53Cool. You're former poor white trash with an Internet connection. If I wanted to hear this kind of sob story about how your family is dysfunctional there's plenty of people I can ask about their family. I think it's safe to say that her father was a dick but it's also highly unlikely anybody in that family is free from blame.
Re: When does a daughter's duty end?
#54Earlier quoted context omitted.
Holy run-on sentences, Batman!
Yeah, I know; in this case, a deliberate style choice not to break the flow most of the paragraphs. This isn't standard expository prose, I think it's allowed for the effect.
Re: When does a daughter's duty end?
#55Re: When does a daughter's duty end?
#56Are any of the people taking a hard line here ("She owes him nothing!") actually children of abusive parents?
Having the opinion that children don't (or shouldn't) owe their abusive parents anything, isn't in conflict with also having the opinion that they might feel differently. It is about freeing these children from moral and legal obligations and giving them the freedom to act in whatever way makes them happy and allows them to move on.
Re: When does a daughter's duty end?
#57> What exactly was my responsibility as a daughter? Is anyone so terrible that they deserve to die alone? And what would it say about me if I were willing to let that happen? Maybe I just don't get it. The answers to these questions are obvious and straight-forward. I wouldn't think twice about my responsibility to a person who molested me, beat my mom, and then "fucked off", let alone spend 4,000 words bloviating ab…
I will start from the beginning to explain why. Keep in mind, I will talk from the point of view of Asian cultures.
When you are a child, your world is limited to your parents. You listen to them because that's what you are told to do by everyone else. You love them because that's what you are told to do. My mother kept on telling me to go under a bus because I am dumb, or I was not good looking. She told me to always tell myself that I am stupid and dumb and I will never achieve anything in life. But yea, she loved me too, in her own way; atleast that's what I like to think. So its not been exactly an easy childhood for me.
In no way, I have undergone what the author has experienced. But had that happened to me, what would I have done ?
The answer is complicated. What about compassion ? What about forgiveness ? And keep in mind, I am an atheist. But what do I gain by letting someone die ? Nothing.
I take a step back and try to understand from their point of view. Why did they do what they did ? There is always a reason. Maybe the author's father experienced abuse or had a rough childhood too. Maybe he wasn't loved enough. Maybe love and understanding is all he needed. Or I maybe wrong on every count. Who knows ?
So I will try to forgive and be compassionate towards everyone. Maybe because I don't have the balls to stand up and defend myself. Or maybe those feelings do not come to me at all. All I know is this is what I can do and will keep on doing. And hope that one day, everyone is kind to each other.