Live data from Hacker News

Materialistic – Ad free, open source Hacker News client

play.google.com

31–40 of 100 posts

Re: Materialistic – Ad free, open source Hacker News client

#31

It's a nice app and I've been using it for some time, but one thing that's always bothered me is the strange scrolling / caching behavior of the app. A quick scroll down displays a blank page while content is gradually "plugged" in. I don't think I've ever seen this odd scrolling behavior in another app.

It's because stories/comments are loaded on demand. If you never scroll to it it won't be loaded. It was designed this way partly due to how HN API works, which doesn't provide all data up front.

Alternatively app can aggressively load everything up front, which is slow; or paginate content. To me it tends to feel faster when u have progressive UI change (empty card then fill it) than abrupt change (completely empty then all items appear), so I decided not to paginate.

Re: Materialistic – Ad free, open source Hacker News client

#33
post #12

It's definitely the most feature-rich HN client. Sad that something comparable is not on iOS :( (But the ones on iOS aren't bad..I've had the most luck with one called "Hacker News" by Premii)

MiniHack! Been using it for a couple of years. Easily the best native HN client on iOS.

I'd pay for Minihack on Android. All those Material apps waste space with the card paradigm and huge fonts.

Re: Materialistic – Ad free, open source Hacker News client

#34
As a counterpoint, I find the web version pretty great on iOS. Minimal JavaScript, loads fast, everything on one long screen, and the back button always works, leaving you exactly where you left off.

It is a nice counterpoint to overly heavy web that we have unfortunately gravitated towards.

Re: Materialistic – Ad free, open source Hacker News client

#35
post #32

Its a great app. A couple of things that would make it even better: - a refresh button - an "are you sure you want to quit" warning when I click the back button.

+1 A per-story refresh button is badly needed so that the comments of only that story can be refreshed.

Re: Materialistic – Ad free, open source Hacker News client

#37
post #32

Its a great app. A couple of things that would make it even better: - a refresh button - an "are you sure you want to quit" warning when I click the back button.

+1 A per-story refresh button is badly needed so that the comments of only that story can be refreshed.

Single story refresh is a nice idea. I just added it to my backlog. Thanks!

Re: Materialistic – Ad free, open source Hacker News client

#38

Materialistic is the only way I access Hacker News. But it would be awesome if the developer took some inspiration from the Reddit client Relay ( https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=reddit.news ) too :) Great job hidro!

Thanks! I have incorporated the idea of on-screen navigation button and grouping setting options. What else you think I should consider from Relay?

Re: Materialistic – Ad free, open source Hacker News client

#39
post #19

What does the word "Materialistic" have to do with Hacker News? I did a web search to see if I'm missing something, but it looks like it's just a name that does not fit. How about "Hacker News client by Trung", or "Trung HN" for short.

When I created it material design was a hot thing, so I just randomly came up with that name. Now it's not relevant anymore but I keep the name to avoid confusion for existing users.

You might consider updating the name to something like "Materialistic for Hacker News" so it's more clear and easy to find.

Re: Materialistic – Ad free, open source Hacker News client

#40

As a counterpoint, I find the web version pretty great on iOS. Minimal JavaScript, loads fast, everything on one long screen, and the back button always works, leaving you exactly where you left off. It is a nice counterpoint to overly heavy web that we have unfortunately gravitated towards.

I've been doing the same on Android for a some time now. Before HN was responsive, I preferred native apps for presentation, but the good ones lacked voting, commenting, etc. Honestly the web client is quite usable on mobile now.
Post reply on HN