Live data from Hacker News

What is the biggest mistake that a big company has made?

quora.com

21–30 of 76 posts

Re: What is the biggest mistake that a big company has made?

#21
post #9

1. Yahoo not buying Google? 2. Yahoo rejecting the Microsoft offer? Glad (1) didn't happen though. Pretty sure they'd have screwed it all up for everyone.

If Google would be bought by Yahoo then probably we would forgot about Google by this time. Then that would be the biggest blunder for Google.

Re: What is the biggest mistake that a big company has made?

#22
The Scottish Darien Company attempted to establish a colony in Panama in the late 1600s, to compete with England. Backed by almost half the money in Scotland, they completely failed at establishing a colony, lied about it, got more money and settlers who then also utterly failed at establishing a colony, almost started a war with Spain, bankrupted Scotland, and set the stage for Scotland to be absorbed into the United Kingdom in 1706.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darien_scheme

Re: What is the biggest mistake that a big company has made?

#23
post #13
post #8

Blockbuster passing on the Netflix purchase... Yahoo! passing on Google...

Alright, these are existential mistakes up there with Decca. I still chuckle when I think about Yahoo's total market cap being less than the value of their share in Alibaba. The market determined that Yahoo! had negative worth. Ouch!

AFAICT, that delta was because there was high probability that Yahoo would have to pay tax on the profits if it tried to sell Alibaba, not because the market determined that Yahoo! had negative worth.

Re: What is the biggest mistake that a big company has made?

#24
post #2

As recently as 2009, Nokia was estimated by Interbrand to be one of the top 5 global brands [1]. Interbrand's guesstimate at the monetary value rated "Nokia" as being worth over two times as much as "Apple". Just four years later, in 2013, Nokia had lost 80% of its value and Apple's brand was estimated to be worth about 13 times more. Such a tremendous collapse for a global brand seems unprecedented. (And no, it wasn…

[deleted]

Re: What is the biggest mistake that a big company has made?

#25
post #7

This one is easy: Decca recording turning down the Beatles. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Beatles%27_Decca_auditio... "We don't like their sound, and guitar groups are on the way out." Sort of like Adidas turning down Michael Jordan for not being tall enough, except that Adidas is still in business.

I doubt few if any of the people that we think of as icons today had the fortune of being immediately accepted.

Elvis was rejected by nearly everone, JK Rowling's Harry Potter was rejected by a slew of publishers.. basically everyone who is currently famous has these stories, and often many of them.

The lesson though, is that the key to success is perseverance.

Re: What is the biggest mistake that a big company has made?

#26
>I feel that large companies back in the 90's didn't care about any of their workers all they cared about was making money .

I'd suggest that companies of the 1990s had nothing on 1930s-1940s IBM: IBM allied itself with the Third Reich to develop technology (punch card databases) as a key facilitator of the mass identification, enslavement and genocide of millions of people. They also backed another horse in that gruesome episode, creating the punch card database key to running FDR's Japanese internment camps in the western United States.

http://www.ibmandtheholocaust.com/

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_during_World_War_II

Re: What is the biggest mistake that a big company has made?

#27
IG Farben entanglement with the Nazi regime. They ended up being part of countless deaths and the company was declared by the Allies to be too morally corrupt to be allowed to exist and broken up after the war. Their successor companies AGFA, BASF, Bayer and Sanofi are all still big today, so IG Farben could have been a massive conglomerates if they have acted differently.

This was also not just a business failure where one lost money. IG Farben participated directly on some of the worst crimes in human history.

More: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IG_Farben

Re: What is the biggest mistake that a big company has made?

#28
I always remember the company who lost all it's assets in one day due to a deployment bug to one of their servers. They were a high frequency trading company, so seconds/minutes to them were obscenely expensive.

I feel a cold pit in my stomach putting myself in the shoes of the developer that did the `cap deploy` that day. Yikes!

Re: What is the biggest mistake that a big company has made?

#29

I'm a little surprised to see no mention of Osbourne computers. The name lives on with the Osbourne Effect: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Osborne_Computer_Corporation#T... This is why, even today, big companies don't announce when a new product will be available until the last minute as to not cannibalize sales from the current production run.

Except Osborne admitted in a Wall Street Journal article that he made up that excuse for their failure. It's been so long I can't remember the details of the real reason, but it was the general sort of thing that companies like that screwed up.
Post reply on HN