Live data from Hacker News

New Virus Breaks the Rules of Infection

npr.org

121–130 of 135 posts

Re: New Virus Breaks the Rules of Infection

#121

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This isn't on topic and has been discussed many times before

This comment is also off-topic.

Indeed. But I'm not derailing an entire conversation. The conversation has been derailed already. I'm just pointing out that these comments about hot button issues, that rehash the same stuff again and again, are annoying to some users, especially since they appear quite unpredictably.

Re: New Virus Breaks the Rules of Infection

#122
post #93

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's more that NPR's write-ups are usually quite good.

Seems like whenever NPR reports on subjects I happen to know really really well I find myself disappointed. Makes me wonder about the rest of their reporting.

NPR is almost as bad as CNN and such, but it's marketed towards intellectuals through linguistics. I noticed whenever they speak on a topic I'm deeply familiar with, they use overly-complicated wordage to get the point across while missing important details. Almost like how "over-designed" websites usually have terrible backends.

Re: New Virus Breaks the Rules of Infection

#123
post #93

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's more that NPR's write-ups are usually quite good.

Seems like whenever NPR reports on subjects I happen to know really really well I find myself disappointed. Makes me wonder about the rest of their reporting.

"Not quite up to the standards of a topic expert" is still a damn sight better than most science reporting.

Re: New Virus Breaks the Rules of Infection

#124
post #94
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You don't even need to wipe out all mosquitoes - just a few species (something like 6 out of 300) account for the vast majority of disease transmitted.

Agreed. Mosquitoes are important pollinators and necessary members of our food chain, we would be hurting without their help. Only reproducing females require a blood meal, further complicating the issue. To that end, check out this [0] anti-mosquito laser weapon, which they claim can be tuned to target only females based on wing beat frequencies. While I disagree with the principal, a laser mosquito defense system g…

I've seen it firsthand. It's not very impressive, sadly.

Re: New Virus Breaks the Rules of Infection

#126
post #117
post #95

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As in the do more harm than good to the ecosystem.

So just like humans?

Ecosystem does not care, it just is. So far it seems that humans are the only entities in the ecosystem that care. Hell, the "bad" and "good" state of the ecosystem is defined as its ability to support human life and growth.

Re: New Virus Breaks the Rules of Infection

#127
post #98

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"their legal fiduciary duty is to maximize profits" actually is not true. Although it's of course a very common motive.

I would tone the statement down, but it's still true that the number one purpose of a for-profit business is to generate profit. All other activity, in general, is secondary to profit. It's like saying a human doesn't need to eat. Sure, sometimes healthy people go without food to achieve a goal, and a few rare people sacrifice themselves for the common good. But these people are exceptions to the rule. It might more…

I don't think that's true at all. In the UK at least I believe there is some expectation that a limited company will return profits to shareholders, but besides that the shareholders and directors can set the priorities of the company to be anything they want.

If you know of anything to the contrary I would be very interested to hear it!

Re: New Virus Breaks the Rules of Infection

#128

Why if instead of spending money researching the diseases that mosquitos could transmit to humans on the future we spend all that money into figuring out a way to exterminate all mosquitos from the surface of earth once and for all? As someone who lives on a tropical country and had have both Dengue and Chikungunya I can attest mosquitos are pure evil, and there are several researchs suggesting they serve no purpose…

Yes, after the War on Drugs and the War on Terror, we need a War on Mosquitoes. It'd be a much better allocation than the other wars and much more beneficial for humanity. I can already picture the SWAT teams running with their electrical mosquito swatters :-)

I think we already had one... back in the 60's. DDT use was widespread worldwide. My Dad even used it at our cottage... best summer ever, next to no mosquitoes. Unfortunately DDT has a big impact on birds... softens the eggshell such that eggs don't hatch/grow. DDT is outlawed in a lot of places... but by no means all.

We almost won the war on mosquitoes but our allies the birds would have been wiped out if we'd kept fighting :)

Re: New Virus Breaks the Rules of Infection

#129
post #46

Why if instead of spending money researching the diseases that mosquitos could transmit to humans on the future we spend all that money into figuring out a way to exterminate all mosquitos from the surface of earth once and for all? As someone who lives on a tropical country and had have both Dengue and Chikungunya I can attest mosquitos are pure evil, and there are several researchs suggesting they serve no purpose…

We generally arent trying to cure diseases. I mean, individual researchers want to find cures (e.g. the dedicated clinician who went to med school because her mother had breast cancer, the passionate hacker who eschewed private buses and free lunches at some startup to work at a research institute) Generally though, the pressure of the overall system is to make as much money as possible. If you cure someone's disease…

>We generally arent trying to cure diseases.

Exactly. Now consider that a vaccine is a medicine for a healthy person.

Re: New Virus Breaks the Rules of Infection

#130
post #94

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Agreed. Mosquitoes are important pollinators and necessary members of our food chain, we would be hurting without their help. Only reproducing females require a blood meal, further complicating the issue. To that end, check out this [0] anti-mosquito laser weapon, which they claim can be tuned to target only females based on wing beat frequencies. While I disagree with the principal, a laser mosquito defense system g…

I've seen it firsthand. It's not very impressive, sadly.

Yeah, but how often does an anti-missile researcher go homicidal on mosquitoes with a laser? :) The idea was neat at least.
Post reply on HN