Live data from Hacker News

From Chrome Apps to the Web

blog.chromium.org

21–30 of 111 posts

Re: From Chrome Apps to the Web

#21

Does this have any effect on the seemingly small pool of games in the Chrome Store? Has anybody actually made money from that market?

It is possible to make some money on there. If you own a Chromebook with Chrome OS, it's the only place to get software. There is a torrent app for sale on the Chrome store for £1.89 and has over 50k installs: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/jstorrent/anhdpjpo...

do 50k installs of this app equal 50k sales?

Re: From Chrome Apps to the Web

#22
post #3

I've always been somewhat confused by chrome apps. How do (did) they differentiate themselves from extensions? Even Google seemed unsure about that as Hangouts has been available as both an extension as well as an app for quite some time. As a user I'm really glad to see this move, along with the move towards android apps on Chrome OS since I'm hoping it will unify the Google-driven ecosystem a bit more.

Chrome apps can have extensive permissions that web platform does not provide.

- Full TCP/UDP socket support (AFAIK this is never coming to the web platform)

- Bluetooth support (Web platform is getting this, though)

- Filesystem support (e.g. get persistent read/write access to user selected directory. Web platform probably won't get this)

Notably the socket and filesystem permissions are not available to extensions. Most of the other permissions though are available in extensions.

https://developer.chrome.com/apps/api_index

Re: From Chrome Apps to the Web

#23
This is going to be really annoying since hardware access from HTML5 is still very rough and not even standardized. Stuff like talking to a serial port isn't even on the radar (so good luck programming a board like BBC micro:bit, Arduino, etc. without a native app), and efforts like WebUSB are still extremely early and not even a full standard. I feel like the product managers making this decision are completely oblivious to the major gaps between chrome app support & HTML5 support. This line in particular is basically a giant middle finger to folks in this situation: "Developers who can’t fully move their apps to the web can help us prioritize new APIs to fill the gaps left by Chrome apps."

So in short, Google proves once again to _never_ take a bet on their technology.

Re: From Chrome Apps to the Web

#24
post #22
post #3

I've always been somewhat confused by chrome apps. How do (did) they differentiate themselves from extensions? Even Google seemed unsure about that as Hangouts has been available as both an extension as well as an app for quite some time. As a user I'm really glad to see this move, along with the move towards android apps on Chrome OS since I'm hoping it will unify the Google-driven ecosystem a bit more.

Chrome apps can have extensive permissions that web platform does not provide. - Full TCP/UDP socket support (AFAIK this is never coming to the web platform) - Bluetooth support (Web platform is getting this, though) - Filesystem support (e.g. get persistent read/write access to user selected directory. Web platform probably won't get this) Notably the socket and filesystem permissions are not available to extensions…

I will add HID API support, that apps have and extensions don't.

https://developer.chrome.com/apps/hid

Re: From Chrome Apps to the Web

#25

Does this have any effect on the seemingly small pool of games in the Chrome Store? Has anybody actually made money from that market?

It is possible to make some money on there. If you own a Chromebook with Chrome OS, it's the only place to get software. There is a torrent app for sale on the Chrome store for £1.89 and has over 50k installs: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/jstorrent/anhdpjpo...

That's 50k weekly active users.

Re: From Chrome Apps to the Web

#27
So what are developers of existing paid Chrome packaged apps suppose to do for existing users?

"Starting in late 2016, newly-published Chrome apps will only be available to users on Chrome OS."

As someone who has been building a Chrome app this sudden change with a lack of notice has made me very nervous.

Re: From Chrome Apps to the Web

#29
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is possible to make some money on there. If you own a Chromebook with Chrome OS, it's the only place to get software. There is a torrent app for sale on the Chrome store for £1.89 and has over 50k installs: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/jstorrent/anhdpjpo...

do 50k installs of this app equal 50k sales?

I don't know but there is no free version at the moment. Looking at the updates in the description it mentions that they will refund any unsatisfied customers, that was in 2013 so it was for sale back then too.

Re: From Chrome Apps to the Web

#30

So what are developers of existing paid Chrome packaged apps suppose to do for existing users? "Starting in late 2016, newly-published Chrome apps will only be available to users on Chrome OS." As someone who has been building a Chrome app this sudden change with a lack of notice has made me very nervous.

The post said existing apps will continue to stay in the store for the next few years at least. So you have at least a few years to adapt.
Post reply on HN