Live data from Hacker News

Uber’s First Self-Driving Fleet Arrives in Pittsburgh This Month

bloomberg.com

171–180 of 244 posts

Re: Uber’s First Self-Driving Fleet Arrives in Pittsburgh This Month

#171
post #67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What makes this stop sign a challenge?

In most places, when you merge onto a highway you have a ramp of decent length with a yield sign. You are able to get up to speed and merge safely. In this particular spot, the end of your on-ramp has a stop sign. So, you're sitting at a dead stop with 65+ mph traffic 10 ft in front of you. Things get even more complicated since you're merging into an exit ramp. You have approximately 1/4 mile of road to merge into t…

Why is there a stop sigh?! Isn't that a usual merge/exit pattern?

Re: Uber’s First Self-Driving Fleet Arrives in Pittsburgh This Month

#172
post #58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Give me a car which self-drives for 4 months of the year, and requires me to drive it the other 8 months. That's still a massive advantage over the car I currently own.

Indeed but the context here are all the futuristic predictions starting with mass-unemployment of taxi and truck drivers (indeed that's what Uber is selling their market valuation on). If drivers are still needed 60% of the time, they're going nowhere. The hype right now is so great that even if the reality is amazing it will be disappointing.

> If drivers are still needed 60% of the time, they're going nowhere.

Think about what you're saying here. If manual driving is still required 60% of the time there will still be mass-unemployment of taxi and truck drivers. These guys are not paid well enough that they can afford half the amount of income that they currently have.

Re: Uber’s First Self-Driving Fleet Arrives in Pittsburgh This Month

#173

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Indeed but the context here are all the futuristic predictions starting with mass-unemployment of taxi and truck drivers (indeed that's what Uber is selling their market valuation on). If drivers are still needed 60% of the time, they're going nowhere. The hype right now is so great that even if the reality is amazing it will be disappointing.

The disruptive effects still happen even if we don't get to 100%. For example, a train of self driving trucks can be led by 1 in the front. Yes, I know, REAL trains exist, but they don't go everywhere. A train of self driving trucks could save a lot of money. If self driving Taxis don't work in the rain, then Uber can just NOT drive them when it is raining! For example, Maybe the penetration rate will be very low in…

They still have to work in the rain before gov't allows them on the road though..

Re: Uber’s First Self-Driving Fleet Arrives in Pittsburgh This Month

#174
post #62

How dare you say that. Don't you know that every single job is legally required to provide you with enough money to support a family of six while living in the Bay Area and driving Escalades?

We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12311880 and marked it off-topic. Please don't derail threads with unsubstantive inflammatory comments.

Re: Uber’s First Self-Driving Fleet Arrives in Pittsburgh This Month

#175
post #112

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"As a person within the industry" has there been any talk about the paths driverless will take? New roadways? Attendant-less roadways? Change in existing designation of highways? How to accomodate 10-20 people (vehicles won't look like they do now)? I envision future photos-videos of driver and driver less "vehicles" at a busy intersection just like horses and early cars.

These are the right questions to be asking! Yes, there has been some talk -- but not remotely enough. At present, the vast majority of work in the vehicle-automation space is being done by, well, vehicle people. The assumption is that driverless vehicles will slot into the existing infrastructure with minimal modification. There's a fair amount of consideration being given to vehicle-to-infrastructure communications…

Take the Las Vegas Strip for example. They have a lot of pedestrian bridges for people to avoid crossing streets. Granted, this also works to funnel folks into casinos. However, it would be difficult for a pedestrian to get into the street at some intersections because of fences and barricades. I have to think that most cities will evolve similarly when self-driving cars become commonplace

Re: Uber’s First Self-Driving Fleet Arrives in Pittsburgh This Month

#176
post #15

Ubiquitous comment, as a person within the industry: there's a big difference between cars that have a hands-free driving mode, and cars that do not have a driver. The latter will be an absolute game-changer; the former can yield some marginal gains in safety and congestion, but does not really shatter any paradigms. This is the former. The latter will certainly happen eventually, but is orders of magnitude more chal…

>Ubiquitous comment, as a person within the industry: there's a big difference between cars that have a hands-free driving mode, and cars that do not have a driver. Surely the pay is far less for the passive driver? If not I assume it will be soon.

Solution: pay drivers a bonus for the number of 'accidents avoided', or the amount of times they need to grab the wheel after the car sounds the 'take-the-wheel' ping. Drivers will be incentivized to pick-up passengers in more complex areas, which then improves the data and the car learns how to drive better in complex area.

Re: Uber’s First Self-Driving Fleet Arrives in Pittsburgh This Month

#177
post #7

I wonder how Uber drivers feel about working for a company that is actively trying to make them obsolete. Not passing judgement or anything, just kind of a strange thing to contemplate.. Uber kept saying they were disrupting the taxi industry by letting more people participate when really in the end they're trying to remove the people from the equation altogether.

People may yet make a comeback as a premium service since they can do things that self-driving cars can't like help a passenger carry bags.

Wouldn't that be a destination service? There is no need to carry a person/bot that is just needed at the endpoint.

Re: Uber’s First Self-Driving Fleet Arrives in Pittsburgh This Month

#178
This is a no-lose situation for Uber.

If it goes well, then Uber has suddenly pushed forward autonomous driving and set itself at the forefront of commercial adoption.

If it is a disaster and many accidents result, Uber will set back driverless cars by a decade, burying it under a wave of pessimism, allowing their current business model to persist well into the future.

Re: Uber’s First Self-Driving Fleet Arrives in Pittsburgh This Month

#179
post #7

I wonder how Uber drivers feel about working for a company that is actively trying to make them obsolete. Not passing judgement or anything, just kind of a strange thing to contemplate.. Uber kept saying they were disrupting the taxi industry by letting more people participate when really in the end they're trying to remove the people from the equation altogether.

I always talk to the drivers about their feelings and so on when taking Uber. Maybe my data is skewed but most accept it as inevitable and are not worried much as they have other side jobs. The cab drivers are the ones who must be anxious. It will be really bad if they cannot be retrained for other jobs as it will add to the existing frustration around automation. We simply cannot afford to leave people out as we mov…

> Humanity cannot progress by leaving people behind.

You're way overestimating the value our civilization places on an individual human life, doubly so if they're unexceptional and male.

And that's even more true for less developed societies. The sanctity and preciousness of human life and desire to avoid suffering and achieve equal outcomes is a relatively new concept, unique to the developed nations of post WWII era.

Re: Uber’s First Self-Driving Fleet Arrives in Pittsburgh This Month

#180
post #140

> "Supervised by humans in the drivers seat" Ah, borrowing from the Musk marketing playbook, just say "self-driving" often enough, and enough uninformed people who have never seen contemporary luxury assisted-driving features will be impressed. Calling out Autopilot as "souped-up cruise control" is a nice touch. > For now, Uber’s test cars travel with safety drivers, as common sense and the law dictate. These profess…

The level of autonomy exhibited by these vehicles are much greater than that of the Model S

Can you elaborate? What driving maneuvers do you expect these vehicles to be able to perform? Where is that feature set documented?
Post reply on HN