Live data from Hacker News

Rate Limits

letsencrypt.org

1–10 of 121 posts

Re: Rate Limits

#2
What I personally find more inconvenient than any of those limits (as a non-power user) is the 3 month lifetime of certs. I am a windows user. Running a VM once a month just to renew my 3 certs is a huge headache. Will it really be that much of a burden to have like a year?

Not to mention the whole process is so very incredibly fugly. For something as important as it is why is there not an official online UI to manage certs? I know of atleast one online client that does exactly that but it's not official. We need the process to be as simple as making a facebook account for example. I am not very knowledgeable in certificates btw, so I may be just about to have a duh'oh moment..

Edit: Forgot to mention, I can't use auto renew scripts because my sites run on shared hosting and I don't have any kind of command line access. I have to manually upload certificates via cpanel.

Re: Rate Limits

#3
post #2

What I personally find more inconvenient than any of those limits (as a non-power user) is the 3 month lifetime of certs. I am a windows user. Running a VM once a month just to renew my 3 certs is a huge headache. Will it really be that much of a burden to have like a year? Not to mention the whole process is so very incredibly fugly. For something as important as it is why is there not an official online UI to manag…

I'm pretty sure there are letsencrypt windows clients. Which you can run every week to make sure they auto-renew. And you could do this as well by running the VM regularly, automatically.

The point of letsencrypt is to have auto-renewed certificates. It's intended to force you to automate the process.

Re: Rate Limits

#4
post #3
post #2

What I personally find more inconvenient than any of those limits (as a non-power user) is the 3 month lifetime of certs. I am a windows user. Running a VM once a month just to renew my 3 certs is a huge headache. Will it really be that much of a burden to have like a year? Not to mention the whole process is so very incredibly fugly. For something as important as it is why is there not an official online UI to manag…

I'm pretty sure there are letsencrypt windows clients. Which you can run every week to make sure they auto-renew. And you could do this as well by running the VM regularly, automatically. The point of letsencrypt is to have auto-renewed certificates. It's intended to force you to automate the process.

I can't run those scripts. My site runs on shared hosting, I don't have command line access. All I have is a file manager for my 'htdocs' and standard cpanel stuff.

Re: Rate Limits

#5
post #2

What I personally find more inconvenient than any of those limits (as a non-power user) is the 3 month lifetime of certs. I am a windows user. Running a VM once a month just to renew my 3 certs is a huge headache. Will it really be that much of a burden to have like a year? Not to mention the whole process is so very incredibly fugly. For something as important as it is why is there not an official online UI to manag…

We could very easily make the cert lifetimes one year, or anything else. We chose 90 days for the reasons outlined here:

https://letsencrypt.org/2015/11/09/why-90-days.html

Additionally, long cert lifetimes are dangerous because revocation is ineffective and things like heartbleed happen.

Re: Rate Limits

#6
post #2

What I personally find more inconvenient than any of those limits (as a non-power user) is the 3 month lifetime of certs. I am a windows user. Running a VM once a month just to renew my 3 certs is a huge headache. Will it really be that much of a burden to have like a year? Not to mention the whole process is so very incredibly fugly. For something as important as it is why is there not an official online UI to manag…

>Running a VM once a month just to renew my 3 certs is a huge headache.

Not overly familiar with Windows administration (or the tools available to work with SSL/TLS stuff), but you can use Docker to automate basically all of that; IIRC it's supported on Windows now.

>Not to mention the whole process is so very incredibly fugly.

On the contrary, the process is pretty simple, even if you're going fully manual!

1. Generate a CSR for the domains you want to register

2. Place a proof of ownership somewhere on your server in a way that Let's Encrypt can verify it's there

3. Contact LE's API and tell it what domains you want to register, what you want to get signed, and where your proof is

4. Get a signed cert back. The rest is just server configuration to point to the cert.

If you use something like `certbot-auto`, it's basically a GUI step-through process.

Re: Rate Limits

#7
post #2

What I personally find more inconvenient than any of those limits (as a non-power user) is the 3 month lifetime of certs. I am a windows user. Running a VM once a month just to renew my 3 certs is a huge headache. Will it really be that much of a burden to have like a year? Not to mention the whole process is so very incredibly fugly. For something as important as it is why is there not an official online UI to manag…

> What I find more inconvenient than any of those limits (as a non-power user) is the 3 month lifetime of certs. I am a windows user. Running a VM once a month just to renew my 3 certs is a huge headache. Will it really be that much of a burden to have like a year?

You shouldn't do anything by hand to renew certificates. The short certificate lifetime encourages you to automate the process.

Clients exist for Windows, and web servers exist for Windows that include native support for ACME and Let's Encrypt.

Re: Rate Limits

#8
post #4
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm pretty sure there are letsencrypt windows clients. Which you can run every week to make sure they auto-renew. And you could do this as well by running the VM regularly, automatically. The point of letsencrypt is to have auto-renewed certificates. It's intended to force you to automate the process.

I can't run those scripts. My site runs on shared hosting, I don't have command line access. All I have is a file manager for my 'htdocs' and standard cpanel stuff.

So... this is less an issue with Let's Encrypt and more an issue with restrictions imposed by cPanel and your choice of host.

Re: Rate Limits

#9
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I can't run those scripts. My site runs on shared hosting, I don't have command line access. All I have is a file manager for my 'htdocs' and standard cpanel stuff.

So... this is less an issue with Let's Encrypt and more an issue with restrictions imposed by cPanel and your choice of host.

In fact isn't shared hosting the most common type of hosting? Any larger sites can afford paid certs anyways so letsencrypt is especially suited for smaller sites like mine, that can't afford the cert but also don't have the luxury of a dedicated machine/vps.

Re: Rate Limits

#10
post #4
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm pretty sure there are letsencrypt windows clients. Which you can run every week to make sure they auto-renew. And you could do this as well by running the VM regularly, automatically. The point of letsencrypt is to have auto-renewed certificates. It's intended to force you to automate the process.

I can't run those scripts. My site runs on shared hosting, I don't have command line access. All I have is a file manager for my 'htdocs' and standard cpanel stuff.

FWIW, cPanel just announced Let's Encrypt integration with their AutoSSL feature: https://blog.cpanel.com/announcing-cpanel-whms-official-lets...
Post reply on HN