Live data from Hacker News

IPad screenshots make this thing seem less like a giant iPhone

engadget.com

11–20 of 41 posts

Re: IPad screenshots make this thing seem less like a giant iPhone

#11
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Increasing screen real-estate has a non-linear effect on lots of UIs.

Example?

I am not sure, and nobody can be, but isn't the web an example? When the most common resolution was 800x600 the graphical interface patterns were really bleh.

Re: IPad screenshots make this thing seem less like a giant iPhone

#13
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Example?

I am not sure, and nobody can be, but isn't the web an example? When the most common resolution was 800x600 the graphical interface patterns were really bleh.

This is a good point.

Sorry, I accidentally downvoted you while trying to upvote on my G1. Kind of ironic given the discussion.

Re: IPad screenshots make this thing seem less like a giant iPhone

#14
post #2

Most people that have handled an iPad dismiss that it's just a larger iPod Touch - the old axiom a picture is worth a thousand words certainly applies here. For education / gaming / medicine / industrial / etc etc the apps we see for this format are going to be incredible.

> For education / gaming / medicine / industrial / etc etc the apps we see for this format are going to be incredible.

I wonder how long Apple will be able to sustain the advantage though. In a year or so when Android tablets are available, I'd predict that any new medicine or industry projects would be more inclined to use an open-source tablet.

If I were building, say, an e-ticket redemption system for events, and I decided to use off-the-shelf hardware, I would much prefer to build it on Android than iPhone or iPad simply because I would have more control of the devices and not be stuck with a single hardware supplier.

Re: IPad screenshots make this thing seem less like a giant iPhone

#16
post #14
post #2

Most people that have handled an iPad dismiss that it's just a larger iPod Touch - the old axiom a picture is worth a thousand words certainly applies here. For education / gaming / medicine / industrial / etc etc the apps we see for this format are going to be incredible.

> For education / gaming / medicine / industrial / etc etc the apps we see for this format are going to be incredible. I wonder how long Apple will be able to sustain the advantage though. In a year or so when Android tablets are available, I'd predict that any new medicine or industry projects would be more inclined to use an open-source tablet. If I were building, say, an e-ticket redemption system for events, and…

"I'd predict that any new medicine or industry projects would be more inclined to use an open-source tablet."

Really? What % of those industries have done that with operating systems and other past decisions?

Re: IPad screenshots make this thing seem less like a giant iPhone

#17
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> For education / gaming / medicine / industrial / etc etc the apps we see for this format are going to be incredible. I wonder how long Apple will be able to sustain the advantage though. In a year or so when Android tablets are available, I'd predict that any new medicine or industry projects would be more inclined to use an open-source tablet. If I were building, say, an e-ticket redemption system for events, and…

"I'd predict that any new medicine or industry projects would be more inclined to use an open-source tablet." Really? What % of those industries have done that with operating systems and other past decisions?

what % of those industries have used Macs in the past? There's a reason for that.

The Android tablets have advantages, that are only indirectly caused by open source. Having a lot more control over the software, hardware and not to be beholden to a single supplier is invaluable in industrial use.

Re: IPad screenshots make this thing seem less like a giant iPhone

#18
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Example?

I am not sure, and nobody can be, but isn't the web an example? When the most common resolution was 800x600 the graphical interface patterns were really bleh.

IMO Web pages wider than 800px generally use the extra space for junk or whitespace.

Re: IPad screenshots make this thing seem less like a giant iPhone

#20
post #2

Most people that have handled an iPad dismiss that it's just a larger iPod Touch - the old axiom a picture is worth a thousand words certainly applies here. For education / gaming / medicine / industrial / etc etc the apps we see for this format are going to be incredible.

"Most people that have handled an iPad dismiss that it's just a larger iPod Touch"

Is that a typo ("have handled" -> "haven't handled")? Because reports of actual hands-on use I've read have been glowing.

First example I found from google:

    The iPad is something to be held and experienced,
    because so many of its advantages are tactile:
    how it feels in the hand, of course, but also how
    the software responds. (Where our opinions differ,
    we break them out.)
- http://db.tidbits.com/article/10960
Post reply on HN